Forum Moderators: open

Message Too Old, No Replies

Why has the Advertising/Affiliate section faded

A suggested answer

         

Michael Anthony

9:36 pm on Jan 27, 2007 (gmt 0)



Q: Why does the Advertising Sales & Affiliates Programs forum get so little posting these days?

A: Because anyone offering sound advice based on experience gets accused of self promotion and has all their posts deleted.

Q: But surely someone who knows what they are doing helping others through a free forum is a good thing?

A: I'd tend to agree, but you'll notice that most of the people that used to post helpful tips and advice have not posted here for ages

Q: Why is that?

A: I think that they found it a little disheartening to spend hours typing up helpful posts and see all their hard work deleted by the moderators

Q: So what is the point of this forum now?

A: It's OK if you want to find spam, or if you are bored and want to obsess about spyware or other people stealing your traffic

Q: But I want to learn about Advertising Sales & Affiliate Programs?

A: Sorry, we can't help. We're not allowed to say anything real.

No offnce, but WebmasterWorld moderators, if you are reading this, do me the courtesy of explaning your draconian logic on here, in public, so that I and others can understand exactly how it all works.

We've spent years helping people on here and used to find it a great place to come and share ideas - these days it's as dead as a duck. Seems like a real shame, don't we all agree?

Leosghost

12:06 am on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



well just to be obliging and to save you staying up late to wait for the inevitable ..

so ..lets dissect ..ripping apart has no finesse and I'm fussy what I get on my clothes and hands ( Mrs Leosghost who come from franchise immobilier and marketing in another place ..and thinks you guys are so old school ..gives me hell when I get nasties under the bridge ) ..so I'll be delicate ....might even warm me 'ands ;-)

1.

Oh no, one of those supposed "self promoters"

no, precious ;-)..you promote mr anthony ..who one presumes gives you a cut of all new recruits if you actually manage the tag team succesfully enough to generate any ..

( cleans hands ..back to dissection )

2.

There is a THICK grey line between promotion and educating...

mais non mr wray luv ;-)..the only thing "thick" here is that you still havent got that we are are not so "thick " as to fall for your routine ..

( cleans hands ..again ..back to dissection ..Mrs Leosghost is gonna be cross wiv I )

3.

I guess there is no limits as to how brown your nose can get?{

sorry ..cant here you mr anthonys greater intestine ..where you appear to be posting from ..is muffling your words

( cleans hands ..and screen ..again ..back to dissection ..Mrs Leosghost wants to know since when WebmasterWorld became askat forum ..I said dunno ..see mr wrays join date )

4.

I was genuinely intersted in the subject

two part reply ..
a) pull the other one it's got bells on ;-)
b) if you need to ask ..you shouldnt be a "headmaster" ..unless you are running out of "students" to the point where you no longer "'ave enough "students" to 'ave a statically large enough sample to base your ebook on ..

( cleans hands ..on ebook ..burns lovely ..warms hands )

5.

hot thread

time share speak ..

( steralised hands in flames from ebook ..burns well ..has at least one use )

6.

when someone posted and merely mentionned that I had done well because of my affiliation with him,

see #4a ..above .. :-)

( steralised hands in flames from ebook ..burns well ..desert tribes know that camelsh*t burns well ..so apparently does electronic BS )

7.

but once a few self-righteous, trusted, old school forum posters didn't like what they "percieved" as promotion, it was shut down.
dunno about that guv ..I'm a semi domesticated nordic mythical whossit ..come closer to being IP banned here more times than you ( if we are getting into cred and pissing contests and all ;-)..but I got me this motive meter ..fixed now ( but you're banging the stops on the BS one too ..ya lil devil you ;-).. maybe others can tell that a good thread suddenly went rotten ..due to the presence of something lurking beneath the surface ..who nose ..? some things just smell funny ..there's roses ..and there's attar of roses ..;-)

( dont need to clean hands ..cos wrote attar of roses ..;-) )

8.

It's true that the forum offers almost no good information anymore. I can say that truthfully

sorry read that bit and had to replace me keyboard ..Mrs Leosghost is gonna make me clean that up me'sen for sure ..

was gonna say somethin else ..but TOS wont let me ..:(( ..can think it tho ;-) ..just like every one else is ;-))

( dont need to clean hands .visted TOS ..it's clean there )

9.

Due to overmoderation we have taken away some of the best threads in my opinion, and you have kept many of the best in the business from posting.

nope ..but the mods and admins have closed down your recruiting activities more times that you and you 6 figure bank accounts are happy about ..whats with the WE ..your activities ( which you cant resist ) mean mods and admins have to sometimes lose entire threads which the removal of your compulsive and unsubtle spamming render incomprehensible if left after your spamming is cut ..you are the problem ..perhaps you actually do this to deliberately kill threads by going over TOS each time the "secrets "that you would charge for elsewhere look like being discussed in open fora here ..

( cleans hands and cuts fresh romarin ;-)

9.

EVEN if we posted purely educational content to help others, which we do, we'd be worried that it would be deleted because of someone's unfounded "suspicions" as to what our motive could be. I mean, why/how could we possibly post anything useful unless we wanted to benefit from it somehow.

you should be more carefull with your punctuation ..commas are for where one would pause for breath ..if you read your paragraph out loud ..your real motives cant help but be exposed ..
thus
EVEN if we posted purely educational content to help others

then because it just sort of slipped out back there ..
which we do
would have been more credible if that had've been the part in caps ;-)
we'd be worried that it would be deleted because of someone's unfounded "suspicions" as to what our motive could be.
snot stopped you til now ..mr anthony will explain what are "chancers" to you
I mean, why/how could we possibly post anything useful unless we wanted to benefit from it somehow.
with no more than the addition of a bold tag what was really in your mind whilst you typed becomes crystal clear ..freudian slip? ..you see mr wray ..you've all got "form" ..and just like body language ..it can even get past your very bestest typing face ..

( cleans hands ..again ..for now ..) ..

so who's left in the woodwork ..?

oh yeah ..you see mr a and mr m ( and shills )..people like ronin are quite happy to give stuff away and exchange ideas ..just like webwork said ..and no ulterior motive ..ronin hasnt' got form ..

now when is one of you going to answer lawman ..carefull his BS meter is better than mine ..and he's cut me more times than you can shake a stick at ..but we both ..along with Marcia and others who oppose you ..truely have the interests of this forum and its at heart ..not merely our own

Leosghost

12:16 am on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



oddsod bears listening to mr o and your friends ..your own self interest blinds you and kills your chances here to anything that you claim to have wanted to acheive ..so when you try it on elsewhere ..learn the lesson ..

oddsod may even explain to you how ..for free :-) or not ..his decision ..

but way back in this thread ..he too agreed that you and your kind should not change the way the aff area is run ..

gamiziuk

12:36 am on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



That post only goes to prove that the mod should have deleted ALL of them and not allowed ANY specifics. Or should have nuked the whole post. Newbies need to learn HOW to evaluate and pick programs for themselves.

Long-time, trustworthy senior members have expressed their views, which aren't the same as whiners and/or those who have a personal agenda; but then again, maybe that forum has been too loose after all, and needs to tighten up a bit.

Oh dear. Well I am not a "trustworthy senior member," so it appears that I do not need to participate in this discussion any longer.

:wave: Bye!

eljefe3

4:50 am on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Interesting thread... ISP goes down for 3 days and look at what I've missed.

Now as I go to write this thread, look at what I see right below the text input box:
Promoting, selling, and recruiting are not allowed in the general forums.

Seems this thread has two very different sides. One side wants to be allowed to break the TOS about no self promotion as saying that by breaking the TOS they would be helping out fellow members. Just curious did this group have a booth at pubcon and pay for the privilege of promoting their helpful program?

The other side wants to keep the forum as it is, which is a forum that abides by the forum charter and WebmasterWorld's TOS. If Brett wants to alter or amend this, then that's his perogative.

Somewhere I read in this thread that all the old long term posters such as mfishy etc. Have been driven away.......Nonsense. I see mfishy here and when he has something to post, he posts.

I also see mention here of mods having ulterior motives about allowing some URL drops while deleting others. I know my fellow mods and they don't do this, and neither do I. Heck we'd all love to drop URL's to various programs but that is now what this forum is about.

This forum is about helping each other out with tips, info etc. This forum is not about pointing members to high paying programs that line everyone's pockets for promoting the latest and greatest ebook, mlm, forex program or anything else.

Now I'd love to hear ( as I'm sure Brett would) people's solutions as to how we can maintain the forum and to teach people how to earn more money online without the forum being one giant spamfest/URL dropfest. Who's to decide which URL's make it and which don't? As Marcia suggested, maybe we as mods need to not allow any URL drops and that would keep those that think we have a personal interest on one progam over another from coming to this erroneous conclusion.

Suggestions?

Marcia

4:50 am on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I mean, why/how could we possibly post anything useful unless we wanted to benefit from it somehow.

That about sums it all up, doesn't it? Including starting this thread.

Nuff said.

davewray

5:08 am on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Leosghost...I can't respond to anything you've posted because I can't bloody well figure out what you are going on about. I think it's the English language, but I'm not sure? Care for another bottle of Scotch?

Marcia...That was sarcasm dear...one as sage as yourself should have been able to figure that out. Or, maybe that's why you are misinterpreting everything else in this thread?

Eljefe et al...Who said anything about Ebooks? Or MLM? This has nothing to do about either! Did you not know that MLM and Affiliate marketing are two completely different things? And I don't think anyone's suggesting dropping URL's. Even I don't want that. I think the main issue is where to draw the line. If we can't talk about programs that do well...can we talk about industries in general? If not industries..then what? Success stories inspire...I don't think it's bragging at all, it's encouragement for others who want to know that they can in fact make it...even in today's internet marketing world. Rfung's thread inspired even me. Everyone wants to hear that someone who first struggled finally made it and is now a success.

Question for all: And please, only serious answers. So, you know that certain individuals do well. And they do well in certain industries with certain programs. What kind of posts would you consider legitimate from such an individual without thinking they were self-promoting? I ask this, because even if we presume that we are posting something useful, or educational, there will always be someone who thinks that we are promoting ourselves. A no-win situation.

Leosghost...Instead of burning all of those Ebooks (and who knows where you're getting all of them...you must like buying them), why don't you just burn us at the stake to keep warm?

Shawn Collins

6:25 am on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Affiliate programs are generally setup as MLM/pyramid systems (and that is NOT a criticism of it - only commentary) designed to pass on the actual act of doing the front line selling to someone else.

That is patently incorrect.

Perhaps that is your perception, because affiliates in two-tier affiliate programs (by the way, anything more than two-tiers is not an affiliate program) are the ones who try and spam here.

But the two-tier affiliate programs account for a small minority of affiliate programs out there.

If you are familiar with the larger affiliate networks, such as CJ, LinkShare, Performics, and Shareasale, it's not even possible to have two-tiers when running an affiliate program with them.

Brett, can you provide a citation from a credible source to back up your statement?

Marcia

7:04 am on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Hi, Shawn. I don't mean be interpreting what Brett posted, but from my understanding, I believe the reference is being made to two-tier programs.

I personally was "befriended" by someone a couple years back who subsequently (and subtly) gave me a "friendly tip" and helped me with ideas for content (by personal example) for a program they were making a lot of money with. Which they sure were! I joined up "under" the person, found a terrific keyworded domain and put up a site - and never could bring myself to promote anything in that space, it didn't "feel right" to me, personally. So I let it lie fallow and just let the domain expire. Sad to say, the person stopped being my friend for some strange reason (sniffle, sniffle).

There are, indeed, people who have made a bundle of cash by recruiting a sizeable "downline" - much the same way as MLM'ers do. It's part of what could be called "relationship marketing."

credible source

I may not be a credible source, and BT would have no way of knowing anything about my personal experience, but I can vouch for the fact that I was recruited for a 2nd-tier "downline" in the same way that others in the past have tried to recruit me for their MLM downlines - like those diet cookies years ago, wearing buttons that said, "Lose weight and earn money!" Anyone remember that one? :)

If you are familiar with the larger affiliate networks, such as CJ, LinkShare, Performics, and Shareasale, it's not even possible to have two-tiers when running an affiliate program with them.

Shawn, I've never seen any at the other networks, but there actually are a few at SAS. In fact, one of my best programs there has a second tier - but I'd rather just keep VIP% than bother with "recruiting" which wouldn't feel right to me, personally. But I've never seen any emphasis at all placed on the 2-tier aspect, with that one or others on that network.

==================================================================

Marcia...That was sarcasm dear...one as sage as yourself should have been able to figure that out. Or, maybe that's why you are misinterpreting everything else in this thread?

No, I'm not misinterpreting anything at all. You may have meant it as caustic sarcasm, but a rose by any other name is still a rose.

You have to look at the context and know the field, a moderator of the advertising and affiliate forum should be selected because they know the advertising and affiliate field, not just because they stuck their hand up.

Fully agree. The lady down the street who works at the laundromat and has a Geocities site running Linkshare banners on her poetry site would be a poor choice indeed. No mistake about it.

Eljefe et al...

Yeah, right. Eljefe et al can run circles around any two-bit, conniving, self-promoting profile spammers any day of the week. And incidentally, it's been a couple of years since I read the thread on "Professional Forum Spammers" but if there isn't reference being made to profile spammers it should be updated to include them, so that we can link directly to a post on it when folks fit the bill as perfect examples and think they're pulling the wool over anyone's eyes.

[edited by: Marcia at 7:35 am (utc) on Jan. 29, 2007]

Leosghost

8:39 am on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Leosghost...Instead of burning all of those Ebooks (and who knows where you're getting all of them...you must like buying them), why don't you just burn us at the stake to keep warm?

Where I'm posting from ..burning things and or people at the stake , if you have my accent , is a big no no ..:-)

Leosghost...I can't respond to anything you've posted because I can't bloody well figure out what you are going on about. I think it's the English language, but I'm not sure? Care for another bottle of Scotch?

Two part answer there ..you too apparently have a problem recognising sarcasm ;-)..and second part ..if you paid attention to how I spell whiskey ..you'd know I dont drink scotch ..

Did you not know that MLM and Affiliate marketing are two completely different things?

Not the way you , mr a and the rest of your friends run your profile sites they arent ( when your profile sites stay still long enough to be seen that is ) ..either have a site in your profiles ..or dont ..but the way you keep switching them around is like watching "find the lady" ( otherwise known as the 3 card trick ) or sidewalk scammers ..

Now why would there be such a glaring similarity between watching you all at work when you are posting and watching people running 3 card tricks ..hhhmmmm ..

Again the current thread on the hotel industry and online affs is working very well , giving very detailed info , and no one has seen it necessary to tell us their "success story" nor quote their income , nor describe their cars ..in order to for us to know that they know what they are talking about ..there is no "come on" ..no "hook for the marks" in that thread ..unlike all of yours ..

Yeah, right. Eljefe et al can run circles around any two-bit, conniving, self-promoting profile spammers any day of the week. And incidentally, it's been a couple of years since I read the thread on "Professional Forum Spammers" but if there isn't reference being made to profile spammers it should be updated to include them, so that we can link directly to a post on it when folks fit the bill as perfect examples and think they're pulling the wool over anyone's eyes.

I agree with you totally Marcia :-)

BTW mr wray ( et al )..as to where I get all my ebooks from to burn ..easy ..comes of having mates in the UK fraud squad , the FBI and the gendarmerie nationale ..and les services des "repression des fraudes " and les "police juridique" ..they send me copies of ebooks ..the french services sometimes even bring em personally ..or show me foriegn sites that their nationals have had problems with .. and ask what I think of them ..I translate complete with all the nuances ..we all laugh at how gullible some people are ..and how clever some others think they are ..

..and at how you cant actually hide in tax havens as easily as some think ..

Status_203

12:27 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Not sure I have the post count to qualify for this thread ;)

Just like to say thank you to Brett for leaving this thread open.

By the time I got halfway down the first page I was wondering why it had not yet been locked.

By the time I got through the lot (to date) I'd realised just how educational the thread is.

Marcia

12:28 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Oh my gosh, Heavens to Betsy, good golly Miss Molly, good gracious, Mergatroid! WASSUP?

This is what the sub-title of this thread is, written by the person who started the thread:

A suggested answer

Answer? What answer? I haven't seen any tangible "answer" yet, but OMIGOSH! When looking at the follow-up posts by the various and sundry members of this officiously orchestrated tag team operation, is there some kind of subliminal implication being suggested that one of this illustrious lunch bunch be assigned as one of the moderators of that forum?

Begging forgiveness, but inquiring minds want to know.

[edited by: Marcia at 12:36 pm (utc) on Jan. 29, 2007]

Michael Anthony

12:53 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)



I was suggesting an answer to why the section had died.

Leosghost

12:57 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



and we keep telling you that it hasnt ..nor is anyone going to let you and yours try and declare it dead ..so as to turn it into your own pet zombie

lawman

1:00 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



I was suggesting an answer to why the section had died.

Like I said, I don't hang there. But if you're correct, solution(s) with specifics probably would be helpful.

eljefe3

2:11 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



In my earlier post I was asking for solutions nad suggestons also that still ahdere to the TOS as well as the forum charter. I'm all ears :)

BTW Marcia, yes we need to update the charter to include profile spammers. Usually these are easy to spot, but once in a while a few are that good and subtle that they accomplish their goal.

Shawn Collins

2:13 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Hi, Shawn. I don't mean be interpreting what Brett posted, but from my understanding, I believe the reference is being made to two-tier programs.

So do I - I was challenging his assertion that "Affiliate programs are generally setup as MLM/pyramid systems".

There is no question that two-tier affiliate programs exist. it's just that such a scheme is NOT how affiliate programs are generally setup.

Brett_Tabke

2:20 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



First, cool discussion. Obviously there is a diverse opinion base - and oh so passionate - about aff programs. What a refreshing change from all google all the time.

> If you are familiar with the larger affiliate networks,
> such as CJ, LinkShare, Performics, and Shareasale, it's
> not even possible to have two-tiers when running an
> affiliate program with them.

Hey Shawn - welcome back to the board. Comments appreciated.

I really don't mean that statement about a pyramid program as a *bad* thing. It is just a commentary on the structure. If a dealer, seller, or site is working directly with the manufacture of product, then that is single tier. However, when you get into networks, where dealers, sellers, and sites are more than 1 step removed from the producer of the product, you are in to a multi level distribution and sales setup (eg, cj). Most of those front line sellers, dealers, and sites (eg: generally called affiliates) have no contact with the original manufacturer of those products.

Again, that is not a negative criticism about the format of aff programs and/or networks. Don't let the industry lingo-of-the-day blind us to the problem we face here in that the biz model turns those dealers, sellers, and site owners in to pitch men. Their skin in the game is to go out and promote and generate leads and sales for that product. As a public venue, we have often become an unwitting vehicle for that act. From simple drive by spam, to sophisticated whisper campaigns, we have seen it all.

Shawn Collins

2:36 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Hey Shawn - welcome back to the board. Comments appreciated.

Thanks. Never left - just a serial lurker. :-)

I really don't mean that statement about a pyramid program as a *bad* thing. It is just a commentary on the structure.

I guess it's all about semantics, but affiliate marketing and MLM are two very diverse camps in theory and practice.

For instance, something like AGLOCO is not an affiliate program. It's MLM and MLM/pyramid are bad things to legitimate affiliate marketers.

Since the MLM side of it has a dicey reputation, they sometimes try to brand themselves as affiliate marketers.

There are plenty of annoying one-tier affiliate marketing spammers for sure. They're just a different breed of abhorrent from the MLM/pyramid guys.

Webwork

3:49 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



In my earlier post I was asking for solutions nad suggestons also that still ahdere to the TOS as well as the forum charter. I'm all ears :)

You asked for it:

  • How is link building for affiliate sites different that link building for other sites and what's the best approach? Link spam?
  • How to negotiate a better revenue share with an affiliate manager?
  • Seasonal affiliate strategies: Is it all PPC?
  • Keyword strategies for new product promotions.
  • PPC games that can kill affiliates: jams, crams, etc. What are they? How to deal with them?
  • Is it the article (review) or the image?
  • Optimizing an affiliate website for ease of maintenance.
  • The ins and outs of developing and selling leads, by industry.
  • Writing to sell - revisted - and revisited. Times change. Does the model?
  • Social networking and affiliate marketing? How to make the most of it?
  • Do the new sources of free traffic convert? Sometimes? When? How? Never? How do you know?
  • Is PPA the future? If so, how will it evolve?
  • How to track conversions?
  • What are the best steps for tracking fraud or manipulation by an affiliate program operator?
  • Phone numbers and affiliate promotions: What's the best ideas, approaches for dealing with phone calls "cheating" the affiliate?
  • What's the latest on clickjacking? Again and again.
  • Cookie cleaning by browsers and the future of affiliate marketing.
  • Affiliate feeds: When and where do they work best?
  • Arbitrage Levels Beginning, Internediate and Advanced Tutorials. (Shudder . . who would give that away?) :0)? or :0(?
  • Are casino and drug affiliates bringing something new to affiliate marketing in other spheres? What will the outcome be?
  • Traffic that converts: A perennial issue. How? Where?
  • Conversion tracking and strategic adjustments: Historical experiences, lessons learned. How to - beginning, intermediate, advananced tutorials.
  • Chargebacks, cancellations, affiliate commission rollbacks: What industries show what trends or averages or norms? What to avoid? What to expect?
  • High volume, low commission versus low volume, high commission: What goes into the decisionmaking and execution process?
  • Affiliate program terms and conditions: Are they written in stone? How to navigate them? How to deal with the 'email of death' or near death?
  • So many affiliates. So few performers. Why?
  • Picking an affiliate program that Person A is suited to: Is there some magic to finding the right program?
  • What makes a person a good candidate for being an affiliate marketer?
  • Work-at-home moms: Where and how should they get started? How? What tools do they need?
  • Man . . I could go on . . . pick one.

I've routinely checked into the WebmasterWorld Affiliate Forum. It IS a fairly quiet place. I think it could buzz, as an educational place, but that likely would require a change of mind:

  1. The presence of affiliate managers who are willilng and able to talk, in general terms, about the "how to's" of affiliate marketing and leave the self-promotion at the door. (People sometimes forget that just being helpful, without being promtional, invites inquires.)
  2. Affiliate marketers who aren't afraid to give up the goods. Whose mindset is "there's enough to go around" or "there's a difference between knowledge and execution and personality - so I can give up the goods and still rule the roost".

Like I said in my earlier post, I've routinely visited most affiliate forums. The "educational signal" to "other signal" ratio if about 1/187.

Teach. Teach affiliate marketing. Teach all aspects of it. Make the Affiliate Marketing forum a school, not a social event nor a promotional forum. Leave the egos at the door.

That would be something to watch, to experience, to participate in, wouldn't it?

Marcia

4:24 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



It's a filibuster! Webwork for Senator in 2008!

Webwork

5:01 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



I suspect many believe I am asking for the impossible.

Affiliate Managers who teach the ins and outs of affiliate marketing without being self-referential? How could it be done?! (It's not really "can it be done" it's "But . . but . . what's in it for me? Will the bosses go for it? What's the ROI?" I'd like to suggest that showing intelligence and the ability to teach and train and the willingness to go to the effort would likely be a BIG attractant to anyone's program - without ever mentioning the particulars of the program. Okay . . well maybe the link in the AM's profile might give enough of a hint.)

Affiliate Marketers giving away the goods? That reluctance - the sense that "If I share this then I'm doing myself harm" is something that I suspect some people will never get over. As if it's just "this knowledge" is the trick when it comes to business success, forgetting about everything else, like drive and intelligence and alertness to change and adaptability and ability to manage cash flow and . . . "Oh, but if I tell anyone that ProgramX is working well then . . . "

Consequences or predictions are often more perceived than real, especially when it comes to sizing up a competitive landscape. I suspect that a great deal more could be vetted in an affiliate forum without material adverse consequences to those who might choose to be open or share a bit more. There's so much more to success than a list of tips or pointing someone in the right direction or even giving someone a "how to manual".

Michael Anthony

5:06 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)



Webwork - that is a completely brilliant post (the long one, not the one immdeiately above), and hits the nail on the head.

And my school only exists because I was deluged with stickies from WebmasterWorld members after posting educational stuff here around three years ago and got sick and tired of sending the same info by email, so your point about teaching bringing enquiries is bang on the money.

Make it like a school, not a dictatorship.

Perhaps what I'm asking for is that if a thread contains some obviously promotional posts, that these alone are edited/deleted by the mods, rather than the recent heavy handed approach where the whole thread, good posts and all, is deleted outright.

And to make it easier for those whose threads are moderated to comply in the future, it would help if the mods could leave a note (as they admitedly often do) explaining their reasoning, so that the offending posters can learn where they went wrong.

As I stated above, I like this place. I like helping others and I enjoy seeing others succeed, regardless of whether or not it profits me personally. I'm sure that many others feel the same, and a more conversational approach to moderation would encourage like minded individuals to return to the section in question secure in the knowledge that they weren't going to have their carefully thought out work deleted in its entirety.

[edited by: Michael_Anthony at 5:11 pm (utc) on Jan. 29, 2007]

oddsod

5:28 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Webwork, great list! :) MA, go on, pick one :)

that if a thread contains some obviously promotional posts, that these alone are edited/deleted by the mods, rather than the recent heavy handed approach where the whole thread, good posts and all, is deleted outright.

Sounds like a perfectly resonable request (except where the OP itself is promotional).

[edited by: oddsod at 5:33 pm (utc) on Jan. 29, 2007]

Webwork

5:32 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Make it like a school, not a dictatorship.

Thanks for the compliment but there's more to address as a result of your response.

When I was a child I simply abided the rules of my parents house. When I was a teenager I started to rebell, question and resent their rules. When I felt a bit like I was an adult I moved out on my own, determining that I would live by my rules. Now that I'm older, when I go to my parents house, I accept their rules. It's their house, not mine, even though I once called it "my house, my home". I feel respect for their ways, as they live according to choices they have made and principals they choose, and I have an understanding of their ways that has been shaped by further experience and living and parenthood. I take that experience into other places, such as workpaces and forums.

Ultimately, a forum - even though it's a community - is always someone else's house. You either live by the rules of the house or build your own house.

The rules here are a bit different, which is why the place works - in it's own way. It attracts certaini folks and others run from it shouting epithets.

The nice thing about being connected to the WWW is that it makes it easy to move houses or even build your own.

Michael Anthony, the very fact that you resort to the word "dictatorship" suggests that for you it's time to move on and build your own house.

Then, after all that hard work and effort, you can be the person whom other's refer to as dictator - in your own house.

Michael Anthony

5:47 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)



I've got my own house thanks, but I'd still like to visit and chat with you and my other "parents" once in a while.

Even parents can occasionally admit that their approach may be wrong - I know as a parent myself that my children have taught me lots about myself, and that I don't know it all.

One learns very little as a dictator, much more as a child. And these parents have still got stuff to teach me, I'm sure.

encyclo

5:50 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Note: the following is a personal response and is not intended to be seen as being an "official" reply. Please ignore the label under my username for the purposes of this post.

A forum is supposed to be a place for discussion, not lecturing. An exchange of views, ideas, a conversation between professionals and which at the same time offers a welcoming attitude to newcomers. The "education" comes from participation, questioning, and personal testing and experience.

The concept of presenting a forum as a school is not just desperately infantilizing, but it would actively boost self-aggrandizing experts and diminish equally valuable but less experienced members. (This is not meant to diminish Webwork's valuable comments, but merely to add focus to the methodology). Would a forum which is merely a school be best for the long-term health of the discussion?

For the specific questions of moderator actions relating to particular threads which have been edited or deleted, it would be better to refer to the moderator or administrator in question or another administrator (for example BT or engine) via sticky mail if you are unhappy with the decision taken, in accordance with terms of service #24 [webmasterworld.com].

davewray

6:26 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Webwork...Thank-you for your post. It is just those topics that should be covered in the affiliate marketing and sales forum. However, due to previous slashing and burning of posts, one would be reluctant to post for fear that they might be labelled a "spammer" or "self-promoter".

Blatant promotion shouldn't be allowed, it never has been. That includes comments like, "Join my program here, you'll make a killing!"...Or, dropping URL's. Like you said BT and Encyclo, once you start that it's a dangerous slippery slope that never ends.

I honestly was looking for good discussion when I posted that ROI thread. I admit when MA joined in it looked a little fishy, as the association between us became apparent. But let me be clear. I did not ask MA to participate in my thread, nor was I going to keep him from doing so. He has a lot of good information to offer himself. What ensued in terms of Sticky Mail and mass thread deletion had me a little baffled and surprised. Why? Because instantly I was painted as a "villain". I wasn't given the chance to explain myself, or what had happened. I wasn't given the chance to declare that MA and myself hadn't secretly met/discussed before hand that we would "tag team" and try to "fool" newbies into joining our programs. That was Not the intent. Yet, I might as well have been guilty before being proven innocent.

Now, I will be reluctant to post anywhere. Even though I feel like I have a lot of knowledge and good information to offer. Some may welcome that news. But I think it's unfortunate. We were all newbies once...and we all have benefited from this place. To make forum members who have been around a while and who have a lot to offer feel like criminals before they even post is just wrong.

It's against the TOS, but I wish I could post the Sticky message that I got from a certain admin, to show you how scathing it was was...considering I had never EVER been "accused" of doing something like that before.

Anyways, let's get back to good conversation about how we can make the aff/sales forum a great place to contribute and share good ideas again.

Dave.

Webwork

7:58 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Now, watch the lowly moderator go at it with the mighty Administrator Encyclo

A forum is supposed to be a place for discussion, not lecturing.

Some of the very best WebmasterWorld discussions are kicked off by 'a lecture'. You know the ones: those long and detailed authoratative posts. That said, so long as people are allowed to reply a forum will never be a lecture.

The "education" comes from participation, questioning, and personal testing and experience.

Slight twist of the kaleidoscope, different outcome: The "education" comes from context - a philosophical, prinicipal, rules and operational contextual framework. If we didn't operate in a context of education WebmasterWorld would likely look like all the other forums that offer participation, questioning, testing, sharing of experience. We don't, and I say we don't because of a) a strong anti-promotional policy; and, b) a committment to conversation in an educational context, one that does a decent job of rooting out BS by virtue of participatory dialogue amongst a goodly number of professionals, professionals that I say are drawn here in large part by the context of professionalism and education, not promotion.

The concept of presenting a forum as a school is not just desperately infantilizing, but it would actively boost self-aggrandizing experts and diminish equally valuable but less experienced members.

I'm not certain Aristotle or Socrates would agree. If your construct of "school" is grammar school then yes, it's a spot on statement. Of course that's me presenting an extreme interpretation to challenge the conclusions you draw about school being infantilizing. "School", well executed, can also be empowering. I guess it's partly a function of who runs the school and in what manner, but this is all a bit too much of an abstraction. I do so love abstractions, just not the ones that don't empower concrete action, so . . must . . transition . . before Dilbertesque moment is further perpetuated . .

So far as self-aggrandizing experts that's something I love about forums: The minute one puts one's self out there as an expert the certain gravity of public participation starts to exert itself.

This is not meant to diminish Webwork's valuable comments, but merely to add focus to the methodology.

Me? Unfocused? Never.

Would a forum which is merely a school be best for the long-term health of the discussion?

I'm not certain how that would ever happen. It's a somewhat mystical statement to me. Care to explain, teacher, the evolutionary process whereby a webpresence generated by forum software begets what anyone would refer to as "merely a school"? Pedants only? No student contributions? All books and desks and class schedules? I'm at a loss. Please elaborate. ;-P (Yep, it's a school fershur, and my middle name is trouble. Go ahead. You're an admin. Send me to detention. I double dare you. :-P :-P)

And yes, my fellow WebmasterWorld members, even moderators get sent to detention, get upbraided, get politely told to sit down and shut-up at times . . so, my point being, don't take it too hard that it happens. It happens to all of us, me too, as well it should from time to time, lest we confuse ourselves with Brett.* Overseeing dialogue - moderation - is an imperfect art executed in an imperfect medium - human communication and human psyches - so show a little mercy to your fellow human beings who struggle against the frailties of their humanity. I don't know any dictators here who don't struggle to ask "Am I doing the right thing or going about it in the right way or for the right reasons?"

*Reigning in Brett is Mrs. Tabke's job. You ever see a nurse give orders? Scary when they combine orders with "the look". Yes, Mrs. Tabke.

[edited by: Webwork at 8:16 pm (utc) on Jan. 29, 2007]

Leosghost

10:27 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



webwork my friend ..you want to try to atone ..to defy , to become part of what you perceive as the rebellion ..to become their avocat ..first do your homework you have become the mouthpeice and the tool of scoundrels and vagabonds who laugh behind your back even as you expound their cause in the name of freedom ..their banner that you raise aloft so defiantly is already besmirched and stained by their own words in the past ..in threads deleted and gone which they will deny the very existance of .. you know not the history of those whose part you take ..

and in nice plain english ..J ..shut the * up and stop letting yourself be used as their mouthpeice ..while you work out your angst ( they were asked for concrete non selfserving suggestions ..they didnt have any ...the rest of us know their history ..from threads now deleted that you never saw and they will deny the existance of ..so we never expected anything other than more smoke and more mirrors from them .they stalled ) ..and then you jumped in wanting to crucify yourself in an argument with the other mods and admins here for reasons more to do with outside here and rebellion and finding yourself than anything in this thread ..

familiarise yourself with the full background to the specific breif and individuals under discussion before posting ..and before deciding to try to plant your cross here on this hill and daring admins to come up with the nails ..because as a friend and not an admin nor a mod nor a member of Bretts family ..

i'm telling you ..you want to bleed ..start your own thread ..

and that pains me immensely to post that to a friend ..

walk away ..take a break ..it pains me to see you being used ..and that you walked into it ..it pains me also to see the kick in the teeth that your post gives to Marcia , Eljefe and his co mods in the aff fora ..and all the others who try to keep this place as clean as it has been til now ..and whose integrity and commitment has been called into question by those only interested in self promotion ..

and it pains me so much more to have to say that in public ..

you make a crap troll ..some of us can still see the tears ..

admins ..Brett ..your choice if you leave this post in eventually ..i'd have locked the thread when the towel was thrown in in post #:3235003 but you let it run so here we are ..i just wish the vermin werent witness ..i wont be posting again in this thread ..my position is known ..J ..you want to shout at me ..call ..i'm still your mate ..M

[edited by: Brett_Tabke at 12:49 am (utc) on Jan. 30, 2007]

cornwall

10:31 pm on Jan 29, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I've routinely checked into the WebmasterWorld Affiliate Forum. It IS a fairly quiet place. I think it could buzz, as an educational place, but that likely would require a change of mind:

"Me too" as the bishop said to the actress

Forget the rest, that is the core of the problem with the Affiliate Forum

This 118 message thread spans 4 pages: 118