Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from

Forum Moderators: mack

Message Too Old, No Replies


Now nothing is relevent - How do they do it?



11:43 pm on Mar 11, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

Looks like a change again!

The serps were OK ish yesterday, now they have rolled back to that junk results index they tried a few weeks back.

They must be having a laugh, nothing on MSN is currently even remotely on target now following this change.

Are they working off the sample data set they used last time?

Its such a dam shame - msn have so much potential, googles results are currently in a mess with the supplemental problems and everything else and this is a time that MSN COULD do some damage, but what do they do - roll back to that junk index they had to withdraw a few weeks back.

This morning the serps were about 70% right they are now about 2% - Amazing


6:08 pm on Apr 26, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member billys is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member

Earlier this month, my traffic from MSN came to a complete halt. After months of steady growth, MSN had grown to about 20% of traffic. This month down to about 5%, just slightly ahead of Ask (but Ask is gaining).


9:10 pm on Apr 29, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

Sites with inbounds and anchortext still stay on top consistantly. It's funny that Microsoft still hasn't used IE to track search patterns like Google toolbar. You'd think they would've done this first since IE has been around so long, I guess people get comfortable and need a kick in the ass sometimes.


5:25 am on May 3, 2006 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member

Hah, here's a laugh ...

I have a few small sites, and a mediocre blog I started up at the end of last year. One of the gadgets I reviewed on my blog was the WMS 801 weather station with MSN Direct from Oregon Scientific ...

My traffic for that story disappeared from search results quite some time ago - I assumed it was because I wasn't updating my blog enough to appear "important" to the SE's. But just for kicks I just ran a search on MSN on a phrase that used to reliably get me hits on the first page:

"WMS 801" review

The most popular result now, in four pages? Some made-for-search site that obviously posts the same article across 30-40 different properties, in exactly the same manner (note the same "viewarticle.jsp?id=38444" in all the link URLs). The properties portray themselves to be animation artist sites, digital video production sites, Mac sites, iPod sites. Total crap. Yet MSN seems to love them for its results pages.

And Google's a mess these days with the new algorithms. Yuck -- what a horrible time to be starting up new web sites and writing content.... can't get love from anyone.


2:16 pm on May 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

A month on and i thought i would have a good look at the msn serps again to see if any improvements are showing.

Bad news - i find the results are still as dire as normal. I just dont know how they do it. Its amazing how poor the msn serps are.

Do you think anyone at msn is even interested in the quaility of the serps?, or is it a case of to many yes men at msn who believe their own BS that the search is the best already and will overtake everyone because of IE7 so they dont need to pay it much attention.

A number of sites we work on rank great in msn so i should be jumping with joy, but users are just not going to stick with msn, if a search produces only 10% or 20% relevancy you are going to give up using it very quickly imo.

Poor results damage the good sites listed imo if junk or non relevent sites are listed next to your own.

As a private test, i set our home computer default page to msn from Yahoo to see if my wife (who has no internet experience) would notice the differance using the msn search bar over Yahoos. Within moments of her searching for sites on the net with the msn search bar she wanted it put back, she said she couldnt find relevent sites with it, i have now changed it back.

In closing, msn have had a good period now to do something with the search and failed. Its a complete pile of junk and imo they should just scrap it, save the money and resign with Yahoo like it was in the past before they started playing with something they are clearly out of their depth with.


8:06 pm on May 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member crobb305 is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member

Its amazing how poor the msn serps are.

You are absoultely correct. I have been emailing them about the subdomain spam for over a year now. MSNdude even specifically asked some people for examples of the subdomain spam here at WW. But nothing at all has happened to correct it. It is only getting worse. I don't think MSN has had an "update" that utilizes any algorithmic improvements in months.

Absolutely horrible, and getting to be quite humorous (if you have enough traffic from Y and G and can see the humor in the silliness that is MSN).



2:17 pm on May 8, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

MSN search is not that bad as you are saying. I been using it.
Regarding the subdomain spam. I see it has reduced now & I also agree that junk spam is there, but no one is perfect. Google also have lot of spam in it.
This 36 message thread spans 2 pages: 36

Featured Threads

Hot Threads This Week

Hot Threads This Month