The ultimate question - is Google giving us a penalty which we can just rectify or have we just been moved down to our rightful position in the SERPS and no immediate changes are going help?
We had over 300,000 visitors a month through Google pre-Panda. Post Panda traffic from Google has almost halved. SEO visibility according to Search Metrics has decreased from over 20,000 to about 6,000.
A number of "potential" causes - any of which with some hard work we can turn around (doing all is going to be very difficult though!). Nothing black or grey has ever been done, but the list of things that we "could" be being punished for stretches to around 8 things.
Do we look at each possibility and weigh up the probability and just deal with it accordingly?
Is there any way in which we can categorically find out if we are doing something wrong inadvertantly?