Forum Moderators: open

Message Too Old, No Replies

The excrementification of search, social media etc.

Doctorow uses a slightly different word...

         

ronin

10:32 pm on Feb 5, 2023 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



I always have time for Cory Doctorow but his analysis here is equal to some of the best stuff he's ever written:

The ‘Enbleepification’ of TikTok
[wired.com...]

The article is well worth reading. Here are just a few gems...

Doctorow summarises the lifecycle of popular online platforms:

Surpluses are first directed to users; then, once they're locked in, surpluses go to suppliers; then once they're locked in, the surplus is handed to shareholders and the platform becomes a useless pile of bleep.


Doctorow summarises the state of FB:

Today, Facebook is terminally enbleepified, a terrible place to be whether you're a user, a media company, or an advertiser. It's a company that deliberately demolished a huge fraction of the publishers it relied on, defrauding them into a "pivot to video" based on false claims of the popularity of video among Facebook users. [...] But Facebook has a new pitch. It claims to be called Meta, and it has demanded that we live out the rest of our days as legless, sexless, heavily surveilled low-poly cartoon characters. It has promised companies that make apps for this metaverse that it won't rug them the way it did the publishers on the old Facebook. It remains to be seen whether they'll get any takers.


Doctorow summarises what we've seen with online platforms (not least Google Search) time and again since the late nineties:

Once you understand the enbleepification pattern, a lot of the platform mysteries solve themselves. Think of the SEO market, or the whole energetic world of online creators who spend endless hours engaged in useless platform Kremlinology, hoping to locate the algorithmic tripwires, which, if crossed, doom the creative works they pour their money, time, and energy into.

Working for the platform can be like working for a boss who takes money out of every paycheck for all the rules you broke, but who won't tell you what those rules are because if he told you that, then you'd figure out how to break those rules without him noticing and docking your pay. Content moderation is the only domain where security through obscurity is considered a best practice.

Sgt_Kickaxe

7:47 am on Feb 6, 2023 (gmt 0)



I disagree with him, I think mainstream media has become the source of excement and it's infecting everything else. I literally just posted about it before reading this post, what do you think? [webmasterworld.com...]

ronin

12:51 pm on Feb 6, 2023 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Fair enough. I've replied to the thread you referenced above.

(TLDR: My take is: there's no such thing as mainstream media).

Can we discuss Doctorow's piece in this thread? (Please read it - it's really good.)

[wired.com...]

I think mainstream media has become the source of excement


He's not talking about the relative merits of the content to be found on social media / social sharing / social performance platforms.

He's talking about how the business model of such platforms metamorphoses over time.

And that we have so many examples of this metamorphosis now (from the last twenty years), we can draw and describe the common outline of it.

That outline is remarkably more consistent and predictable than any of us would be forgiven for thinking.

Genuinely, it's an articulate and fascinating analysis.

not2easy

1:43 pm on Feb 6, 2023 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



That is an excellent analysis of observations of various platforms in social media and eCommerce. How and why they morph into increasingly useless time drains that slowly choke off what you found inviting and attractive about them. Things we sort of knew but the slow change makes it almost unnoticed by their hostages. Thank you!