Forum Moderators: open
This is not 1 link but approx 2000 high PR backlinks. The same thing these other guys are doing. They buy a link on a huge site thats 2000+ pages all indexed with high pr in google. The link is on EVERY PAGE of the site.
I have played fair and have 100+ backlinks obtained "legally". My rankings at google are nonexistent and the pages are optimized well IMHO. I hate to be a bad webmaster, but not as much as as i hate to be a broke webmaster ;)
Just wanted to get some opinions and weigh out my options, didnt really plan on jumping into this anytime real soon if at all.
You also mention that you had a drop in your conversion rate. Why don't you concentrate on that? Get all the basics down, before you start trying the fancy stuff. Follow the forum for a few days and spot a few of the "How is this low PR site beating a high PR site" threads. Head over to some of the other forums now and then and pick their brains.
What will you do if those 2000+ links are not enough? What if one of your competitors decides to report you for spamming? Is your site totally clean otherwise? Since you seem to be in a spammy field, do you think google is likely to give you the benefit of the doubt if they do a hand check?
2000 links from one domain, even of a high PR, may not help much. Google tends to discount multiple links from the same domain.
May be you need to look at the problem from another direction.
Is there content that would interest the same people you are targeting? This may bring in the same traffic.
You may need to step back from looking at this simply from a search engine battle and look at the marketing options.