Forum Moderators: open
Another site with a good title and description in Yahoo who comes as # 1 in the SERP's got 2,625 uniques in 4 days.
This wasn't the case in the past. Yahoo has really slowed down for us and is sending less traffic than ever.
Interesting that it got on the first SERP the same time as getting the first Google listings.
See what I mean? ...you can't just say, 'I am #1 here, there, and over there, and this one gives me the most traffic', because for all we know, you might have nailed a bunch of other spin off phrases that are inflating your gross numbers for that engine.... or maybe that engine will stem words, or look at plurals and singular as the same search... you have to be careful when you compare traffic numbers... and we haven't really touched on *quality* ...if you get paid 'per click' versus 'per sale', you might value those clicks differently as well... anyway if we could put all that info together and draw some general conclusions cool... but if the question is just 'which engine sends you the most traffic' then then a similar question 'what music do you listen to?', or 'what do you like to eat?'
... both great topics for the Foo forum:)
What was interesting at the beginning of this thread is the idea that Yahoo could be the #1 referrer for so many different people, who's sites were ranked in so many different spots for so many different target deomgraphics and keywords, etc. When one site is the top referrer for the majority of respondents, regardles of the "real" deciding factors of each individual case, it makes a very strong case for that site's overall clout online.
...most definitely... not really scientific, but the evidence is so strong that it would be very difficult to argue otherwise.
As far as I'm concerned, Y! is the bomb as far as big, high quality traffic. A strong link there can float an entire business and it is much more stable than any engine as far as serp fluctuation goes...
The reason I warned (newbies) to compare apples with apples, is because the numbers and percentages that you see here can get out of wack depending on the situation... for example, you might have a domain with 5000 pages. You submit it to Y!, you get one index page in there and you nail 3 terms.... Great. BUT the same site in AV might be coming up for 500 searches and is driving more traffic...
Generally the bigger the site, the more traffic you will get in the deep crawler engines (if the pages were optimized), and therefore the lower the Y percentages will be in overall site traffic... not because you are comparing portals, but because you are comparing one link to many.
That's definitely a serious consideration... but for dynamically driven shopping sites (which may not get indexed well) and "mainstream" commercial sites, Yahoo may be continuing to beat all, traffic wise. I'm getting the feeling that Yahoo may be good at hitting the slightly more "tech savvy" end of AOL demographic...
Kinda like a large shopping mall as opposed to a specialty boutique in the "brick & mortar" world... If you're on the lookout for a very specific or unusual product, you'll go to the specialty boutique (or the crawler engine and/or specialty directories). If you're doing more general window shopping, or only have a vague category of product you're looking for, you're more likely to browse the mall (visit Yahoo)
