Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from 22.214.171.124
However, I've been turned down by Fastclick and Casale Media. Both of them give me generic responses to why I wasn't accepted.
I WAS accepted by realtech media, but I'm very displeased with them. I've also heard some bad stuff about the company.
This is a bit discouraging. I always thought that a site getting a good bit of traffic (over 10 mil pageviews monthly) wouldn't have any trouble being accepted to ad companies.
I have now been educated.
My site is a 'super-niche'. It's console gaming. Most of my visitors are teens and young adults, although I do have an older crowd as well.
I KNOW that I could make money selling video games and accessories that were correctly targeted. It burns me as well that I could even DO the targeting, but I can't find any company that does this sort of thing.
What I really need:
1. To find a company that will provide me with highly targeted ad banners for video games and accessories that I could sort through and choose from.
2. A company that would allow me to make my own ad banners for their game products.
I feel for certain that I could make something like that successful.
Another killer is that I've seen ads running on some gaming sites that are amazing, and perfectly targeted to my audience, but I have NO EARTHLY idea who serves those ads, and haven't had any luck finding out.
I thought that Ebay affiliation might be my answer, but as it is, their ads are generalized and unnactractive, and my question as to whether I could create my own banners was met with, "Well, you can try to run those banner images by our approval department, but it will take two to three weeks for a response." What the heck is that about?!
Sorry about the frustration. It's just amazing to me how hard it is to get people to allow you to sell their stuff.
When I first started out, I sent very nicely written letters to about 10 gaming companies asking for an ad contract. I quoted them a price that is laughably low (I make twice the amount per day with Google that I was asking per MONTH back then), and I only got a response from one company.
Ugh. I better stop. ;)
And Amazon converts well because so many people know them already.
They allow you to very easily drill down to the 'per product' promotion level. I'm not a 100% sure of what offers they currently have in your arena, but they may be a good resource to check in to.
Also, you should look into other types of products that would target your audience. Music, Videos, DVDs, etc. that may be relevant to the young audience that you have. Try to capitalize on the demographic as a whole, not just the 'super-niche' of your site.