Forum Moderators: not2easy

Message Too Old, No Replies

Magazine Articles Similar to Articles on My Site

They Even Have a Surrogate Me!

         

Jane_Doe

2:10 am on Dec 30, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



I picked up a magazine I don't normally read at the airport over the holidays. One of the articles was a interview with someone supposedly named Carolyn, but "Carolyn" seems to have an absolutely uncanny amount of similarities to a personal experience story I have about myself on the web -- a story that happens to be ranked number one in Google for it's main keywords.

So then I turn the pages of the magazine and the next two out of three articles are on the exact same topics as other articles on this same site of mine. The articles even refer people to the same products I sell on my site and even use the same references. In yet another article they have a very unusual quote I use on one of my other sites, so Its obvious someone is going through my sites looking for content ideas.

They were very careful to not copy any of the text exactly, but I think the amount of similarities are rather slimey, none the less, and doesn't show a tremendous amount of initiative on the magazine's part to come up with original content.

My husband calls them web scavengers - writers to lame and incompetent to find stories on their own. It is bad enough having spammers copying my articles, but to have a national magazine making up an interview for a story that in reality came from my site is pretty lazy.

So I have no point to this thread other than therapeutic venting. I'll actually probably make money from the articles because people will go to the web for more information and find my sites, but it still feels like I've been ripped off.

Essex_boy

6:49 pm on Dec 30, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Do you have the magazine still? I think id be tempted to take it a solicitor and have him/her question it with the publisher.

By the way this is the first time ive heard this sort thing happening.

hunderdown

6:55 pm on Dec 30, 2005 (gmt 0)



I agree--even if they have been paraphrasing, if they took enough recognizable and unique content, then you might have a case. At the very least, they might owe you (and their readers) an apology!

Very strange, too, that they based three articles on your content....

FrostyMug

6:59 pm on Dec 30, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



a letter to the editor should help - a post letter addressed to him. maybe reference the issue, author's name and details.

BadSense

7:00 pm on Dec 30, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Why not make a post about it on your site/blog? Sometimes pointing out what the "big guys" do can have the greatest effect of all.

On digg.com, someone posted his experience with a camera shop that treated him poorly, and the results for the business were devastating.

Don't know if this is allowed, but google 'Pricerite photo' and read the second result - it's the most-dugg piece on Digg.

Webwork

7:27 pm on Dec 30, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



I'd say a fair quid pro quo would be that they run ads to your website in their magazine for the next 6-12 issues for free.

Jane_Doe

11:40 pm on Dec 30, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Thanks for the support and suggestions.

I may just put something on my site outlining the similarities between my articles, which are several years old and have many wayback machine entries, and their recent magazine articles. At least that may give whoever is going through my sites something to think about and perhaps they'll move on to violating the copyrights on someone else's site. I've been wondering if I checked back copies of this magazine what else of mine I'd find. It's a bit creepy because they seem to be targeting my articles specifically since stuff was taken from more than one site of mine -- sites that aren't linked except for my ownership info.

Or maybe I'll put an open letter to certain magazine writers with a link to the story about Jason Blair, the New York Times reporter fired in part for plagiarizing a story from another newspaper. The good part about the Blair story is that not only did he get fired but he took a couple of the top editors with him, so it is a good warning story for both writers and editors.

This magazine is a very inexpensive one, so I do wonder if they aren't just keeping expenses low by getting all of their article ideas from the Internet.

Leva

2:12 am on Jan 10, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



They may not realize the content was stolen. If they bought the story from a writer, the writer may be at fault.