Forum Moderators: open

Message Too Old, No Replies

Is broad match actually working?

Can't find any evidence ...

         

storevalley

10:35 am on Aug 19, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I have set up broad matching on a number of terms, but can't find any evidence of it actually working. Anybody out there having more luck?

Exact matches are working fine.

johannes

10:56 am on Aug 19, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



oops too quick, don't know the answer.

kidekat

11:17 am on Aug 19, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Definitely not working for me, neither is phrase match.

Sarah Britton

11:25 am on Aug 19, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



For me also none is working, neither the broad/phrase/exact-

guess have to wait for those guys to come in and then ask them- the thing is they also don't have an answer- was told yesterday that the bidding wud be okay before the end of the day yesterday but so far nothing has happened.

fenway

3:51 pm on Aug 20, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



the word we got was that the standard match/matchdriver would continue to always be first, anything you bid on broad match would show up under anything using matchdriver, and then keyphrase below that I believe.

since I havn't been able to get in and actually choose different matching processes, i havn't been able to test..

anyone else, who has been able to use the feature, seen evidence of this?

Tropical Island

5:08 pm on Aug 20, 2003 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



We were just into our accounts at Over US, UK & DE. We are now able to see all of our search terms and make changes although we had to do some hunting. Here are some observations:

Check your various categories for your terms - "all listings doesn't seem to work if you have them.

Put the search term page on 200 lines (upper corner). It looks like the system now sees each term as three lines to take into account the three different matches. By using 200 you should be able to see up to 66 listings on 1 page.

We have many terms that are of the nature of
regional area
regional area vacation
regional area hotel
regional area guest house
etc.

If we now go to broad or phrase match for "regional area" won't we be duplicating these terms? Can we trust Over's new system to realize these are duplications?

Does anyone know when detailed reports will reappear?

johnnydequino

5:18 pm on Aug 20, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Here is how this new feature works guys:

Standard match will always come first. It's the most relevant, and overture editors have already approved it.

Next, phrase match will appear. I recommend most business to use this, but what do I know. =) In the example below:

regional area hotel
one dollar hotel regional area

Will show up under phrase match.

The next listing, broad match, will show underneath, and since overture only allows you to use 15 negative keywords traffice will be junk in my opinion.

Examples of broad match:
regional hotel in the utah area
regional person in an area specific

And so far I have seen no evidence of these new features working, as overture said it will take 24 hours. It has been longer for me.

Good luck all - jd

webdiversity

6:32 pm on Aug 20, 2003 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



We've seen the odd search query in our tracking tool that show up as a phrase match (don't like broad match so wouldn't be able to tell if it was or not).

I think that Overture are probably taking the wise approach of trying to restore some sort of a normal service and work on things a bit at a time.

Interesting though.

fenway

7:10 pm on Aug 20, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Say, for the helluvit, i was bidding on the word "flowers" and nobody else was. If I choose phrase and broad match for this term..would my listing show up in the #1, #2, and #3 spots?

johnnydequino

7:48 pm on Aug 20, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Fenway - no.

Bidding on the term flowers would look like this:

Let's assume you had the highest bid for the term flowers for standard, phrase and broad listing.

If some one typed in flowers, you would be number #1.

IF someone typed in flower shop, you would be under the standard bidders. For this example, there are 9 people bidding on the term flowers so you would be 10.

Apply the same logic for broad match.

Hope this helps - jd

Tropical Island

8:52 pm on Aug 20, 2003 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



johnnydequino -

You bring up another interesting point about the amount of the bid. If you are using "auto bid" and it's set higher then you are comnfortable with be really careful. You could find yourself paying maximum bid for some phrase or broad match terms if you fall into some heavier competition.

webdiversity

11:35 pm on Aug 20, 2003 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



If you click on the keyword it brings up the three bid options, you can then set a different price for each, it's effectively three auctions in one.

In time advertisers will get the hang of it..... maybe, but in the meantime.

jeremy goodrich

11:39 pm on Aug 20, 2003 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



>>effectively three auctions in one.

Um, Overture is a marketplace - you won't find "auction" on their literature, anywhere - hasn't been there for well over a year :)

Seems to me that they are still using the "match driver" and have yet to fully implement the newer matching scheme.

storevalley

8:07 am on Aug 21, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Standard match will always come first. It's the most relevant, and overture editors have already approved it

johnnydequino ... is there some literature from Overture that confirms this? I hope so ... it will keep Overture interesting :)

One of my suspicions with broad matching was that if ...

  • Somebody bids 0.10 today to grab top spot for "some service local area" (exact match)

  • Twenty other people are bidding much more for "some service" (broad match).

    ... the initial bidder will end up in 21st place for "some service local area" once the new match logic kicks in (and that this will be reflected in DirecTraffic Center)

    This will call for a change of tactics for more than one Overture user I know.

  • johnnydequino

    10:36 am on Aug 21, 2003 (gmt 0)

    10+ Year Member



    storevalley - it's correct. Call overture to ask them. It makes perfect sense to me - overture has an entire staff to approve keywords and keep them relevant.

    Just wait to see how irrelevent this broad/phrase match will be for most internet users.

    It works on adwords because it's like an ad - and you have a ton of negative keywords to use.

    I like overtures better if you ask me.

    jd

    storevalley

    12:01 pm on Aug 21, 2003 (gmt 0)

    10+ Year Member



    jd ... just had a chat with one of the Overture reps. You are 100% correct. They tell me that the order is ...

    1. Exact match
    2. Phrase match
    3. Broad match

    I like overtures better if you ask me

    Me too :)

    Sarah Britton

    12:22 pm on Aug 21, 2003 (gmt 0)

    10+ Year Member



    For the search term "soccer"

    Advertsier A is bidding at $2 for standard match and Advertiser B has a broad match and is bidding at $ 2.05-

    will Aevertiser "A" appear at top position or "B"
    or vice versa?

    Sarah Britton

    1:42 pm on Aug 21, 2003 (gmt 0)

    10+ Year Member



    In standard match we are supposed to appear for the misspelt as well as the plural form of a given search tem- However I do not see it happening.

    Can somebody explain this?

    storevalley

    2:54 pm on Aug 21, 2003 (gmt 0)

    10+ Year Member



    Advertsier A is bidding at $2 for standard match and Advertiser B has a broad match and is bidding at $ 2.05

    Based on the info I got from Overture this morning, I reckon ...

    If they are both bidding for "soccer", Advertiser B will appear on top.

    If Advertiser A is bidding on e.g. "soccer kit" using exact match, and Advertiser B is bidding on "soccer" using broad match, both will appear if "soccer kit" is typed. But Advertiser A will appear on top.

    Best idea is to ring Overture if you have a specific scenario that you need to clarify. They are always very helpful.

    Sarah Britton

    3:06 pm on Aug 21, 2003 (gmt 0)

    10+ Year Member



    Thanks- It is clear now
    Can you also tell about the plural/misspelt search terms

    Sarah Britton

    3:32 pm on Aug 21, 2003 (gmt 0)

    10+ Year Member



    Hi It is clear- only when they have enough traffic for the misspelt search term will they map it for exact match.

    Otherwise it is wiser to put up another listing!

    webdiversity

    7:48 pm on Aug 22, 2003 (gmt 0)

    WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



    Um, Overture is a marketplace - you won't find "auction" on their literature, anywhere - hasn't been there for well over a year :)

    Still works like a never ending auction with #1 going to the highest bidder, and in the absence of a highest bidder, to the highest bidder in the next auction.

    Bit like being in the jump seat, a phrase match has got to be better for overture than an unbidded backfill.

    fenway

    3:40 pm on Aug 25, 2003 (gmt 0)

    10+ Year Member



    quick clarification on Overture's "exact match." I don't think their standard match should every be compared to Google's exact match. If you look at, over time, actual queried terms coming through Google "exact match" campaigns and Overture's "standard match", standard match results list of words are much more similar to what you would see come through a "broad match" campaign. Given the misspelling matching and the ca. 20 noise words which O's matchriver takes into consideration, it's hardly exact match at all as defined by Google.