Forum Moderators: martinibuster

Message Too Old, No Replies

AdSense Account Termination

What triggers Google to flag an account?

         

juvenall

7:09 am on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I'm finally giving in and setting up an AdSense account for myself, but I have always wondered what criteria will set off a "fraud" flag. Does anyone have any insight?

diamondgrl

7:31 am on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Hopefully fraud will set off the fraud flag.

So don't try anything.

juvenall

9:50 am on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



..ok, anyone with a serious answer? :-P

As I was looking into joining, I ran into more then a handful of stories on people who've lost their account for what turns out to be anything but their fault. One that stood out more then the others was that of a local Chicago web forum where the users/staff from a rival site clicked on enough ads to get the account closed.

Now, I know things like that are rare (at least I hope so), but that still brings up the question of exactly what it takes for your account to be closed?

davthp

10:03 am on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



You have the answer already - fraud - don't do it - its that simple.

You cannot allow for the actions of others if they do as you say and click on your ads.

Macro

10:16 am on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



That is your serious answer, my friend.

We've had cases here of people complaining they did nothing wrong. They were usually new members and it usually turned out that they had done something wrong but hadn't realised it. Almost every single time. The one or two occasions that are "in the balance" are where we didn't know the poster's URL and couldn't see what was possibly wrong with his site.

Read the TOS, read the TOS, and read diamondgrl's post again. Making your account valuable to Adsense [webmasterworld.com] may help.

juvenall

10:45 am on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



First, sorry to diamondgrl if I came off rude. I really wasn't trying to..

You cannot allow for the actions of others if they do as you say and click on your ads.

I guess I should phrase my question better. Does the AdSence program offer any way to report traffic that would look like fraud? Say, I normally get a single click a day then, out of the blue, I'm getting 100.

Making your account valuable to Adsense may help.

Thank you for the link, Macro. That did answer some of the questions I've had.

Macro

11:15 am on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



You could email Adsense that there's some funny activity on your site. Some say it's paranoia. I say it doesn't hurt to drop them the odd email.

perfectlover

11:57 am on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Don't ask your friend(s)to test(Click) Adsense on your site :) and be happy.

ownerrim

3:40 pm on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Actually, you'd be safest not to even mention to your friends or relatives that you have a website. and certainly do not mention the earnings mechanism to them.

When I first got into adsense, I explained the thing to several people (naive excitement over the concept). The first person said to me "wow, i have a bunch of friends and I can get them to click on your ads". I recoiled in horror when I heard that". Then, two people at work said the same da#$ thing to me. This made me hyperventilate and nearly throw up. As fast as you can spit, I blocked my employer's entire IP range from accessing my site.

These days...I don't say jack to anyone I know. If they say, "how do you make money on your website?", all they hear from me is the sound of crickets.

freeflight2

4:42 pm on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I am advertising since a couple weeks on the adsense content network and I am truly amazed that some of these sites showing my ads are still in the network... the best one was showing adsense on the logout page saying "you may leave the site now by supporting one of our sponsors" showing adsense and a competing network at the same time... (still, adsense is fantastic for branding and showing your name to millions of (new) users - if you have a "sticky" site it's the way to go.)

BennyBlanco

5:01 pm on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Sorry to point this out, but does anyone else find it a little funny that someone is thinking about joining AdSense..... but they first want a clear definition of fraud :) This is just too funny to me. Think about it. You think this guy is talking about incorporating AS into an existing, valuable site... or do you think they want to create a straight AS site?

If you have to ask what fraud is, then don't be surprised if your methods may be included. Just mho.

martingale

8:21 pm on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member




I don't think it's too funny, there have been so many "horror stories" posted here that I think practically everyone worries about it. It sounds like Google isn't even-handed when they suspect fraud.

BennyBlanco

9:45 pm on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



But still, why would fear of being cancelled prevent you from signing up in the first place? The only way that makes sense to me is if you think you will be pushing it from the start. Horror stories aside, I guarantee that very few of those who have been cancelled would have not signed up in the 1st place had they known it would go away eventually.

ownerrim

9:55 pm on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



"But still, why would fear of being cancelled prevent you from signing up in the first place?"

If you have a site with a thousand+ pages, you probably want to know what the potential risks are before you update your entire site with ad code. Sounds reasonable.

BennyBlanco

9:59 pm on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



sure, i guess if you have thousands of static pages, that would be a chore, but again, unless you thought you were gonna push the limits before signing up, why wouldn't you take the shot in the 1st place? Does anyone here dispute that AS, if you are not booted, is great?

BTW, does anyone still really have thousands of static pages to update? :)

europeforvisitors

10:14 pm on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)



If you have a site with a thousand+ pages, you probably want to know what the potential risks are before you update your entire site with ad code.

Sounds like a good reason to update those static pages with server-side includes (SSI) for borders and navigation bars. (I use FrontPage shared borders, which do the same thing, and I can change the ad code for whole sections of my site in one fell swoop.)

BennyBlanco

10:20 pm on Jan 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



efv, thats what I was getting at ;)

juvenall

7:48 am on Jan 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Needless to say, I'm a little offended. I'm not asking what counts as fraud, I'm asking for ballpark ideas on what can set it off. Is it sudden mass clicks/surge in traffic? High view/click ratios? Any professional would be concerned over the same thing.

My personal experence with a closed account comes from one of the many open source projects I work with. The admin had set up the account for the site, added the code to the site's engine and set it so it like we do with the other ads so they won't show to the staff (him, my girlfriend and myself..so only 3 IPs). Now, I can't say 100% that the admin didn't do anything, but in the 6 years I've been working with him, I've not known this Mormon kid to lie. So the account is closed with about $200 under lockdown until Google "investigates" (whatever this semblance of courtesy entails).

So yes, I'm a little leery about the whole thing. I signed up because I understand that these events are few and far between and I do have much faith in the way Google is running the show. However, as someone who's income currently depends on what his sites can bring down, I have a legitimate concern as to the seemingly arbitrary nature of some of these closings.

Oh, and for reference, the site this account is targeted for has been up for about 3 years, generates around 4 million hits from thousands of uniques a month and is currently paying for itself with inhouse advertising. I'm trying to use the AdSense program to offset a recent change in my bandwidth costs so I can keep my normal ad rates at reasonable levels.

The bulk of the concern I have is towards the over zealous members of my 32,000+ member community. I fear they may take it upon themselves to over click in a misguided attempt to help the site. As I scan over the AdSense ToS, I can't help but be worried as it seems I'm powerless and unable to say "Please don't click everything you see."

jstar

8:25 am on Jan 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



You don't have any AdSense now, so you're currently not earning anything from them. The worst thing that could happen (barring a criminal investigation if you perpetrate some kind of massive, obvious fraud) is that you lose the income you currently don't have anyway.

So what's there to be afraid of?

davthp

9:38 am on Jan 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Why do all these threads end the same.

1. I ain't done nothing wrong.

2. It was completely without warning

3. Oh! - you mean I can't do that

4. Well yes perhaps I did some of that

5. Never posts again

Macro

9:54 am on Jan 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Innocent until proven guilty.

juvenall

10:08 am on Jan 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



You don't have any AdSense now, so you're currently not earning anything from them. The worst thing that could happen (barring a criminal investigation if you perpetrate some kind of massive, obvious fraud) is that you lose the income you currently don't have anyway.

So what's there to be afraid of?

Exactly. That's why I signed up and I'm working in the code right now (trying to rearange the page so the Google ad isn't near any of the actual sponsors). I just don't want to get too complacent and start to rely on them, only to hear "Hey, guess what?"..lol

BennyBlanco

3:01 pm on Jan 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



jstar, that is exactly what my original post was getting at. So, juvenall, be offended all you want, sorry. But, I still say that unless you think you will push the limits from the start there is no reason not to sign up.