Forum Moderators: Robert Charlton & goodroi

Message Too Old, No Replies

Website disappeared from a specific query, has my website been removed?

         

RogerThat

4:41 pm on Feb 10, 2015 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Hi there,
I'm running a website for 6 months now. The website used to be on the second search engine result on the first page of Google USA for a specific query.
The average position of my website at that specific query was 3.0
It's 3 weeks now that it seems like my website has been removed from that specific query although it still indexed on Google when I search my website name as a query.

I didn't get any warning or an error from Webmasters tool and I truly don't know what to do.

I would be thankful for any help,
Avi.

aakk9999

2:46 am on Feb 11, 2015 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Welcome to WebmasterWorld, RogerThat!

There could be a number of reasons really.

- your site, as a new site, might have been given a boost for some queries and this boost has been removed. This is known as honeymoon period.

- When did the site disappear for that query? There was SERPs changes reported recently in our Monthly update thread [webmasterworld.com]. Have a look at our monthly thread around dates your site has disappeared and see what others are reporting. It could be that there has been some update that for some reason changed criteria that resulted in your site not being seen as relevant enough for this query

- What happens if you try similar queries (synonims, permuted words, little bit of long tail words added etc). Any of these still show your site or has your site disappeared for that one query only?

minnapple

3:41 am on Feb 11, 2015 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Don't know if this is your issue, but rule it out.

Try changing your search settings to display 100 results and check for your site.

Sometimes sites are lost between the fold of page results. If that is the problem, it means you are in a ghost position between 10 and 11.

Page one results thinks you should be on page two, page two results thinks you should be on page one.

Ghost Positioned. Seen this happen many times, doesn't last forever, but may last a week or more.

RogerThat

4:44 pm on Feb 14, 2015 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Thanks a lot for both of you guys.
I've tried to search for long tail keyword query and my website apperas at the very first result on the first page.
When I try to search for the main query my website doesn't even appear on the 100 first results even though it was ranked at the first page for months !
BUT when I search a long tail keyword (3 words when the main keyword is 2 words) my website appears, as I said, at the very first result.
It is very strange to me and it seems like Google just removed my website for this specific query !

Any ideas ?
Thank you.

lucy24

8:35 pm on Feb 14, 2015 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



To double-check, use a site: search together with the specific query that you've disappeared from. And, of course, re-check from different browsers using different IPs.

Has there been any attested case of Google removing or penalizing a site from some specific search but not all searches?

Obviously you can't have memorized the full SERP package from before. But are the sites that now come in at 1, 2, 3 etcetera the ones you used to see immediately after your own site?

Robert Charlton

8:28 am on Feb 15, 2015 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



RogerThat - Search engine rankings are competitive, like a horse race. There are some 200 or more ranking factors, and they change over time. There's a general understanding that Google changes its algorithm 500 or 600 times a year.

Beyond algorithm changes, your rankings might drop because your competitors are making improvements to their sites, perhaps more than you've been making to yours. The best sites are perhaps attracting more and better links over time, which would change their position relative to yours. Some ranking factors are also time dependent.

The reasons the results might change are what this entire forum is about. Your questions suggest that you may not be understanding this.

The end of the honeymoon period, as aakk9999 explained, is a common reason for a new site to drop. If a site hasn't attracted traffic resulting in high quality links during that time, it will generally lose position.

BUT when I search a long tail keyword (3 words when the main keyword is 2 words) my website appears, as I said, at the very first result.

Longer queries are more specific, and as such are less competitive than shorter, more general queries. And different queries have different degrees of ranking difficulty.

It is very strange to me and it seems like Google just removed my website for this specific query !

Just because a page isn't ranking where it used to rank does not mean that it's been "removed", though that can happen.

Using the site: search with a specific query is one way of checking whether the site is in the index. Searching for a unique phrase on the page in quotes is another.

As minnapple suggests, pages will sometimes drop out for days or a week at a time. Perhaps someone duplicated your content. I think you've got a lot of reading to do to catch up on the basics. You might consider posting in our New To Web Development forum [webmasterworld.com...] for more detailed answers on basic questions.

Akira

12:04 am on Feb 16, 2015 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



RogerThat, this happened to me one year ago. I have set up as site with very poor SEO on page, no backlinks, no blogs post, just dead site with 5 pages.

Within 3-4 weeks I ranked 3d place (for the most important keyword I have) on the first page fro some moths. Then site dived to 6-7th page.

Now my site is 1 year old and I'm ranking 3d page with lots of efforts to boost social presence and on page SEO.

I thik you have had a beginner's boost in the first months and now you have to take a close look at who you will be back to the top pages :)