Forum Moderators: open

Message Too Old, No Replies

Looking for a basic, sane printer

Are you paying through the nose for ink cartridges?

         

luckychucky

4:20 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I got a free HP Deskjet 5550 with my Mac. But the cartridges have really wimpy capacity, and cost a fortune to replace. They're like crack dealers..the first hit is free, then they own you.

I tried refilling the cartridges myself, which worked for a while. Now when I try to print in MSWord their software says I can't because the (newly refilled) cartridge is 'Empty', but in all other apps it prints just fine...

I've been fantasizing about a simple black-and-white-only printer whose only function is to crank out invoices and documents, where photo resolution and anything above decent readable quality are really unnecessary. And it would have a huge tank of ink, like a liter bottle or something, you'd just overturn and let it print for a month or two between refills...

I think if anyone tried it, he'd myseriously vanish, end up at the bottom of a river or in a hole in the desert. Planned obsolescence rules the planet, that's why we're choking on our own waste. Ever see the movie 'Tucker'?

On the other hand, if any company had the cojones to manufacture and market such a printer, they'd rapidly dominate the market. But I dream

digitalv

4:24 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



One of my smarter moves was going to color laser. I picked up a Minolta Magicolor 2300 DL off ebay for about $350 brand new. The quality was impressive. The toner cartridges aren't cheap (around $70 for "high capacity") but it lasts about 6 times longer than ink so ultimately it ends up being far less expensive, and just prints out better overall. I'll never buy another ink jet again.

luckychucky

4:33 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Hmm...so I pay $350 up front for the equivalent of around $11.65 per cartridge.

I guess it's better, but I'm still not ecstatic, truth be told. I want it all. Why can't I have it all?

[edited by: luckychucky at 4:34 am (utc) on July 17, 2004]

digitalv

4:34 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Yeah but dude, come on, color freaking laser :) heh

luckychucky

4:38 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I dunno what you do for a living. Maybe you're a graphic designer. Think of all the workhorse businesses out there who need a basic workhorse printer-- off the top of my head: dentists, auto repair, picture framers, whatever. They just need to economically print frigging invoices all day long, reams and reams of them.

digitalv

4:48 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Nah, I'm not a graphic designer I just hate inkjets they're messy. Plus its cool for printing 8x10's and framing them.

If you're really just looking for a workhorse printer get a black & white laser (which is what those offices you were referring to usually use) or a dot matrix. Believe it or not, dot matrix printers are still around and still widely used for high volume printing. But for you a black & white laser might be the best option - you can get them for under $100 on ebay.

ogletree

4:54 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



They do this because 1 they are greedy and 2 they don't make money on the printers. They make money on consumables. Also they are having a hard time with the refil and recycleing people. That hurts there bottom line. I know a guy that refills toner and ink. It is a constant battle with printer companies. They put features on there toner and ink for the sole reason to foil the recycleing guys. It is the American Way. Our whole econamy is based on everybody ripping everybody else off. It's the whole greed is good thing. Every industry has something like this. Americans are stupid (I am one). We want to be lied to. We have stores here that have everything on sale 75% of the year and give out coupons and have big events every weekend. That seems to be what we want. We won't buy anything unless it is on sale. Never mind that it is always on sale. We have laws that stop the stores from having them on sale every day. They would if they could. I have seen stores that have been going out of business for 3 years. Our polititions lie to us and our stores lie to us. We just come to expect it.

luckychucky

5:06 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



ogletree:
Test-i-fy, brother!

digitalv:
Are these eBay printers old models or do they still manufactiure them? Also, know of a good brand and/or model number by any chance? How about OSX compatibility? Ink cost? Printing speed?
Question, questions, questions.

ogletree

5:15 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Watch out for durms. Stay away from printers with drums they will kill you. I found that the HP 1012 to be a pretty good deal for low budget. In the long run the 2300 was cheaper but has a higher initial output.

Remember Drums are a rip off. They sale really cheap sub $200 at the store printers. Often times it is cheaper to buy a brnad new one that comes with a drum and toner than it does to buy a drum and toner.

digitalv

5:31 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I don't know about that, the drum I have on the 2300 DL will do 60,000 pages before it needs to be replaced.

Do a search on ebay for "laser printer" - you'll find many brand new in the box and many of them are models that are still produced today. I could walk into Office Depot right now and buy this Magicolor 2300 DL for $799. Most laser printers will work with a Mac. The 2300 DL has a built in network card too, you can probably find similar printers in black & white.

Toner cartridges are on the high side, but you can also buy toner in a bottle and refill it yourself. Of course every printer manufacturer tells you that doing this is the equivalent of selling your soul to the devil, but screw em :)

ogletree

5:34 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



I was not talking about high end and/or color that is different. The point is check to see how much a toner and a drum cost if it is more than the printer then just think of it as disposable.

uncle_bob

10:11 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



For just black and white work, a laser printer will be cheaper hands down. Where an ink cartidge may do 500 pages, for only twice the price you can get toner that will do at least 3000 pages (some do 6000!).

I'd recommend you have a look at lasers from brother and hp. Check the initial unit price, the cost of replacement toner, and how many pages the toner will do. Some cheaper lasers have much more expensive toner, so take care choosing.

Leosghost

11:46 am on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



hey guys ..a color cartridge for HP .at 42 ml or grms whichever you want to measure it is 64$ wher I live ..
Discounted has to be sent in from Belgium and thats refilled stuff done in China ..costs 45$ ...

do your own with the syringe works out at 25$ ..and is actually better quality ink ...( tho like you say lots of progs then decide your cartridge is empty ..OVERIDE THE THING and print anyway ) ..

Digitalv ...if I told you how much even on Ebay .we have to pay for the kind of stuff you are talking about ..you'd want to start shipping to France ..trouble is the shipping and the customs and the tva etc ..

Already I ship so much stuff in because of how much we have to pay for things that the rest of you take for granted as cheap ...

[edited by: Leosghost at 12:40 pm (utc) on July 17, 2004]

luckychucky

12:19 pm on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Hey leosghost,

>>...( tho like you say lots of progs then decide you cartridge is empty ..OVERIDE THE THING and print anyway ) ..

HOW? I tried everything I could. I'm using an awful HP Deskjet 5550. Please tell me the magic secret.

<snip>

[edited by: Macguru at 12:24 pm (utc) on July 17, 2004]
[edit reason] Lets try to stay on topic, please. [/edit]

PCInk

12:28 pm on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



If you want to simply print invoices then a laser is definately the way to go. You will normally find that laser printers with separate drum and toners (rather than cheap HP/Canon) are cheaper to run.

Note that there is no point in buying most HP laser printers: They are made by Canon and the Canon ones are cheaper as are the consumables.

> But the cartridges have really wimpy capacity, and cost a fortune to replace.
You will find that on the first cartridge (supplied with the machine) for almost any manufacturer. It reduces costs and you need to buy a cartridge almost instantly. The manufacturers "do not make a profit on the printers". That statement is not actually true - most make a loss and make the profit on the cartridges.

Because they need to sell the cartridges to get the money back, they are priced highly.

Buying a top end machine means you pay a lot more for the printer - but in that market sector, the manufacturer can make money (there is less competition) on the printer. The cartridges can be much better value for money.

Try to avoid looking at the price of the printer. Look only at the price of the consumables (difficult, but it helps with money in the long run).

But don't forget that some printers can now take:

** Inkjet cartridges (remember that the printheads may be separate - extra costs)

** Many inkjet cartridges (some take 7 or 8, but remember that when the yellow runs out - you are not throwing away half a cartridge of magenta)

** Toner cartridges (remember to add in drum costs and other items)

** Color toner cartridges (remember that there are at least four toners and usually two or four drums. There may be developer kits, maintenence kits, waste toner bottles...etc - work them all out to see if it is worthwhile).

Parts can sometimes be expensive: One Kyocera printer used to sell for £250 (UK), but a replacement drum cost £240.

Refilling cartridges (especially inkjet) is not a good idea unless you know exactly what you are doing. HP/Lexmark should be normally OK, but Canon/Epson/Xerox can be much more difficult. You will not notice until you find that the ink has damaged the printhead (often a spare part, totally overpriced for these machines and tremendously difficult to get hold of).

P.S. Expect refilling modern cartridges to be very difficult. Manufacturers are trying to stop compatibles on the market and are trying every trick in the book. These include page counters and date recognition (some cartridges will automatically stop working after a certain date!).

charlier

12:45 pm on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Have a look around for an old Panasonic KX1150 dot matrix. The print quality is excellent and they last forever. I had a couple I used to publish a video tape rental newsletter and I used to let it print 24 hours a day. I gave one to my nephew and he is still using it.

luckychucky

1:33 pm on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



charlier:
How's the ink (toner?) cost on a Panasonic KX1150, and do you think they'll ever discontinue supplying for it?

Bummer. Just searched eBay for
> Panasonic KX1150 dot matrix <
and came up with zero results.

PCInk

3:00 pm on Jul 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



- if you are going to buy Panasonic, make sure that you have at least 1 years worth of consumables on the shelf. They are the worst company for items being unavailable (6 months delivery estimates on some of their products is deemed as 'quick').

P.S. Dot Matrix use ribbons, and are noisy - so it depends where and when the printer will be used as to whether that will be practical (but duplicates are easy and cheap by using two, three or four part listing paper).