Forum Moderators: open

Message Too Old, No Replies

Why the hubbub over OOXML?

passionate arguments over a Microsoft XML schema

         

httpwebwitch

2:33 pm on Mar 13, 2008 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



From the outside, the debate over whether the International Organization for Standardization should formally ratify Microsoft's Office Open XML format as international standard DIS 29500 seems almost completely political. And during last month's ballot resolution meeting (BRM), the reports on how that debate was proceeding were so wild and uncorroborated as to be almost unintelligible.
source:

[betanews.com...]


Here's the story in a nutshell:

The ISO is possibly going to standardize a special XML schema that Microsoft invented, a schema which will make documents authored with Microsoft Office products more accessible to each other and to 3rd party software developers.

Word documents, Excel spreadsheets, etc will all use a common XML schema to describe their data content.

Some don't think Microsoft's schema should become an ISO standard. Some argue that the schema just isn't good. I'm sure the technical details of this keep many people up at night arguing over coma-inducing details like namespace naming conventions, the right elements to use to define "dropcaps" in Word...

The debate has spawned an anti-ooxml petition with over 86,000 signatures (noooxml.org)

Microsoft promises that this format will be open, free, now and forever.
source: [microsoft.com...]

cmarshall

8:14 pm on Mar 13, 2008 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I haven't ever seen a reason to avoid using it, but Microsoft is known to have done some of their standard "market playa" shenanigans, which have upset a lot of people, and may take the attention of the [de]merits of the standard.

I just want A standard. I don't care which. Any standard upon which a bunch of diametrically opposed organizations can agree is gonna be a mess anyway, so there's actually a chance that a vendor-supported standard will be better.

MarkFilipak

4:31 am on Mar 14, 2008 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Wow! Is this reminiscent of javascript1.2 vs. jscript or what. And it's taken us how many years to get back to a semblance of interoperability? Microsoft sees the standards organizations as marketing opportunities. I say: cut Microsoft out; no interoperability with MS applications at all; screw them or they will screw us.