Forum Moderators: buckworks & skibum

Message Too Old, No Replies

A "click" showing/charged for Local AND Regional?

Is it possible for just 1 click in Local OR Regional to show up in both?

         

tclcorp

6:26 pm on Nov 23, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



We have 1 Adwords account with 2 campaigns (1 Local and 1 Regional) for our small, local service business. Each campaign pretty much has identical ad-groups, same ad copy and MOSTLY the same keywords. We set it up this way for 2 reasons 1. A couple seasoned experts here suggested it. 2. As I understand it, Google visitors HAVE to search the Local area to see any Local Ads, but either Local OR Regional Ads will show up in a "main page" Google search (which MOST people use). After careful monitoring over the last 6 mos., I've noticed that often the SAME Ad-Group, keyword and/or even identical ad is showing as "clicked" in the local AND regional, even though it may have been only clicked once (which means we are paying 2x's). I tried it myself using a keyword that's in both campaigns, doing a Local only search, seeing Ad and clicking it. But did NOT do it in a Google "main page" search. When I checked back in my campaign summary a couple hours later after it was recorded, sure enough, there's the ad-group and same exact Ad (or a similar Ad) that has same keyword attached to it. We do not get enough hits per day to say this could be purely co-incidental due to a large proportion of hits. I suppose if a visitor did BOTH a "main page" search AND a Local search, they could see and click a similar/same Ad, since they most likely would use the same keyword for search. But, it doesn't seem likely that a visitor would do a main page search, see and click an ad, then do a Local search and see and click the exact same ad again. Now, this doesn't happen EVERY time, but I would say it does happen at least 30-40% of the time. Also, the results sometimes do not show this during the very next update, but will at some point before the end of the day. My questions are, is this even possible? If so, why? Is it how I have my campaigns structured? Since we don't have "Conversion Tracking" activated yet, would it help when we turn it on to explain/confirm this? Thanks for any advice! Mark @ tclcorp.

werty

10:32 pm on Nov 23, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Mark, most likely you are getting two real clicks from real people. Each click should be recorded separately, as they are in separate campaigns.

Local targeted ads will show if someone is within those bounds/location you are targeting and they type in a keyword, and the regional will show if the user is on AOL (area show as richmond virginia), or some other non local ip address.

My suggestion would be to add a unique tracking url to each ad:?source=Google&targeting=local for local and?source=Google&targeting=regional for regional. Then use your analytics program or log files to tell if the clicks are showing as dupes.

Based on the percent you are seeing I am guessing you are just mis-interpreting the reports.

tclcorp

2:01 pm on Nov 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Thanks Werty....I think you're right. The %'s I see this happen in are too low to be a "regular" thing. But, if it's as you suggest, then seems like a lot of people are looking for same thing @ same time in local AND regional during same day. Which, if that's the case, then one could say I've chosen good keywords, good ad copy and am providing a service that the market can support. Maybe it really is just "human trends" that allow for the natural changes in search habits (keywords, etc...). I guess that's why we create ad copy relevant for seasons, holidays, etc... In any case, I will ad tracking and analytics soon to be better able to monitor this situation, as you suggest. Thanks, Mark