Forum Moderators: skibum

Message Too Old, No Replies

CJ.com not accepting Indian and Chinese publishers

Commission junction is no longer accepting signups from India and China!

         

vik_c

3:54 pm on Nov 18, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Commission junction no longer has 'China' and 'India' in its drop down option for publisher sign up.

Shutting their eyes to two of the largest countries in the world?

Mike_Mackin

4:06 pm on Nov 18, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Just get a USA [mbe.com] address.
Will help with Yahho! as well.

theposter

4:29 pm on Nov 18, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Not a very good idea to get a USA address as u then need to post TAX info, and if you were to post such an address they would send checks to u at that address i supose...hmm...dismal scenario....what dd the indians do wrong here?

jackofalltrades

4:36 pm on Nov 18, 2002 (gmt 0)



Have they given any reason for this?

JOAT

profitpuppy

9:17 pm on Nov 19, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I live in Australia, and because of this have been declined from many affiliate programs that I wanted to join. I'm thinking of getting a US mailing address ... this is easy ... you can get the mail forwarded to wherever you want in the world, but yes, then problem I see is whether you then have to get a US tax number ... which is a bad idea for a number of reasons ... certainly it's not a good idea to be in the IRS tax database if you don't have to be.

If anyone has some suggesstions on this it would be much appreciated.

vik_c

2:54 pm on Nov 22, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Amazing! CJ accepts applicants from Nepal, Pakistan, Western Sahara, Tunisia, Niue, Guadeloupe, Congo and every little speck and dot on this planet except India and China!

arunkw

1:17 pm on Dec 29, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Huh .....I couldn't tell you how much I hate to see "India"
not listed in the affiliate list in many of the Affiliate Programs
I have requested in my personal mails to all the "contact us" and "support" emails of these various Affiliate program sites to list India in their affiliate list.
I wanted to join affiliate program and like me their might be others who would prove to be a potential revenue generators to the respective affiliate programs.
I stay in metropolitian city mumbai and have various bank a/c in various international as well as local banks.
but still this is of no use here...

"Oh god please forgive them cos they don't know what they
have done and are missing .......$"

Thanks
Arun Kumar

[edited by: heini at 10:30 pm (utc) on Dec. 29, 2002]
[edit reason] no sigs please (see your mail at top of screen) thanks! [/edit]

vibgyor79

1:55 pm on Dec 29, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Does CJ still have CPM and CPC affiliate programs?

There is a general perception that affiliates from India and China try to cheat the merchants. From the comments of certain WebmasterWorld members, it looks like there is a perception that all Indian/Chinese credit card purchases are fraudulent too.

See thread [webmasterworld.com...]

Unless there is a sea change in merchants' perception, affiliates/customers from India and China will remain blacklisted.

digitalbrain

2:47 pm on Dec 29, 2002 (gmt 0)



I think CJ's decision is extremely correct.
The reasons are
1. High rate of unemployment in india
2. Cheapest internet access in the world
3. Chepest telephony ( land-line ) in the world ( Recently Started at Rs 0.4 per minute. 1USD=48INR comes to around $0.008 per minute)
4. Low density of Credit Cards
5. Low Per Capita Income with zero purchasing power

if cj allow indian publishers the unemploed will flock to the browsing centers with which just a one click will earn more than thay spend for the cybercafe per hour.
Also due to the above reasons the clicks will not lead to any returns for the buyer thus ensuring the low return on investments...

After all US economy should not be diluted because of indians.. same thing applies to china in much more way where mobile phone population is the highest in the world and is the biggest market for second hand mobile phones

vibgyor79

3:24 pm on Dec 29, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Sorry. Your arguments don't make sense.

1) If a guy is smart enough to join CPC affiliate programs and get around the anti-fraud systems in place, he WOULD NOT be unemployed.

2) Really? Then why is internet penetration so low in India? I hear only five percent of computer users have an internet connection. If you are referring to those cyber cafes that charge Rs.10 per hour, I'm sure that no self-respecting affiliate/publisher would go to cyber cafes to generate income for himself.

3) Huh? Which one? Reliance Infocomm?

4) and 5) Yep. But that doesn't explain why CJ should ban Indian affiliates. Indian affiliates don't BUY - they SELL.

As mentioned before, I feel its just a perception problem.

CJ should allow merchants from all countries. If they are worried about their CPC/CPM/pay per lead merchants, they should allow merchants to filter out affiliates from certain countries.

Pay for performance/pay per sale merchants will never have problems with any affiliates.

buckworks

9:29 pm on Dec 29, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



It might make sense for merchants to flag certain applicants for hand review before acceptance, but automatic rejection seems both heavy-handed and short-sighted to me. I'm Canadian and I get my share of those ...

I have occasionally written "please take a closer look" notes with good results. But a surprising number of merchants seem to think the web site owner's country of residence is the only place the site's traffic will come from. Yeesh!

profitpuppy

10:01 pm on Dec 29, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



As I say it is not just India. I have been rejected from australia, and then went to one of their competing sites and now generating tens of thousands of dollars of revenue. It is a short-sighted attitude to reject affiliates. I agree however that it might be reasonable to reject indian affiliate for a cost per click program, but not for cost per action programs.

vibgyor79

4:33 am on Dec 30, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Don't worry fellas! I think I will start an affiliate program that is open to publishers from India, China, Australia and Canada only! :)

merchants seem to think the web site owner's country of residence is the only place the site's traffic will come from.

Elisabeth, such merchants do not deserve your attention. It looks like they are new to the world of internet/ecommerce and it actually shows their naiveté. Their affiliate support would probably be questionable too.

reject indian affiliate for a cost per click program, but not for cost per action programs.

Do we still have good CPC programs? I thought that model rolled over and died sometime back. The only CPC programs I see nowadays are casino and adult programs.

If you do know some good CPC affiliate programs, let me know. And don't worry - I won't spend the rest of my life clicking on the ads at a cybercafe...

jamesyap

5:19 am on Dec 30, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



US is a great country but sometime what they do on 'looking down' on other countries is very frustrating.

Affiliate world is one of them. I can't join clickbank and many other affiliate program. I stay in Malaysia. They usually give 2 reasons

1. High Fault Rate - Nahhhhh!
2. Country politic/economic system (comunisimne, fix exchange rate like my country, claim to be undevelope country ...)

Another one is PayPal, I think I need to wait 10 years before PayPal will reach my country.

Next - THE most frustrated. Some websites block access to network of other country which claimed to be related to terrorism. One of them is godaddy domain registrar.

But for those who are from China/India/Australia ... any other countries that are not in the west. We have some benefit and advatages, one of them is what we earn are in USD - very high in return when exchange with our currency. And we are usually using resources from our own country which may be cheaper.

And we don't need to pay TAX as US citizens pay the most TAX in the world! :)

profitpuppy

5:26 am on Dec 30, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Some very interesting points:

- Yes I agree there are no good CPC programs

- I have just got a USA address (costs $150 per year) to relay mail to my address, so I can 'pretend' to be in the US.

- yes, having a USA passport is actually the worst passport in the world to have from the point of view of taxation (with the exception of Libiya) because they tax you on your worldwide income even if you don't live in the US. In other words, if you have a USA passport but have lived in India for the past 30 years, if you didn't file a USA tax return you could go to jail.

Having said all of that, I'm not basing the US ... I love it ... fantastic economic success, great place to live, good skiing :) and an economic model for most of the world.

jamesyap

5:31 am on Dec 30, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Huh, I just check the CJ country list and didn't saw my country listed. Look's like CJ is also like godaddy, just they didn't allow you to signup instead of blocking your access. I have an account with them that I signup around 2 years ago. It is only actively generating revenue currently and I have never receipt a check before. I am wondering now will they decline to send me check!

On having a mailing address in US, how does this work?

firstmark

12:11 pm on Dec 30, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I bet if you have a "quality" site that CJ would accept you even if you lived in China, India, or Antartica.
Writing them a letter and inquiring would yield better results than trying to work around a generalized security feature of country exemption that CJ has implemented.
In business all things are negotiable if you are just willing to try.

mayor

5:46 pm on Dec 30, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Of every dollar I earn online, almost 50 cents (that's right, almost 1/2 of what I earn) goes immediately into the Federal, State and local taxing authorities.

Why should I have to compete in my own market with some offshore entity that pays little or no tax? (I exclude my complaint from businesses in those nations that have similar taxing systems and share in the worldwide responsibilities and burdens of modern nations).

It's quite possible that CJ is responding to some US Federal regulations designed to foil tax avoidance. It's getting real hard to launder money now that the Fed is watching closer than ever.

Set up a legitimate business in the US, with a legal business residence, pay your taxes just like I do, and I'll have no complaint.

jamesyap

5:54 pm on Dec 30, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



US people choose to serve tax at first as they thought of taking some monet from the rich to help the poor. But times go by, the tax system has become a burden of the middle/poor people. It is a mistake that has been done long time ago.

Mayor. How much you make if you didn't work in US? I don't know what is the price in US but in dutch as someone told me, it is $600! $600 for a non working ppl. Do you know an engineer in many coutries include mine can hardly get $600!

No one will want to pay tax true from their heart. Including Mr Mayor. You just don't have a choice.

mayor

6:57 pm on Dec 30, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



>>Mr Mayor. You just don't have a choice

Yes I do. I can leave, but I'd rather stay here and accept paying taxes.

I work at my computer terminal approximately 15 hours each day, and usually six or even seven days a week. All that to play my role in keeping our economy humming. I earn the right to complain about freeloaders and I earn that right each and every day.

Jamesyap, I would love to see you and all the people in the world earn a good living. All I ask is that people who want to earn it in the US market play by the same rules that I have to.

I applaud the US Federal authorities if they are shutting down the outflow of US dollars to offshore tax havens. You can be sure they are cracking down on the outflow of untaxed dollars through cyberspace and that hole, once plugged, will never again open.

That said, you might search Google for 'Delaware Corporations' as a place to start learning how to set up a legitimate US Corporation. Build a real infrastructure within the US economy to work from, pay your taxes, and the $600/yr earnings you're talking about might just be your taxes for the week.

vibgyor79

7:07 pm on Dec 30, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Mayor - I'm afraid you are going off the track. CJ's ban has nothing to do with "outflow of dollars". I think you should start a seperate thread on that topic for some really interesting comments. I will be waiting for you when you do that :)

And if India and China are tax havens, then pigs can fly!

Writing them a letter and inquiring would yield better results than trying to work around

Did that sometime back when I wanted to join Overture's advertiser referral program. Did not receive a reply.

mayor

7:48 pm on Dec 30, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



>> If India and China are tax havens, then pigs can fly

Sorry, I was talking about Malaysia

I guess this is heading in a political direction, against the WebmasterWorld TOS, so I hereby declare EOM in regard to any Fed crackdown on money laundering through cyberspace.

vibgyor79

8:03 pm on Dec 30, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I guess this is heading in a political direction, against the WebmasterWorld TOS..

We can always pack our bags and head towards WebmasterWorld Supporters Forum. Because I'm really interested in the topic and would like to know others' opinion on this.

mayor

8:16 pm on Dec 30, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



vibgyor79, I probably don't have a whole lot more to say, but I'll try starting up a thread on "outflow of US dollars to offshore websites" in the 'professional webmasters business issues' forum here at WebmasterWorld and see if we can keep the politics down enough to not have the thread shut down.

See you there soon.