Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from

Message Too Old, No Replies

Google Adds Maps to the OneBox for Local Search


Total Paranoia

9:56 am on Jan 30, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

I have never really liked the local results that appear at the top of google results when searching for a local service but could ignore them as they took up so little space on my page. I also own a few businesses in the suburbs and have always felt that the local results were unfair to me. WHY does Google favour businesses in the city centre anyway?

Now to add insult to injury, Google have slapped a huge map image at the top of the page, thus pushing the natural results off of the page.

I feel that this is one step too far.


4:55 pm on Jan 30, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

< This post was moved from another location >

The local search market just took a hit. Google is returning 1-4 local listings before regular organic serps for [cityname widget] searches.

It's been in and out, but it looks like that's what is coming full time, soon.

[edited by: tedster at 6:11 pm (utc) on Jan. 30, 2007]


7:54 pm on Jan 30, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member tedster is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member

Google made an official annoucement about their new handling of local businesses yesterday.

From now on, you'll see this every time you search for a place, business, or other local information. In addition to providing the basic contact information and map locations for several choices at the top of the page, we also show ratings and provide one-click access to reviews on the search results page so that you can make more informed decisions about where you want to go.


Franklin Zapata

8:04 pm on Jan 30, 2007 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member

Great. Now half the results page is either filled with sponsor adds or a map and local businesses, many of which don't even have web sites, but are only listed because they are in the yellow pages. My website which was at the top of the results, (of course it has taken me years to achieve) is now, though still at the top...HALF WAY DOWN THE PAGE...sorry about the caps..but, YOU HAVE TO SCROLL TO SEE the # 1 listed site. How can this be good for Google? Well I think I can answer that..ADWORDS. No more free ride. Now I have to buy Adwords.


8:07 pm on Jan 30, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator buckworks is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member

Watch phony reviews and ratings targeted at Google local become the next wave of competitor sabotage.

I've seen it already in a sector I monitor.


8:10 pm on Jan 30, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

Yep, isn't that nice, finally get to the number two position for keyword-town and that map pushes me below the fold. I see big money paying to show up next to the map too.


8:24 pm on Jan 30, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

I don't think it's really sunk in yet the extent to which this change will effect the web. Anyone whose site depends on a city name might want to get a day-job. Google just stole your lunch money.


8:34 pm on Jan 30, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

saw it today for the first time. its awful how HUGE it is. pushes all the relevant results down. searched for one term and it said this scraper site was a local contact worth showing.

outstanding google. your trying TOO hard.


8:37 pm on Jan 30, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

Nice move Google. Finally my local sites are on top.


9:07 pm on Jan 30, 2007 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member

Yeah, I don't like this. This is the part of Google I hate, when uber-popular stuff gets above the fold treatment and the "good" stuff is lost in the long tail.

The results I'm seeing for a couple different cities just aren't very good.

When you're taking up so much of the screen like that, I expect the links to be EXACTLY what I'm looking for. Instead of EXACTLY what I'm looking for, I'm getting three HUGE Yahoo-esque ads for places that only might be what I'm looking for.

For example, if I'm looking for a "xanadu restaurant" that's a pretty basic search; I want a list of results to look through, not 3 commandment-sized choices.

Robert Charlton

11:42 pm on Jan 30, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator robert_charlton is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month

They don't have it yet for all local searches, by any means. I'm not seeing it for the local pizza searches I've tried, eg, which are one of my standard local tests.

Also, I notice in several test searches that [cityname widgets] will produce the map, whereas [widgets cityname] won't.

I'm not surprised by this at all. It's clear that the engines are moving towards verticals as fast as they can produce satisfactory results... and it's very likely that the serps page is going to continue to evolve.

Concurrently, this should create more space for more precisely targeted ads.


12:37 am on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

Let's see...

3 Sponsored Blue Bar links
1 "Local Results for [widgets] Near [location]" link
3 Local Results links
3 "[number] Reviews" links
3 "Get Directions" links
3 "More Information" links
1 "More Local Businese Results" link
1 Clickable Map link

...that means that even if you're #1 in the organic results, you are effectively the #18 link on the page, UNLESS your city has a "Refine Results for..." section, which adds another 6 links (total of 24 links) for the user to get passed in order to click on your cheesy little #1 organic link.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but this looks like a complete wipe-out for travel and local search to me.


12:47 am on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

seems to kill any advantage of buying adwords as well as user eyes are drawn to the map area unless you bid into the top 3 or so..


1:16 am on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

The map is not that large with 1600 x 1200.


2:53 am on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

The OneBox will revolutionize local search. For B&M local merchants like us, trying to fend off thousands of affiliates pretending to be IN our city, it's a welcome relief.

That said, the data provided in the OneBox needs some work.

1) The Yellow Pages data they use is fraught with errors (Buy a local exchange phone number and forward it to your call center, anyone?). There's no way to easily alert G to phonies.

2) They use Y Local's reviews (see above).

3) You guys that want to complain about the slowness of PR or backlink updates will really understand 'waiting' if you follow review updates from sources like Yelp, CitySearch & InsiderPages.

It's not perfect, but it's a giant step towards helping surfers find real, local facilities and merchants.


4:53 am on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member jtara is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member


Maybe this will curb abuse of <city> <service> keywords by businesses that have absolutely no connection with a city, save for being at the other end of a shipping service.


7:24 am on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member

Certainly won't kill the local search game, makes it more interesting and more challenging though.

My local business has position A on a search term for one of the largest cities in the US. Must by 300 (minimum) other related businesses in my city.

My natural position is #3 and it's just barely above the fold. I count 10 opportunities to click before getting to natural position #1.

Time to do some homework!


7:38 am on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

Well it won't be long before they start placing adwords adverts on the maps.

I'm thinkng this is the next step forward for them, anyone that uses Google maps on their sites Beware!


Total Paranoia

12:12 pm on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

Now it is all about location again - and by that I mean physical location of your premises not your website. The UK results are driven from yell and they are ranked by how close you are to the city center as far as I can tell. So any business on the outskirts do not get a look in here.

This is a massive kick in the teeth for many businesses who did well in the natural results yet are not based in the city center. Now they are pushed below the fold.

Well done Google - we hope you are proud of your precious results. Do not forget why your users always loved you - it was because you did not fill the first quarter of your page with crap. Whilst the competition were greedy early on, you knew it was the fast natural results that would win the war. You should not forget that.


1:20 pm on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

smaller hotel sites like mine will get hit with that.
not because google shows direct contact to hotels at the top. this is useless as users prefer meta search sites showing available hotels in order to QUICKLY find what's available.
Checking hotels one by one is not a move forward. So users wont directly use this feature.

Unfortunately, users will use the other features such as well located ads to expedia and other big names.


6:08 pm on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

When you think about it, Google has taken the first step toward moving the hotel meta search function over to Google from individual sites. I fully expect Google to later tap into GDS and also allow the uploading of availability and rates by individual hotel properties into Google proper (a GBase off-shoot, maybe).

To be honest, I never could figure out why Google *didn't* take over the hotel search/res function in the first place. Not only would it vastly increase their revenue, but most importantly, it would solve their travel-spam problem overnight.

The only downside is that a move like that would crush the economic base of thousands of travel sites that provide all the info for Google to index in the first place...unless, of course, Google plans on those info sites gradually shifting to Adsense over the long term.

Hmm...I need a drink.


6:12 pm on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member

Local search is a very needed service which has not been affectively produced yet. Google has made huge leaps in this area, but still in most cases the service fails to do its job. Why? The main reason is for the lack of accurate data. Yellow page adds are not enough to fill an Internet based service with data since many of the results would be Internet based and many times not listed in the yellow pages. To compound the problem, many yellow page adds are not properly written to include the terms you would want to come up under in a search result. People don't think in different terms just because they are using the Internet. A blue widget is a blue widget if you look it up in the yellow pages or search for it on the Internet. Plus most yellow page listings do not have adds, they are just listed under a term. This lack of data is why Google and other local search services have suffered with the lack of accurate and relavent data.

Google has now taken the first step in solving many of these issues. You can now add your business to the local search and maps through google.com/local/add/login if you have a Google account. Spamming is diminished due to the fact they mail a confirmation letter to the business address before the listing goes live. This is a great step in the right direction to give this type of service the boost it needs to go mainstream.

Local search is a trend which will only grow and I hope it to become more widely used. I believe Google is placing these results now in an effort to encourage people and businesses to add their listings and transform this service into what it can become, a true and accurate way of finding what your looking for as physically close to you as possible.

Not every site will benefit from this. Some will take a hit while others can greatly benefit if they properly list their business. The main thing though is to give the searcher the best results.So lets get with the program and add our businesses to this service and not fight it. The protocols available to publishing a website do not really allow for local information to be added which can be accurately found and relied upon by a search engine. Now Google has given us this ability. So lets not waist our time focusing on how bad it hurts, but rather how great it will become. Lets get our listings, spread the word, and help it grow.

--edited for spelling

[edited by: Drag_Racer at 6:15 pm (utc) on Jan. 31, 2007]


6:41 pm on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member

I know this boat left the dock some time ago, but I feel that google.com is moving even further away from search of the internet to search of google.

As a user, I have come to expect google to provide me with objectivly ranked search results of all internet content. Unfortunately, the above-the-fold results for a local search are now mostly google's own content and paid listings. This doesn't appear to meet my historical objective expectations of a SERP.

The the "do no evil", "do a little evil = $", "do less evil than the other guys = $$", "do what we want = $$$$$" slippery slope will, IMHO, will start to drive users away. I recently have come to find myself using MSN and Yahoo more. They are both evil in their own ways, but they never set my expectations as high as google did. They are all in it to make money, and they have the right to do so. And they should. But as a consumer, I/we have rights as well.

I will continue to use google, but as a percentage, less than in the past. I just uninstalled the google toolbar and I feel like I took a good hot shower.


7:33 pm on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

Maybe they are starting to be more of a portal. Just an hour or so ago the SERP look and feel completely changed. At least when using IE7 on Vista x64. Firefox seems to be the same as usual.



9:16 pm on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

IMO Google is making the same mistake AltaVista made way back when... they're making the mistake in a different way, but making it nonetheless.


9:32 pm on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

I just checked a SERP and it had ONE organic listing above the fold (thankfully mine) on my monitor. That means two sponsored Adwords listings and three Google Local feed listings plus three or four side Adwords block ads.

Portal is right, but others currently do it better...


9:54 pm on Jan 31, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

And that big empty space on the left hand side with the "Search for" options doesn't help out any. Who the heck at Google approved that new look?


Total Paranoia

1:12 am on Feb 1, 2007 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

Well they have said for a long time that they want to develop local search.

I just can't help thinking that Google are taking things too far here. The true beauty of Google search has always been its simplicity. I guess they have grown to such a size that they have to make use of the staff :)

Not wanting to sound as though Google owes me a living here but if they are looking for things to fix, perhaps it is time that they found all the missing homepages from .com or .net domains for UK pages etc. Now that really is broken!


1:45 am on Feb 1, 2007 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member

The true beauty of Google search has always been its simplicity.

Indeed. The change they made to the SERP today has made me switch from IE to Firefox so I can still see the clean easy look I'm used to seeing :-/



3:56 pm on Feb 1, 2007 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member

Conventional wisdom would say that when they have pushed all the other contents down a bit on the page, they will get more clickthroughs on their OneBox content while other sites listed in the natural SERPs would get less. (This would be a natural assumption based off the famous Google SERPs eye-tracking study and its resultant heat maps of where users look and click.)

But, I'd recommend not overreacting -- conventional wisdom might be off-base on this one. Other studies show that online users mentally dismiss SERP content that appears to be advertising, and they've been conditioned to figure that rectangular content at the tops of pages is typically advertisements that they're less interested in. If the OneBox content unconsciously seems less relevant to them, it will only irritate them and they'll continue clicking through to the organic/natural results below.

Vimes, you may not be aware, but Google *already* has been selling some mapvertising on particular verticals and in particular local markets. Go to the "Find Businesses" interface at Google Maps, and search for "Hotels" in "New York". You'll see a Sponsored listing icon showing up on the map as a tiny logo icon for Best Western.

Currently doesn't appear in the Web Search results for the same search, but how long before it might?

Total Paranoia, you're right -- they favor businesses in the city center. I actually blogged about how to take advantage of that in my article on Extreme Local Search Optimization Tactics recently.

They aren't using pure city-center proximity, though -- the algorithm is also using keyword relevancy and which of their business listings have the most favorable user reviews. So, getting good user ratings on various sites can help propel one into the top local listings, I'd guess. I mentioned that in my blog as well.

I think the interface is good for their users' experience, though the area it takes up is a bit largish, IMHO. We'll just have to see how most users accept the new interfacing. Probably will accept it pretty well, since Google is good about user-acceptance testing of features before they deploy.

This 41 message thread spans 2 pages: 41

Featured Threads

Hot Threads This Week

Hot Threads This Month