We hired a freelancer SEO todo our SEO and I think our site fell into a Google penalty, we were ranked on page 1 for a certain keyword and now it is on page 4. Other keywords remain unaffected and the site's PR remains the same.
I think the penalty is due to to having too many inbound anchor text links being the same text?
The SEO guy informed me he bought lots of anchor links, plus he placed us on some wordpress themes (footer sponsorships).
We've told him to take down the links he bought, but what happens to all those sites linking to us now on their wordpress theme footers? Last count, we noticed thousands of domains linking back to us? There is no way we can contact these domain owners to ask them to remove their wordpress themes.
Does this mean our site will be in the penalty box forever? :(