Forum Moderators: martinibuster
Definately not worth the trade so far for my sites.
On the other hand, my Adwords campaigns are doing much better with regards to CTR and no change in conversions.
This tells me that results are definately VERY dependant on how the ads are integrated into your site. As a publisher my sites are sucking wind (bad for me, bad for the advertisers), but as an advertiser, the content sites my ads run on are doing better (good for me, good for the publisher).
I hate to think about starting a network wide redesign but it may be necessary if things don't start to moderate.
Freq---
In case anyone cares - the format I'm using that I am seeing such a dramatic decrease in CTR with the 336x250's showing only 2 ads is as follows:
G = Google Ad
C = Content
N = Navigation
Z = Image/Other
B = Blank Space
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
ZZZZ CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC NNNN
ZZZZ CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC NNNN
ZZZZ CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC NNNN
ZZZZ GGGGGGGG BBBBBBBBBB NNNN
ZZZZ GGGGGGGG BBBBBBBBBB NNNN
ZZZZ GGGGGGGG BBBBBBBBBB NNNN
ZZZZ CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC NNNN
ZZZZ CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC NNNN
ZZZZ CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC NNNN
ZZZZ CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC NNNN
I am under the assumption that if I were to wrap the text of the article around the advertisement, the impact would be far less noticeable. It just makes a huge empty void with 2 ads in the above format. I would happily wrap the text around the ads, but I frequently use images early on in articles and the formatting gets crazy with lots of images, text, and ads - not to mention, when Google is showing 3 or 4 advertisements inside the 336x250 I get a really respectable CTR with the above format.
eCPM is also back to normal levels on this channel.
I wonder why they impliment these changes throughout the system when it obviously doesn't have good results on all sites. I thought they did things like this on a per site basis...? There should be nothing statistically that could be telling Google that my site performs better with 2 ads in the 336x250 unit, as it has never affected me in a positive way. I'm a bit confused in regards to this. I'd like to think that the changes they are making to the ads on my sites would be for the better, but I guess I still can't complain - it's a lot less maintenance than Chitika.
After I changed to 250x250 - all was well for awhile, earnings were going up, ecpm up, ctr up.
Things were looking good... now Google is showing only 2 ads in my 250x250 units. Now I'm not even going to mess with other Google formats because this really is a poor judgement on the part of Google. YPN will fill the void until whatever knob got bumped gets bumped back... or longer.