Forum Moderators: open

Message Too Old, No Replies

Easy Yahoo PR7+ Link - Good or Bad

Will it work

         

jamsy

12:44 pm on Nov 6, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Not seen this mentioned around the realms of webmaster world or maybe i just missed it but is this a viable/safe way to get a PR7+ link back to your site:

Create a profile on Yahoo and your profile page will be [profiles.yahoo.com...]

create a link to your site and join all the clubs relevant so that the page is kind of on topic. Then go to Google and submit that actual page.

One concern i initally have is that it obviously will be an orphan page - will this knock my theory on the head ;)

steveb

1:44 pm on Nov 6, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



That PR7 of the profile page is "guessed", not real page rank. Do what you are thinking and the Yahoo profile page pagerank will drop through the floor after the next update.

Check out a bunch of Yahoo profiles, eventually you will find some with lower PR. These will invariably be linked to other full websites (commonly geocities pages). They will then pass pagerank normally and that PR7 you thought you had will be PR4 or whatever.

Dante_Maure

2:14 pm on Nov 6, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Yahoo profiles are not legitimate PR7 pages.

They only show a PR7 due to a "toolbar guess" which is what happens when Google doesn't have enough information to assign a real PageRank.

The guess is based on how far away the page is from the root domain.

For example...

If www.randomsite.com has a real PR of 6 and the toolbar needs to make a guess it will display...

PR5 for www.randomsite.com/folder1
PR4 for www.randomsite.com/folder1/folder2
PR3 for www.randomsite.com/folder1/folder2/folder3

etc.

jamsy

2:41 pm on Nov 6, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



thanks for the info but at least it would be a PR4 link - so all in all would YOU do it yourselves so to speak or forget it has a bad idea ;)

Iguana

5:31 pm on Nov 6, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



The profiles page will only be a PR4 if you have good links to it. PR is determined by links - just being on Yahoo doesn't give you anything

Shakil

5:35 pm on Nov 6, 2002 (gmt 0)



It will probably be a guessed PR4 and from my experience will NOT count as a backlink as it is not an official PR4.

does that make sense? probably not.

Anyway, what I am saying is do NOT rely on it, and instead work on getting quality related inbound links.

Its not that difficult.

Shak

BeetleBailey

9:21 pm on Nov 6, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



What I do is link to the outside page so I know google sees it and then give myself a reciprical back.

Also found that having an outgoing link page that isn't linked to from anywhere in my site doesn't penalize me. I've been setting up lots of free exchanges with linktrade.biz and while they are all very low PR and don't show in a reverse link search they are having substantial impact on my PR, I've gotten my small site up from zero to a three on my "target" page.

Another place to get reciprical links is on a site like xanga, mention your link in the main blogging section and in the guestbook and then link from your site to the xanga pages to take advantage of their high PR. I have not found the Xanga PR to drop once it is indexed by google, so I don't think the yahoo link would drop either. I'm going to give the yahoo a try, thanks for the suggestion.

mykel

9:22 pm on Nov 6, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Sam thing with geocities sites. I have one that hase a guessed pagerank of 6. Added a link to another of my sites a couple of months back, just in case it would work. The link hasn't shown up yet and well..never will I guess.

steveb

4:54 am on Nov 7, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



jamsy when I said "page rank 4 or whatever" I meant the profile will only deliver you a sort of phantom PR. If you link to it from a PR4 page on your site, you will transfer the according page rank to the profile, probably making it a PR2 or PR3. If you then link back to your site from the profile you will be pointing a PR2 or PR3 link at a PR4 site. In other words, basically no value.

Now if you put a photo of Britney Spears in your profile, and get a bunch of other people to link to it, then you could extract a positive out of the profile page. Otherwise its just smoke and mirrors.

Also, back to your original question, yahoo clubs are also usually that phantom PR. If there aren't backward links to a club shown, the PR in the toolbar means nothing, so getting links from clubs is usually no help. On the other hand, if the clubs are on topic, no harm having your link there.

bluecorr

9:07 pm on Dec 27, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



>It will probably be a guessed PR4 and from my experience >will NOT count as a backlink as it is not an official PR4.

Sorry to bring this back but I have seen such a Yahoo profile count as a backlink, e.g be listed in Google's link list when doing link:www.domain.com. Also, some profiles are linked from members.yahoo.com. Can anyone tell me how can it show as a backlink since it's an extrapolated PR?

nell

9:29 pm on Dec 27, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



.

[edited by: nell at 9:35 pm (utc) on Dec. 27, 2002]

bluecorr

9:33 pm on Dec 27, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Sorry, I don't see how this answers why a yahoo profile shows as backlink.

BigDave

9:38 pm on Dec 27, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



As my site started as a as a yahoo group, all the members are also yahoo members. Last month I noticed that one of our member's profile was actually counted as a backlink with a PR3 (yes, a PR3 backlink)

He did have his profile set up as public and has us listed as a cool site.

We are now conducting an experiment with several of our profiles to see how we can affect things with it. It appears that the majoriey of the PR comes from the message pages from the discussion lists that contain a link to the profile page of the poster, but it will take several months to come to a definitive conclusion.

Is it worth it to have one page with low PR pointing to your site? Not really. But we have a couple thousand members, many of whom are active in several Yahoo groups. A few hundred PR3-4 links can be quite worthwhile. They can also give their own homepage a link and then link their page to ours if they wish.

So there are cases where it maks sense to go to the effort. But in the case of commercial sites, or if you don't participate in any of the groups that will give you all those PR1 links from the archives for free, then I wouldn't bother.

<added>Oh yeah, don't even bother to submit it to google. If they do not find enough links to it, it will not make the cut. And if they do, then you don't need to submit it in the first place</added>

kevinpate

9:58 pm on Dec 27, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



seems to me if this was effective, then wouldn't every single mondo spammy page on the web have readily visible and observable backlinks to scads and scads of such profile pages? After all, it wouldn't take a lot of time for someone to decides to create multiple accts at that portal's freemail area. What's that? Only one such freebie email acct or ID to a customer? Oh yeah, and now, let's talk a touch about this bridge that's for sale ...I hear it used to be somewhat fancied by some folks over Brooklyn way.

Might be a better use of time to seek out, or hey, why not even, maybe, sorta consider creating some new original content.

As Charles once said via Snoopy - he who lives by the dirty little dropshot, dies by the dirty little dropshot.

BigDave

12:15 am on Dec 28, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



kevinpate,

You're right if it was a PR7, but like I said, you have to be active with the account in groups with public archives. Just setting up the accounts does not do you any good.

And in the case of sites where you really do have a lot of active members that are willing to list you as one of their cool links, then it is not spam! It is hundreds of individual people putting a link on a page that they control, to a site that they really do think is "cool", otherwise they would not be spending so much of their time at that site in the first place.

It would be a huge waste of time for a single person to try and influence their ranking this way. But if you have an already active account, then it is certainly not a waste to spend 30 seconds to add a link to your page.

stuntdubl

1:20 am on Dec 28, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Generally the answer to any "will it work" question for easy PR is ......

NO. Someone else already tried it:)

Build good pages. Add content. Add Content.

steveb

3:21 am on Dec 28, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Answered this once before, but will try again... a yahoo profile is like any page on any domain. It has guessed page rank. It can get real page rank via links.

I can link a PR6 page to my Yahoo profile. The Yahoo profile will then become PR5 (or maybe PR4). I then link it back to my PR6 Page (or any page), and it will show as a PR5 backlink.

This accomplishes basically nothing.