Forum Moderators: LifeinAsia

Message Too Old, No Replies

Difficult Situation - Consulting

Telling someone they were ripped off...

         

ukgimp

9:40 am on Sep 18, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Hello All

My situation keeps changing and with that comes new scenarious that I have not previously encounterd.

A web desing company has referered me to one of their old (still in contact) clients with respect to improving their current situation regarding SEO.

The company has a passion for frames which is bit of a downner but a few thing could definitely help. My main concern is the general design of the site and is well below standard and very unlikey to convert a sale let along be found by the websurfing world.

Would you have any recommendations as how to approach this situation. I dont want to tell the client that they have been fleeced and they need to spend money on a total redesign plus optimisation and I dont wish to upset the people who refered me. I am stuck between a rock and hard place. Oh yeah, they also host the clients site if it could not get any worse.

The referers also want me to contact a few other clients of theirs, some with the same god forsaken problems.

Help :)

Sinner_G

9:44 am on Sep 18, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



First I would go and talk with the people from that web design company. Working for one myself, I have seen it happen often enough that clients forced their views on graphical design although we told them it would hurt them.

So ask them why they made the site that way.

shanz

12:20 pm on Sep 18, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



My partner and I have had this sort of issue crop up a few times.

In the first instance try diplomacy. Pointing out how quickly the web evolves can work for both the client and previous company. Everyone saves face. Its quite possible the previous company are aware of the shortfalls, but who wants to do work for nothing? especially when to do so would admit you did a bad job first time.

Second strategy, Tell them how it is! This is business after all. Add lots of "This is a new succesful strategy that other companies I've worked for have had success with" or "Search engines have evolved this year, you need to focus on this now."

As you say, it is bad business to alienate anybody!

rmjvol

1:26 pm on Sep 18, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Same idea as SinnerG & shanz. Don't piss off the design firm for 2 main reasons.

First, if you berate them (intentionally or unintentionally), they'll not send more biz your way.

Second, they have the relationship with the client, you don't. Since the firm brought you to the client, they probably trust the firm & don't trust you yet.

Find a way to offer several levels:
1. minimal seo work to make improvements in rankings
2. changes to design to be more seo friendly
3. complete redesign, pitch the concept of a "fresh" site

One approach that sometimes fits is to educate the client on how SEO is a specilty that very few good designers (like this firm) have the time & resources to focus on because it's so rapidly changing. Just like the client can't be an expert in every facet of their industry, it's almost impossible for a design firm to excel in everything interent related. That's why the firm was smart enough to bring you in :)

Good luck,
rmjvol

korkus2000

1:36 pm on Sep 18, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



A web desing company has referered me to one of their old (still in contact) clients with respect to improving their current situation regarding SEO.

How old? If its over three years then they really didn't do anything wrong. The web has changed a lot. What looks good today was almost impossible for designers a couple of years ago. They may also had browser restrictions and the client all in the design. They also may have juat upgraded a legacy site created by the owners son.

I would talk to the design firm to get more history on this site. If their other work looks good then there is probably something here that you may need to know before you go forward. This could be the client from hell.

I have a client that I gave very slick search engine friendly designs. They steered me with much wailing and gnashing of teeth to make it very unproffessional. The thing looks like a 3rd grader did it. Thats what they wanted. I won't link to it and you will never get me to admit I did it.

I would not talk to the client about it. Only talk to the web design firm. You are being paid to make their existing site more search engine friendly. If it is bad as you say then that task should be no problem. It may take a lot of work but you need to charge for it.

glengara

8:03 pm on Sep 18, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Tough one, could be very fruitful if handled properly.
Question of showing them their passion was misplaced without making them feel, never mind look, foolish.
Assume a hostile attitude to the SEs for ruining a wonderful design format maybe?

Travoli

8:41 pm on Sep 18, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Seems like, talking only to the design company and working through them would be the best route. Then they can tell the client that code changes will be needed to make the site rank better, and they can quote a price big enough to cover the frame removal.

ukgimp

8:15 am on Sep 19, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I would like to thank all who have responded to this thread. The ideas given have helped me a great deal and as such I am sure I am crack this situation.

Cheers

sanity

6:04 am on Sep 20, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



How old is the site? If it's quite old there may be an opportunity for a redesign - which would no doubt please the web dev's, and you can ensure it is search engine friendly from the ground up. If handled right it could be beneficial to all.

Shane

8:16 pm on Oct 21, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member




Hope it is not too late (just saw this post), how about doing the work as requested and hopefully they see value in this (increased traffic, but probably no increase in conversions), then say, you are most of the way to higher conversions, you liked the SEO work, the last part of the work I would recommend is ..... a redesign.

Best of Luck,
Shane