problens on adsense "allowed sites" option

Are "allowed sites" steal publishers's legitimate earning?

[blogsdiy]

AdSense China add a new feature called "Allowed Sites" which let publishers enter the a list of allowed domains , to specify which sites are allowed to display AdSense ads with their publisher IDs . The main aim of this feature is to prevent publisher IDs from being placed in spammy sites that do not belong to those publishers . That's fine , Many Chinese Adsense publishers use this options immediately to give our accounts a little bit security.

But here is a problem: there are always some reasonable scenes that adsense display out of the "allowed sites" list , and I think Publishers should get earnings in those situations.

For Example , let talk about Google's images search : When searchers clicks on the little preview images , It will open the original pages use frame , although the adsense still show up and some users will click on , Publishers has no ways to get those earning, because in those situations adsense display on google's domains instead of Publishers's own domains. Is this reasonalbe? We publisher provide great contents and our server bandwidth , but couldn't receives deserving returns? Or should we add google's domain into our "allowed sites"? that's crazy , and can easily exceed the 100 sites limite , not only the "images.google.com" , "images.google.cn" , there are so many country/region domains , aka "images.google.com.tw" and "images.google.com.uk", etc.

When user search images in MSN/live Search , the same thing happens . This even happens when users click the cached page link in SERP .

And the next , There still many little Social Bookmarking Websites in China Which use frame to open original pages when users click , We publisher works hard to get our pages to be bookmarked , and our pages being bookmarked because of we provide great contents , should we get return?

If we want those earining , Maybe we must add those domain into "allowed sites"? that's funning .

And there still something "gray" , Google only said that ads would still show up in sites out of the list , and clicks wouldn¡¯t generate earnings for the publisher, but didn't mention whether advertisers are still being charged for these clicks. In my thought, If Google intend to do this ethics , they can just disable adsense show up or show PSA ads. Is this so difficult? If the adwords advertiser being charged for those click (Sure , I didn't have validate evidences , but many adwords advertiser reports there exist some click form Search engines's cache pages and images search were charged in there records) , maybe we can say Adsense , especially Adsense China , is doing something in evil way.

Sorry for my poor English .

[edited by: jatar_k at 12:38 pm (utc) on June 18, 2007]
[edit reason] no urls thanks [/edit]

[blogsdiy]

No one concern about it? or I was wrong?

[Hobbs]

[webmasterworld.com...]
that's propably why you got no response?