Forum Moderators: open
to be honest I think it would be great of something like that became easily publically available. It would force Google to turn off PR in the directory and on the toolbar and only use it internally. The web could go back to 'normal' and there would be no prejudice when linking. It would be the end of PR bigotry.
Just my controversial 2 cents for a Saturday morning :)
Just a question...
What's the point of retrieving the PR from elsewhere?
Is it just so one doesn't have to use the toolbar or is it some manner to artificially adjust PR?
Sorry if this is a dumb question, I just want to understand. :)
Google ignores the fact that there are more Browsers than IE and more OSes than Win.
In any case, I remain of the opinion that the PR displayed by the toolbar is largely irrelevant. If someone were to offer to swap links with me I would not use the toolbar to check PR I would use AllTheWeb to check backlinks. Slower but far more informative and reliable. The only problem with this is that ATW counts javascript links but Google still does not (a damned poor show by Google if you ask me).
Kaled.
It has been said in another thread that the hash code is stored in the IE cache but I don't think this is of much use except to repeatedly check the PR of a given url.
I have not investigated this myself, so I cannot say definitively that the above is correct.
Kaled.
PS
I am not aware of any way to filter out javascript backlinks on ATW. Depending on how the ATW index is maintained, this information is probably not available.
PPS
You could check cracking sites. Someone may have thrown a debugger at the Google toolbar and worked out how to calculate PR. I'm certain that many people will have tried and I doubt it would be that difficult a problem.
There was a thread in 2002 about a program called PRMaster. This performed PR checking programatically. However, GoogleGuy apparently persuaded the author to withdraw the program. Whether GG applied Kofi Annan's philosophy to the negotiations is unclear.
Kaled.
With regard to (toolbar) PR, I've already decided that it is next to worthless. I've uninstalled the toolbar since I consider the auto-update feature to be a backdoor for viruses, however, I cannot say more otherwise this thread is likely to be deleted.
Kaled.
Why do you consider pagerank worthless?
I didn't say that. I said that I consider toolbar PR to be next to worthless. As a software developer, I have to be super paranoid about viruses. If I feel I need access to toolbar PR I'll have have to set up another entirely isolated computer. Right now, the effort required is not worth the reward. The toolbar does not reliably report PR. In the last six months my own site has been zeroed for around three months. This may well explain why a few sites I have have requested links from have not even replied.
As I have said in other threads, I don't believe that the toolbar is reporting the PR used by Google to return results. Again, as a programmer, I understand what sort of bugs are likely in a piece of code. Out-of-date and zero PRs being reported are not bugs that I would consider likely if the Toolbar were generally reporting true PR. The PR feature of the Toolbar is nothing more than an elaborate and modestly convincing con-trick.
Ask yourself this. Why don't Google simply place the PR indicators used in the directory on all their results? Answer : because they want people to use the toolbar. There could possibly be a technical reason. In the old days, it might have been necessary to use the PR of the previous dance but that's all. Now I guess it might be necessary to show PR that is ~3 weeks out of date but that is all.
The PR feature of the toolbar is bait and webmasters have bitten. What more can I say?
Kaled.