Exact Match vs Synonym

Deciding whether to move an established .com EMD (since 2004)

[courier]

I have an exact match very high value .com domain datng back to 2004. It has had it's good years as well as it's bad. Since last year it has been one of those bad years. I don't rely on it for income, although it still generates a decent ammount of sales. I know about EMD penality in 2012, howevr this site was not hit with it, although I suspect the screws got tightend last year. Either that or when I opted out of the adsence that allowed Google to test different ad types and placements, as it was just months after that, that traffic went down.

So, I am thinking about changing the site to a very broad match synonym. I own the synonym domain (UK market so .co.uk). At the moment the synonym is redirected to the EMD.

If I type this synonym search phrase into Google, the AI overview refers to the products of the EMD, although the products don't show till the second page of the results (my actual website is not one of these top 100 results). I suspect the reason the synonym is showing in the AI overview is that I started years ago to write the synonym instead of the exact match at the end of the title so not to keyword stuff.

Although I don't rely on the income of this site, it would be a nice supplement if it generated more sales.

Has anyone had any experience of this, or tried it (using a synonym domain instead of the exact match domain)? Would it be worth taking a gamble and transfer everything to the to the synonym domain, or should I just ride it out and see where it goes?

It would be good to hear some suggestions.

[Brett_Tabke]

Exact match domains aren't automatically penalized anymore, but they also don't carry the weight they once did. Google treats them like any other domain. Shifting to a synonym domain might look cleaner long-term, especially if it better matches how people naturally search today. But a full migration always carries risk - especially if the EMD still has some age, backlinks, and history behind it.

What you describe with the synonym surfacing in AIO makes sense as they have the semantic pedal to the floor now.

I doubt the adsense changes were the trigger. The serps - they are a changing.

If it were me - instead of flipping the site to the synonym domain outright, you could test it:
o Build out a few synonym-focused kw pages on the existing site.
o Strengthen internal linking and schema so Google understands the relationship.
o Track if those pages start to gain visibility for synonym queries.

[RedBar]

Over the past 30 years I have moved quite a few sites from EMDs to trading names and vice versa. All were clean coded and ranked well and when a site was moved it/they 301d nicely and soon became established and. in fact, I did this only three months ago with a trade name to an EMD, this has gone even better than I thought it may do since it is not a com/net/org but a .asia, it is attracting the regional traffic I want it to and so far is still ranking well.

The last 10 years has seen G et al change their alogos so much and now with "added AI", I'm not at all sure how much synonyms, EMDs or trading names have ranking influence these days. From 1993 onwards I have always strived for relevant quality and accuracy but just how much this now counts for anything is a moot point.

Insofar as a value may be concermed for a generic EMD I would be asking a minimum USD 5 figure amount up to whatever for a really special one. A good industry EMD always looks good on a business card etc.

[tangor]

Since you already own the synonym, why not run that separate? See if you can compete with yourself. :)

As for the EMD, why change it if it is still productive? As noted above inserting synonym based content can provide more leverage for the existing site, without building out a separate site.

Question is, which makes more sense to YOU as you are the one doing the work.

Still, having a bankable domain in hand is not a bad place to start experimentation.

I WOULD NOT move content from A to B until B was FULLY ESTABLISHED and paying better than A.

[courier]

That makes sense, I haven’t considered using the synonym as a separate standalone site, maybe a good idea. As the synonym has been redirected to the EMD, would Google hold back the new site, seeing it as an extension of the EMD?

[tangor]

Answered your own question. Take the redirect off. A STANDALONE means exactly that.

NOTHING prevents you from having two sites for the SAME BUSINESS. Just make sure that each has a flavor of their own which makes them UNIQUE.

At some future time, after the "experiment" has concluded, you can THEN think about combining both to whichever DOMAIN WINS. (A few years down the line, as it will NOT happen overnight!)

[courier]

A good industry EMD always looks good on a business card etc.

Agree, it would be great for advertising in brochures or on radio and TV. I’m a one man band and don’t make full use of the name as could be. Suppose I don’t have the same energy and passion as I used to when I was younger.