Forum Moderators: martinibuster

Message Too Old, No Replies

AdSense disabled due to users clicking

         

krod

12:37 pm on Oct 7, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Hello,
I own a forum and had adsence running on it. I am a non-profit organization. I explained in a post the I added the ads due to the increasing amount of bandwidth i am paying for. Some users took it wrong, made a forum post about clicking on the ads to support the organization without my knowledge or consent. I received a email saying my adsence was disabled. At the time i couldn't think of anything of why they would disable it, then i scanned though the forums and say that a sole user made a topic about clicking on the ads to support us. Before you enter the forum there is a agreement on how the moderators can not moderate every post and to read at the user's own discretion. Why would google disable my account due to a user's misunderstanding?!

oddsod

9:02 am on Oct 10, 2005 (gmt 0)

Ankhenaton

12:40 pm on Oct 10, 2005 (gmt 0)



Putting adsense, Google, click, advertisement, ad, ads etc into the forum profanity filter might be good idea.

If you can hack the forum software as to alert you if any of these terms are used might be a good idea too.

krod

7:10 pm on Oct 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



they just reinstated my account, after i got their phone number, i had a lengthy talk with them. The next day it was reinstated. The ironic thing is, i still use YPN!, it makes 200% more on my site ;)

jeremynz

9:24 pm on Oct 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



If this is an ongoing problem for forum owners I wonder if you could consider cookie'ing all your registered users and displaying something else in your adsense blocks... such that adsense only appears for non-registered (i.e came in from the SERPs) visitors. It would axe your adsense cheques pretty heavily but its a bit of a grey area isnt it - users clicking an ad now and then, or being suspected of click fraud because clicks are from the same bunch of IPs... I've never run it on forums so this is just a guess :-)

fischermx

5:20 am on Oct 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



they just reinstated my account, after i got their phone number, i had a lengthy talk with them.

Wow, we have a new story about a reinstantiated account!

frox

10:29 am on Oct 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Miguelito said:

and reinstate me

Wow, we have 2 new stories about reinstantiated accounts!

krod

10:57 am on Oct 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



yahoo makes sooo much more $$, it also says in the reports x2 the amount of ad impression adsence reports
heh, i also just got about 5 stickys of people wanting their number.

janethuggard

12:08 pm on Oct 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



When you setup a forum, you have to either maintain it free, or charge subscriptions. Fact is since the beginning of BBS times, forums have been plagued with game players. The very fact that users use childish fantasy names says that. Users hide behind fantasy names so they can spew whatever nonsense they want and not be held accountable for it, and/or create mutliple user names.

They are known for slack management, where the rules are weak, never applied straight across the board, and the mulitiple accounts per human can run into the hundreds. That reduces the credibility of the board, it's users, and lends itself to wide rumor mongering. That is the nature of forums. Under those circumstances, it is hard to get advertisers.

Does your forum require users to use their real name, and do you verify accounts by address and phone? I know the anwser is, no. It is too much trouble and has too great an expense, so you don't bother. So, if I was Coca-Cola, why would I want to be seen there?

When you do get advertisers, you have to just about promise them on a case by case basis you will watch their back. How do you do that? There are many ways but, the most common method is for the owners and mods to create mulitple users accounts for the purpose of posting positive comments to outweigh the negative, while mods decide if the real user negative comments require deleting. That invalidates the entire forum.

I will stop short of saying every board owner manipulates the user base and posts for their own benefit, their friend's benefit and trading partner's benefit, there are exceptions. But, of the hundreds of board owners I have personally known over the many years, they all did it. Since I don't personally know this board owner, he would be excluded from that last statement.

It is a tainted system at best. I would charge a modest subscription rate, something most any user would easily be willing to part with. Forget about the advertisers.

fischermx

1:06 pm on Oct 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



There are many succesfull forums running Adsense.
It is not like adsense is not made for forums.
It IS like adsense is not made for child/teenage forums only, that's it.
This 39 message thread spans 2 pages: 39