Forum Moderators: martinibuster
Some people feel the SE's give more weight to "relevant" links, but this is debatable.
I'd always go for related if you could... for one thing, that will add more keyword rich content to your site (in your links or "resources" pages). You don't want to clutter up your site with "real estate links" if your site has nothing to do with real estate, imho.
--Mark
In my opinion, I prefer to stick to sites related somehow to my themes and subjects. I don't do it so much for the SEs, but because I think that is what my customers would like to see. Because I have a multitalented wife who does handmade crafts in mixed media, I look into exchanging with sites related to art, crafts, decorated eggs, etc. I have lots of options, and I believe my customers would be more inclined to be looking for those kind of sites than a real estate site....after all, I don't run a directory or a search engine, but a reciprocal directory with "subject related sites".
Just FYI, this is my own personal choice not based on any statistical analysis, but I reject hotels, casinos, poker, tobacco, alcohol, drugs of any kinds, adult, and many others.
[edited by: martinibuster at 7:04 pm (utc) on Jan. 28, 2005]
[edit reason] spelling [/edit]