Forum Moderators: open
The refresh bot would keep these pages up-to-date (appearing as if the monthly update has indeed updated you) until a refresh occurred on your specific "keyphrases" but only on other sites (your competition) and missing yours.
When this occurs your pages revert back to the monthly updated info.
This will continue (back & forth) until Googlebot (monthly) has crawled each page.
It everfluxed into the directory soon after.
A search for the precise title showed it listed #1.
Since it was not a part of the October crawl, a search for the title showed it not in the results at all during the update.
Now a couple days after the update this new page/title has again everfluxed back to the #1 result.
I expect we will often see here as freshbot gets more and more active webmasters frantically wondering where thir recent site/page/search-results disappeared to during the update.
Freshbot listings aren't the same as the deep crawl.