Forum Moderators: open
I don't think size is as important as relevance to the term. The 5-10K rule I think is more as a benefit for the visitors for easy downloading of the pages. Otherwise, we won't be seeing sites with big sizes being at the top for several years now.
I would say create your site first and foremost for your audience, making sure that you have the kind of content that would attract and keep them coming back for more. Then strive to be an authority in your area, and the search engines will most definitely find you -- even if you have 50K.
It also helps that if you have create 10 different pages of 10k size, that is 10 times as many pages that can possibly rank for any given SERP then if you have one 100k page. And as mentioned, there are still a lot of folks on dial up. Consider how long a 100k page can take to load if the surfer on dial up is at the same moment downloading a Britney Spears MP3 on a P2P client?
" Based on all of the Enzyte ads I see in Google, I would have to say that size matters. "The pages that rank well for my kewords are bigger than 10K. The top one is 200k bu has approx. 84 backlinks. I suppose this factor is more important than the size of the pages.
I think you missed my joke ... look up Enzyte and you'll get it :)