Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from

Forum Moderators: Webwork & skibum

Message Too Old, No Replies

What utilities do you like to see in a directory?



1:19 pm on Jul 25, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

Iam looking for some innovative directory features :

Search (good and bad)
Include Pic of front pages of sites

Any other features you can suggest?


7:34 pm on Jul 25, 2005 (gmt 0)

Can't think of anything. Everything's been done:

Site pictures - been done
Reviews - done
sponsored listings - done
News & Articles - also done
Whatever niche info - done

done done and done.

All done hundreds of times over. I have the list of every worthwhile directory there is - that's how I know. Don't waste cash or time on building a directory, if you can't beat the Thomsons/Yell.com of the world. You're more than likely going to get crushed by the majors. You gotta think like a major investor would think. What questions would they ask, when considering buying a directory. Also (like another post) nothing is free anymore, and to stand any chance of 'making it' is to have something so unique - people will kill each other to get a listing in yours, and I don't mean niche directories either. That isn't enough anymore to make it on the web.

That's reality ok. Do something original for once, and then if it's good enough, it'll get some press interest. But press interest don't mean you'll be stinking rich, so just be careful.

Hope this answers your question


7:49 pm on Jul 25, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

Although eventKings answer is a little harsh (probably because your post seems like an opening for some spamming) he is mostly correct. Bells and whistles have pretty much been worked to death. It's not the glitz that's going to make you a successful directory.

Where I disagree is that you can't compete with the monsters already out there. That is only true if you are talking about a directory of the entire web. Don't bother.

If you are talking a niche directory you can compete. In my niche there simply isn't a decent niche directory. My niche directory is less than 6 months old and it's already driving 10-15% of the traffic on the site. I attribute this to a combination of a fairly good domain name, fairly good SEO and an underserved niche.

It certainly isn't due to bells and whistles. My only feature (besides the listings) is priority placement.



10:06 pm on Jul 25, 2005 (gmt 0)

Yep, the Generals is what I meant. Niche info sources can work - you still need money though to make anything decent. It's easier if you are a very good web designer, as this keeps costs down majorly - unfortunately most aren't or can't web design, and is part of the problem when setting up a web business.

I've made mistakes when deciding on what web design to have, and this costs me every time I need webby work done. Directories and SE's aren't cheap to set up, despite what others on here will tell you. I'm telling you as a non-designer, it's very expensive indeed. You don't necessarily need bells and whistles to make something good (dmoz.....), but sometimes a little glitz can add a nice touch - just don't over do it though. I see money in travel in some way, I could be wrong.

Let's take a look at what's been done to death:

On the SE front we have Yahoo, Google and MSN. Ask, AOL and Webcrawler. The searcher is more than catered for here, without even looking at the 2nd Tiers and Vortals. And not forgetting PPC! Shopping Portals have been done to death - I feel. Some majors were bought up, need I say anymore.... Travel sites, same as above. What does that tell you.

Even Women portals are done and dusted. I must say that this is really about the Generals though, perhaps niche is the answer - and once again, I don't think directories are the way to go. I seem to remember though that some time ago a major womens insurance company started up........ That's the kind of thing I'm talking about, a real wanted service. Hobby sites, new kinds of forums or info sites (non SE).


4:48 pm on Jul 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

more than on market niches and competing against big directories, I was looking for innovative ideas in directory presentation and directory utilities that can increase stickiness and user participation

Frequent -- why do you say my initial post was an intent to spam?


5:27 pm on Jul 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

Frequent has it right.
A niche directory, even with one bell...and a whistle on the way, will (if not overdone) do VERY well. It seems to me that most directories lately want to sell the whole pie and sooooo.. many people are only looking for a slice. And if that slice has a nice bell/whistle topping, people will come back for more. My advice (from personal experience only) is to build up your directory on a part time/unpaid hobby basis and see what your feedback is.
For me:
Ratings...not worth diddly squat
Real comments/reviews from users...worth there weight in gold
Thumb pics of homepages...never did get that one!

If i am looking for something in particular and i have absolutely NO idea "where to look"....first stop..major SEs
If i am looking for a niche product, i will always (if it has substance) go to a niche SE first, and if no luck.....what the hell, the major SEs are always in the background rubbing their hands.
Otherwise, it is difficult to suggest any innovative features without actually knowing what your directory is about. And if your like me, you won't disclose that information until you have a good solid/meaty directory (in my case, circa 2009!)


6:38 pm on Jul 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

Let the fun and games commence. I never tell anyone about my directory, because I know what people say.

"Good luck mate" or "You own a directory, ok so what's so special about it?" Others laugh, or take the mickey - which is why I don't bother to mention it much. Because I know if it were to fail, people will only say "I told you so" etc - the fact is many will fail, run out of cash, aand never get enough exposure, so it can be as niche as you want, but it's just not enough to be niche anymore, it has to get millions of visitors per month to be considered worthy of investment or stand a chance in selling it to advertisers.

I could beat Yell's technology in a second, but they are established and would kill me in terms of reach and distribution. People will go for the reach every time, as this gets them eyeballs/visitors, then they can charge 500 per year. Niches just don't have that reach (apart from 1). That's the whole show.

It takes mountains of cash or a great idea, none of these niches or generals have either. This is going to be funny to see who's still around in 7 years time. Mine's in it's 3rd year already - and I'm thinking about calling it a day, as nothing prepared me for what's involved. I ran out of cash, have no investor and can't continue to run it. This is exactly what I'm talking about! But people are just so hypnotised with the ease of the web, it just totally screws you one way or another.


6:40 pm on Jul 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

I didn't say your initial post was intent to spam. I said it sounded much like many thinly veiled spam posts from the past.

For example:

I just developed a machine that can carve a bust of "Larry King" (insert your favorite celebrity here) out of butter for only a dollar. I plan to sell the butter busts for $9.99 each on my web site. I go to as many forums as possible and say, "I really need to find a place where I can order a bust of larry king. It needs to be made of butter and cost less than $10."

Of course, everyone wants to help so they all rush to their favorite search engine and punch in the obviously relevant keywords from your post and voila. A bunch of people finding your site and a bunch more saying they found exactly what you need at example.com

That is what I meant.



1:23 pm on Jul 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

Is anyone giving the usage stats for each page?
IMHO, it may be a good showcasing if your directory is fairly popular, and in a corner of each page you provide page stats such as, avg. page views (of that particular page), search engine bound traffic, date of page creation, and few others if you can think of. Must be pretty handy for people who submit and a USP at that?


4:37 pm on Jul 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

McMohan, usage stats are a good idea actually. How would you implement this, via a javascript?

Would indirect linking be a couner productive in terms of SEO. IE would it be better to let google know to which sites you are linking.

The other option would be collecting the stats from the logs ...

The date when the page was last updated would be good as well, I notice DMOZ implements that.


6:37 pm on Jul 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

Usage stats are only good for site owners personal monitoring. Having them won't entice punters to spend money nor be enough of a tool to rake in the visitors.

Think about 'Pulling Power', and this will get you back on the right track. Bells and Whistles are okay, but ultimately people will visit for useful information. Stats will only work if you have thousands upon thousands per listing/entry or whatever.

Once you have that - then you have something to shout about. Until then concentrate on quality content.Lot's of different types is required as you need to make your site sticky. What about some tools? News, A to Z something or other, Comparison software? use your imagination and get creative. Using Stats is only copying someone else, ain't original or particularly useful unless the stats are attatched to tons and oodles of content. Better to have lot's of types of content with say 500 in each, than few content areas with tons of stuff. Go for quality over quantity.

Sticky, sticky sticky.


6:38 pm on Jul 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

Content is King!


5:39 am on Jul 28, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

Usage stats are only good for site owners personal monitoring. Having them won't entice punters to spend money nor be enough of a tool to rake in the visitors.

As a webmaster who is submitting a site -

Page Views: I will know how many exposures my listing will get if I submitted my site.

Search Engine bound Traffic to Page: I will know how many of the page views are as a result of search engine queries, and thus targeted (vis-a-vis e-mail promos, banners etc) and how good the website is faring in search engines which is again a signal of quality.

Date of Page Creation: If I see a PR zero for the page, I will know if the page has gone through a pagerank updation cycle or not.

Content, Tools all fine but if the usage stats can benefit in someway and can act as a USP that makes webmasters talk about it in forums, why not provide it?

Added: cicru, I don't know how to go about implementing it for am not a programming man. But, it should be fairly easy to customize and integrate the website to provide stats from web analystics.


Featured Threads

Hot Threads This Week

Hot Threads This Month