My brother just congratulated me by phone for regaining #1 position on a keyword I enjoy. I checked the results and I still see my site at the bottom of the last page just before the supplemental results. He lives a few miles from me so we're in the same area, seeing the same results.
It turns out that if I log OUT of my Google account my site is indeed #1 for the keyword but logged in I'm near last. It would seem that I am also receiving logged in traffic levels.
How come the results are so dramatically different between logged in and logged out for a website I visit daily ? I don't even like the top 3 logged in results and never visit them.