Forum Moderators: buckworks & skibum

Message Too Old, No Replies

Discrepancies btwn Google Search and Ad Preview Tool

         

stonewall

4:32 pm on Jul 8, 2009 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



After contacting my google support rep about discrepancies in the results given by the Ad Preview tool, and the actual google search, I received this reply.

...discrepancies between Google search and the Ads Preview tool are commonplace and we always recommend that you use the Ads Preview Tool to get the truest representation of your ad positioning.

Am I the only person who finds this alarming? How on earth is the preview tool going to give us the "truest representation"? The results on the ads preview tool are not what our customers are seeing, the actual google results ARE. I, at least, would like to see what people are ACTUALLY seeing, not what google wants me to think they are.

AdWordsAdvisor

11:37 pm on Jul 8, 2009 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



The advice you received is correct, stonewall, if perhaps a bit counter-intuitive. ;)

By searching for your own ads constantly on Google.com it is possible for you to change what ads you see or don't see - including your own. Searching for your ads using the Ad Preview Tool prevents this, and shows you what others users are seeing in the moment you search.

Keep in mind that your ads will only show in the Ad Preview tool if they are eligible to show in the moment you search - taking into consideration your budget, and so forth.

AWA

stonewall

12:56 pm on Jul 9, 2009 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member




Keep in mind that your ads will only show in the Ad Preview tool if they are eligible to show in the moment you search - taking into consideration your budget, and so forth.

Not so true. Keywords that adwords had listed as "inactive due to search volume" still triggered ads in the preview tool.

I dont mean to be argumentative. Im sure I seem pretty stupid to all of you experts, but I guess I have a different line of thinking.

pavlovapete

2:21 am on Jul 14, 2009 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Im sure I seem pretty stupid to all of you experts

So true, all of us here were born with the Adwords DNA add-on pack. Our parents had great foresight and purchased the add-on pack prior to Google being invented.

Everyone here has gone through the learning curve, many of us are still on it.

How on earth is the preview tool going to give us the "truest representation"?

My current thinking is that there is no single representation. That each user is getting a personalized version of the SERPs and ads. I think AWA is saying the preview tool has personalization turned off - and so you'll get the nearest picture to reality without sitting next to the user.

300m

7:06 pm on Jul 14, 2009 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



The preview tool should by no means be the end all for ad positioning.

I use the following:

1) Ad Preview
2) Normal Search
3) If you do a normal search and click on "more spnsored listings" you can see yet another change in the AdWords algo.
4) In Adwords UP I look at the avg positions

I ususally gauge them by identifying the most common position. Its not perfect, but it seems to work for me.

Mishaelo

2:00 pm on Jul 15, 2009 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I use the following:

1) Ad Preview
2) Normal Search
3) If you do a normal search and click on "more spnsored listings" you can see yet another change in the AdWords algo.
4) In Adwords UP I look at the avg positions

I would also add a 'normal search' through a web-proxy, depends on the geo-targeting. (surf through US, canada, UK, etc')

300m

5:44 pm on Jul 16, 2009 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Good point, I seldom use proxy's, but its a good idea. Thanks

Rehan

4:03 am on Jul 17, 2009 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I would also add a 'normal search' through a web-proxy, depends on the geo-targeting. (surf through US, canada, UK, etc')

You don't need to use a proxy... You can just add &gl=US or &gl=CA or whatever to the URL to get the results for the geo-targeted area.

IMO, normal search is useless for checking ad positions -- if you're checking your ads regularly, it will cause your ads to appear lower than for a typical user (you can "fix" that by deleting your cookies, but then you'll just see the same thing as the Ad Preview Tool). And "More Sponsored Listings" has been completely unrelated to ad positioning ever since they changed it last summer.

I typically use just the Ad Preview Tool and the stats for my keywords to see where they're appearing for users. I use normal search only when I have to extract a competitor's landing page URL from an ad link.