Forum Moderators: open

Message Too Old, No Replies

Specific Browser Versions For Testing

         

jfred1979

8:14 pm on Jan 1, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I know there have been a million posts about which browsers to test on, but I couldn't find anything that addressed specifically which versions of each should be used. I'm trying to keep the clutter on my computer to a minimum, so if more than one important browser uses the same engine (such as the Gecko based browsers) I'd like to get the most efficient, quick loading, least registry and system invasive version of one of them.

It seems to me that if I get Netscape 4, IE 6, IE 5, Opera, and Mozilla, I should have the important PC browsers covered, right? Which specific versions of each should I get? If I get Mozilla 1.0 will all the important recent versions of Netscape be covered? Also, I seem to remember significant changes from Opera 6 to 7, which should I go for? How about Netscape 4.x, is there a major difference between say, 4.03 and 4.08?

txbakers

8:32 pm on Jan 1, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Yeah, everything is fine, just ignore Netscape 4.

mep00

9:08 pm on Jan 1, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



just ignore Netscape 4.

I, at least for the most part, disagree. While I don't think you should be too concerned about NS4, it's best, if it doesn't cause too much trouble, that it shouldn't break NS4, and the CSS degrade gracefully. I wouldn't suggest loosing any sleep over it, though.

For IE, I would recommend both 5.0 and 5.5. There's a way to run all three (inc. IE6) simultaniesly.

Where possible, Mac brwsers should also be tested. In general, the more, the better. There is a caveat, it largly depends on the application. If you can't afford to overlook anyone, then you might even need to use <shudder>tables for layout</shudder>. (I think you can guess where I stand on that issue. :) )

thehittmann

3:50 am on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



yes i find mac browsers a bit of a weird one. Even with my html validated 100% to w3c standard and 0 html errors. Some people that have tested on macs say that my site just will not load at all.....and if does load is messed up.

Other people with the same mac os and the same browser have said otherwise and given full reports on my site with a handful of browsers.

I think it's not worth worrying about too much....Just aim to please the biggest markets without forgetting the others.

SlowMove

3:56 am on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I'm just wondering if the people that are still using Netscape 4 have any money to spend on computers or anything else.

txbakers

4:06 am on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



people still using Netscape 4 don't understand anything about computers anyway.

just ignore Netscape 4

tedster

4:24 am on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I'd like to reinforce the Macintosh test. IE 5 on Macintosh accounts for 5% to 6% of visitors for many of the sites I manage. That beats the total of all Gecko browsers. Then Safari on Mac OS X, which is promising but still full of dysfunctional surprises.

If you're a web hobbyist, then you might not be willing to take the extra trouble. But if you're going for income in any way - selling your services to others or building your own online income stream - then the Mac test is an often overlooked boost to your site.

The thing is, Mac users are usually much more aware of what a browser is - compared to a PC. I've noticed that my friends with Macs normally have a choice of browsers close at hand because they never know when they might need this one or that one to get a Windows designed website to work for them.

Still, giving Mac users a website that works the first time can help a site.

mep00

4:26 am on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



SlowMove-
I'm just wondering if the people that are still using Netscape 4 have any money...
My hunch is that you might be very surprised. Many times those who are willing to make do with less have a lot of money for that very reason.

SlowMove

5:10 am on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I don't know. You could be right.

hartlandcat

11:14 am on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I'm just wondering if the people that are still using Netscape 4 have any money to spend on computers or anything else.

This is another of these popular misconceptions that I've seen mentioned numerious times -- for some reason, many people seem to believe that Netscape 4 users are "poor".

People still using Netscape 4 don't understand anything about computers anyway.

Or that it simply isn't their choice on which browser they use.

What browser are most schools, universities, colleges, corporations, government insitutions, military bases, libraries and so forth currently running on most of computers? Netscape 4. Because they have (perhaps "lazy") IT departments with very restricted "standards". This is supposedly for security reasons (although I find it hard to imagine how Netscape 7 could have more security holes than Netscape 4).

If you put together all the people using the internet those types of insitutions, you end up with about 1% of internet users. This is where most of the Netscape 4 users are comming from. They're not necessarily "poor" or "stupid". They have no choice other than to use Netscape 4 whilst they are online in the institution which they are a member of.

jfred1979

12:49 pm on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



While I'm glad to have started this lively discussion, maybe I should have been a little more clear about what I'm after. I'm trying to find specifically which versions of the browsers I should test without installing a million different browsers on my machine. For example, is there any reason I should install Netscape 7 if I had Mozilla 1 installed? Will this cover the Gecko engine enough for testing? Should I get the latest version of Mozilla instead? How about Opera, it seems there are some quirks from version 6 to 7. Any specifics would help. I'm trying to get the widest range of testing possibilities with the least amount of browsers.

mep00

1:03 pm on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



For example, is there any reason I should install Netscape 7 if I had Mozilla 1 installed?
One would think not, but I remember reading a question (either here or on the css-d list) about someone getting different results.

It should also be noted that the same browser under different OS's can sometimes yeild different results. I'm not just talking about Win vs Mac, but even Win98 vs Win98SE.

hartlandcat

1:56 pm on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Right, okay. If you want to install the absolute minium on your machine...

I'm assuming you know how to install multiple versions of IE on one computer. Microsoft will have you believe otherwise, although it actually is possible.

Internet Explorer 6.0
Internet Explorer 5.0
Mozilla Firebird
Netscape 6.0 (don't worry if your site has some unexpected bugs in this)
Netscape 4 (it doesn't matter which version)
Opera 7
Opera 6

jfred1979

5:23 pm on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Is there any reason to get Mozilla and Netscape? They are both based on Gecko and should render the same, right?

R1chard

5:50 pm on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



With nothing else available, I'd always rather use Netscape 4.6 instead of IE 4.0 or 5.0. I just think it's better (more secure and less crashing), and I'm not overly bothered by a few layout/mouseover problems. And even if you're a computer genious, you don't always have permission to upgrade.

But anyway, how do you know the N4 user isn't a rich powerful billionaire using a friend's computer? It's just closed-minded to assume something wild like that, and to discard those users.

jfred1979

6:00 pm on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I guess my real question is this, if I have Mozilla 1.0, and my layout looks fine, should I assume that it will also look okay in Netscape 6 and 7? Also if I have Opera 6 and everything looks fine, should I assume it will look okay in Opera 7?

hartlandcat

7:44 pm on Jan 2, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I would also use Netscape 4.x over any version of IE, but I'm just like that. I'd rather use Mac OS 8 over Windows XP.

If you get Mozilla 1.0 then Netscape 7.0 & 7.1 will be covered, as well as all more recent versions of Mozilla and most other Gecko-based browsers. Although there may be some very slight differences, it would be unlikely.

Netscape 6.1 & 6.2 should also be covered by Mozilla 1.0, since they're both based on Mozilla 0.9. However, Netscape 6.0 is a slightly different story, since it's full of very unexpected bugs. Thankfully, very few people actually use Netscape 6.0, since it was so horrendous. At that time, most Netscape loyalists either went back to Netscape 4.7 (and unfortunately stayed put), gritted their teeth and waited for Netscape 6.1 (which was a major improvement), or switched to IE or Opera.

Opera 6 and Opera 7 actually use different rendering engines, so you can't really afford to assume that everything that works in Opera 6 will also work in Opera 7, although you do have a fairly good chance. If you really can't have both Opera 6 & 7 installed on your computer, then I suggest you install Opera 7, since that's what most Opera users use.