Forum Moderators: buckworks & skibum

Message Too Old, No Replies

Has Google ever gone over your Campaign Daily Budget?

Might just be imagining it

         

surfgatinho

3:54 pm on Aug 5, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



I thought I'd try an adword campaign and forgot about it. Ended up costing more than I expected as the Campaign Daily Budget was quite a bit over what I thought I'd set it to.
Has this ever happened to anyone else or has my memory started to go.

Thanks,
Chris

Prolific

4:00 pm on Aug 5, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I've had them go over by a dollar or so. Made me a little upset they didn't adhere to the budget

Frequent

4:42 pm on Aug 5, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



If they go over your daily budget they will credit you the difference at the end of the billing period.

Keep in mind that if you change your budget a lot it can be tough to keep track of how much you should be credited.

Freq---

Eurydice

5:45 pm on Aug 5, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



This is becoming a serious problem. I've not written about this, but it's time to discuss this.

A month or two ago, GAW changed the policy. Previously, overcharges would be modest (a few percentage points per day). But now, it can go over as much as double or triple. Yes, triple. For some of my clients at $200/day, they can see $600 in one day in charges.

GAW does this because on weekends, clicks can be low, so over the week, the extra clicks make up for the lack of clicks. All in all, you get maximum clicks (and billing). At the end of the month, if there are overclicks, those are deducted. You got those clicks for free.

But this brings up another problem. On July 19th, for several of my clients' accounts, GAW "adjusted the overclicks" by turning off the accts for a day. Zero clicks. They did that to keep the acct within budget. But... that's a very bad solution. For a company, it's not amusing to have zero sales. The store costs (rent, staff, etc) are the same, yet there are zero sales.

GAW should not use zero-click days to balance accts. If they overdeliver, then they should either balance this with low-delivery days or take the loss and give credit to the store. But they definitely should not stop ads for a whole day.

Frequent

5:52 pm on Aug 5, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Eurydice,

That definately would be unacceptable. I haven't had that happen to any of our accounts yet, thank goodness.

By any chance, did those "off" days follow major changes in the ads or keywords of the account?

I've noticed that $G is pretty slow to adjust delivery in response to sweeping changes.

Freq---

edd1

11:38 pm on Aug 5, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Mine went over on a day last week but was under the day before so I think it can accurately be described as 'maximum average daily click' rather than maximum in one day.

oldpro

1:45 am on Aug 6, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



mine goes over budget all the time...usually about $10-15 a day. about two weeks ago i tripled my daily budget...so i guess no credit will be coming back to me now. doesn't matter, i'll take all the traffic i can get as long as the ROI holds up.

jbgilbert

2:30 am on Aug 6, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Before continuing with this discussion, you need to understand what Google AdWords calls a daily budget -- don't think just daily, because it's actually monthly!

When Google says you won't get charged more than your daily budget they really mean this:

Say it was July 2005 (31 days) and your "daily" budget for all of July was fixed at $100/day...

For the month, that is $100 x 31 days = $3,100 for the month. Google is saying you won't get charged more than the $3,100 for the month.

- Many times AdWords will automatically adhere to your daily buget setting quite naturally, but I have seen cases where he went over the daily amount by a considerable amount for an entire month. In one of these cases, Google credited the client for the over charges before ever billing the client's credit card.

Eurydice

9:46 pm on Aug 6, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I understand it's actually a monthly budget. But in several cases for various clients, Google wildly exceeded the daily budget (triple the amt) and then "corrected that overbudget" by shutting ads off for a day.

I've emailed back and forth with our dedicated reps about this. Perhaps they'll not do this anymore.

Watch your stats and if you see a day that has zero traffic, you'll know what happened. We need to emphasize to Google that they can not use this solution.

markwelch

10:02 pm on Aug 6, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Someone wrote: "If they go over your daily budget they will credit you the difference at the end of the billing period."

I confirmed this some time ago; indeed, I even "played the system" for a little while by launching campaigns with $0.05 bids and daily budgets of $0.05 for each campaign. The result was that Google would generally overrun my campaigns by 30% or so (on average) and would credit that back at the end of the month, so my cost per click was actually less than 5 cents. I was only running a dozen or so campaigns, and did this mostly to just see whether Google would balance things out properly -- but I could envision someone really using this to abuse the system, if they launched thousands of nickel campaigns with nickel budgets.

Import Export

12:47 pm on Aug 8, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member




I had exceeded the budget a while back and received the credits back to my account.

Recently, however, I have not seen credits being issued.