Forum Moderators: open

Message Too Old, No Replies

Google may be sued by Philip K. Dick's estate

         

travelin cat

3:37 pm on Jan 7, 2010 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



From cnet:

Google's operating system is called Android and its new phone, unveiled to hysteria rather than hisses Tuesday, is called Nexus One. Might the idea for these names have been spawned by a Google Book Club reading of Dick?

"We feel this is a clear infringement of our intellectual-property rights," Isa Dick Hackett, a daughter of Phillip K. Dick told the Journal.

Full story here. [news.cnet.com]

Propools

4:08 pm on Jan 7, 2010 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



In 1968, when the book was first published there were no cell phones.
I think the whole lawsuit thing would be a farce.

Google is the connection point, the "tie" for many people on the internet. It seems like a natural move to name the phone Nexus and Nexus One as it being the first.
Maybe the team did get some ideas from the book but certainly the book did not drive the technology nor the intellectual property associated with the phone. But if we look at the open handset alliance [openhandsetalliance.com] it's clear that it's not just a google "thang".

I don't want to confuse the whole intellectual-property issue with the technology of the phone but it doesn't even seem to come close to a legal case. This is so absurd that the phone is already referenced in Wikipedia from a NY Times article on Dec 21, 2009.

IMHO - The bigger the wallet, the greater the chance of lawsuits filed for nonsensical minutia.

LifeinAsia

4:49 pm on Jan 7, 2010 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Why not sure the U.S. Customs and Border Protection for its NEXUS Program? Why no sure World of Warcraft because of it's Nexus dungeon? Why not sue any number of other technology companies with Nexus in their names?

Sorry, but the origin of "nexus" predates Dick by several hundred years. Was the term "Nexus 6" ever copyrighted by Dick or his estate? Not that I can see. Dick used the word "the" in his writings. Does that mean no one can ever use "the" in a brand name?

This is definitely an instance where I would love to see the initiator of the suit given a massive fine for wasting the court's time for such a frivolous lawsuit.