Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from 220.127.116.11
Forum Moderators: werty
I have 2 rather large accounts with them, with several million keywords. These campaigns have been live since early/mid 2006 and have run with only minor glitches. The campaigns generate in the range of $40K-$60K revenue monthly, and have been consistent performers.
A little over a month ago, Adcenter's Bot decided that my landing page content was not relevant to any of my keywords and started rejecting all my keywords in these campaigns which essentially took my account offline, it started slowly with about a 30-40% drop to eventually about a 98% drop in traffic, and revenue. They admitted that it was an error and all keywords should be approved.
When I explained to the reps how much revenue I was losing I was given the standard, " we apologize for the inconvenience" line and also had it mentioned that most advertisers use other advertising services as well as if losing this revenue shouldn't be a big deal.
First I am a small business owner and losing $20K-$40K per month IS a big deal, and it's not for you to know or judge what other advertising I do use or should use. For this campaign I chose to use you and you are apparently unable to deliver.
Getting to the point. I have contacted Adcenter virtually every single business day for over 4 weeks now, Constantly getting the same reply that the appeals were being worked on.
The first support person I dealt with told me they would keep me updated daily. Daily lasted for about 2 days and then I never heard from them again. I finally got a second person to handle my case and I will say this person has kept me updated as promised on a daily basis, the only problem is, after 1 month NOTHING has been done on this. I keep being told it is in the hands of editorial, it has been assigned to higher management, they are having problems pulling rejection reports, They are overworked, they have a lot of advertisers having the same problem. etc, etc.. Blah Blah Blah
So as of this weekend I went in and modified my ads to see if I could get my campaigns back online, and within a few hours was able to get almost 2 million keywords back online, something Adcenter couldn't do in 1 month. Now the keywords are again starting to be rejected, so when I called today, essentially I was told that because I modified things we have to start over and I should be patient.
Patient? ADcenter, you had 1 MONTH and did nothing except pass things on to someone else, Nothing was done in a month.
I don't want to hear how you are having crawler issues, or how overworked your editorial department is. I don't want to be told that because of what I DID, that you know have to start over.. start over? From what? You accomplished nothing in a month. When I asked exactly what actions had been done to resolve this in a the past month I was given a non answer.
I was asked to patient. I have been very patient and very polite. You had 1 Month and failed.
The best answer I was given was that you were having trouble pulling up rejection reports due to the large volume of my keywords. If you can't handle the large volume, don't accept it. Now I'm told that you have to wait for the keywords to again get clicked so they will be rejected again so editorial can then pull up a fresh rejection report which they weren't able to do in the first place. What a convoluted system you have.
I was given 2 ($200) credits during this month and was told that very few other advertisers were given credits. Either they didn't ask or I don't believe you.
I was also told that since I went in and modified my ads to get them back online, no more credits would be given for this issue, since I am making your job harder. ( Not good PR Adcenter) Putting the blame on the advertiser for your inability to get something resolved, not a smart move.
I constantly asked for a time frame as to when the problem may be resolved and was always told you couldn't provide one.. until today, when after telling your support how I brought my ads online was told that I shouldn't have done that because they would have had a resolution within a week, good timing ADcenter.. and how convenient for you to now have a time frame.
I was told that the editorial person who is working my case actually came in on their own time (Boo hoo) Saturday to specifically work my case and was told they worked "millions" of keywords, though their is no evidence to support this.
I also want to add, that I was told by Adcenter support that I should apply for your premium Adcenter support service which I did, a couple months back, so what happened, you are obviously outsourcing the front end of this process as my response was from someone working for Kelly services, who didn't even know the parameters of the program she was supposed to be representing. I spend a good 5 figures a month with ADcenter and was told that I needed a monthly spend of 6 figures to qualify. This is bogus, as the spend amount is $10K per month, your person then responded and wanted to know how much I spend with Google and Yahoo each month. Here's the answer. None of your D*N* business. Be concerned with how much I spend with you.
I then received a followup from someone who appeared to actually work for Microsoft telling me to ignore what I had already been sent , well, I replied, and to this date not a single followup
Adcenter, You have MAJOR issues, I can't speak for others but you are going to lose this customer real soon.
The quality of your service isn't judged by how things are going when their are no problems, it's judged by how you respond when their are problems and you are failing MISERABLY.
You have 1 VERY unhappy customer right now, I gave you 1 full month to try and resolve this, being patient and polite. You have run out of time and I have run out of patience.
[edited by: Shadoze at 5:51 pm (utc) on Feb. 19, 2007]
As for the 2x $200 credits, lol... as if that is supposed to help things. If you are spending that much each month, I'm sure you couldn't care less about credit, but more about getting your ads up and working again!
It also sounds like they are just playing a blame game with you. Blame should be the least of their concern, you want your ads back up and working, simple as that, I'm sure you aren't interested in who's *fault* it is or isn't.
Sounds like this problem is beyond those who are currently dealing with it.
If you are really making 40k a month, would you be spending your time posting yoru hassles here or on the phone with your adcenter rep trying to make it work?
I just don't "buy" these types of threads because they don't make sense from ANY perspective. As a business owner, as an adsense customer and as someone who has used the competition and seen this type of complaint from ALL sides.
Do you have any idea how much time I've spent on the phone with these people? Apparently not.
>>I just don't "buy" these types of threads because they don't make sense from ANY perspective.
You are entitled to your opinion as to whether what I stated is factual or not. I've been a member here for almost 7 years and have made a total of 54 posts, so I certainly don't spend my time posting on forums for the sake of it.
Sometimes posting things in a public forum is the only way to get someone to take notice.
Usually you get an email description but with how many keywords you say you have thats a crapload of emails to manage.
Do you have keyword examples? Emails? Messages? What are your main topics? Are they brands/copyrighted terms/trademarks? with millions of keywords i'm sure Adcenter has a reason to flag them or drop them for one reason or another.
For relevency sake you would have to have a lot of content/landing pages to make that work.
Perhaps they're dropping stemmed/synonyms/plurals/mis spellings and other broad matches, duplicates. with "millions" of keywords its bound to happen.
hey, its just my opinion. Do as you wish. I don't think MS is really out to blow that much potential revenue on there behalf and with an account that large i certainly hope you have a sales rep to deal with.
I don't have nearly that much spend but i've found the right people to deal with and if you need there names PM me and i'll send you what i have.
I don't think MS is really out to blow that much potential revenue on there behalf and with an account that large i certainly hope you have a sales rep to deal with.
I know it sounds far fetched, but Microsoft likes to hire techies and then put them in charge of business units (one of our ex-employees is now a vice president). Many of these people have no business training and absolutely no business sense. What seems perfectly logical to you or I totally excapes them.