Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from 220.127.116.11
How about running Xenu LinkSleuth over that part of the site to see what you get?
Are there any canonical issues with the URLs? Is there a problem with parameter strings being too long, or with parameters being in a different order depending on the link that was clicked.
This needs a very careful look under every rock to see what might be causing it.
I have no idea if this is normal or not. It is a soho Fantastico generated php website.
I run one of the php pages through Link Sleuth and it seems to run fine.. duration 3 seconds - 43779 size - out links 141 - in links 79 - text/html type - status ok - Apache Server.