Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from 54.211.23.190

Forum Moderators: incrediBILL & martinibuster

6 Tips for Adsense on Forums

   
4:52 am on Jul 28, 2005 (gmt 0)



Adsense on forums is often a frustrating experience for new adsense users. Looking for a way to monetize all that forum traffic many new adsensers wind up on a forum themselves complaining about the poor returns. The following advice is based on my experiences of running adsense on forums for 2 years. ( I only successfully figured out what to do after being on WebmasterWorld and experimentation )

1. Topic is important.

If your forum is focused on car loans or investing your going to get better payoffs per click than if its about music. This is simple to understand so it should need no more explanation.

If your forum is in a low CPC ( cost per click ) topic then try putting in a for sale section, jobs section, an a wanted section. These will help build some better paying traffic for you.

2. Ugly URLS have got to go.

ModRewrite is a must ( assuming your using apache ), you have to have easily crawlable urls to get fully indexed in the search engines. Most of your clicks are going to happen by people reffered to your site not by your normal users, so the search engine referrrals are what are going to pay for the forum. Also your targeting will improve if your urls are simpler.

3. Regular users don't click.

Regular users of your forum are their to talk to other people not click your advertisements. Once you accept this and move on you'll be better off. I tested this several times by the following:

- showing ads to all users
- showing ads to only users referred to the site
- showing ads to only users not logged in.

The results were that regardless of who I displayed the ad's to I always received the same number of clicks. With this in mind I chose to stop showing ads to logged in users all together.

4. Position the ads right.

Use the heatmap over in the google optimization tips page. It works.

5. Cloak your content. ( WARNING: This is considered risky by some )

Cloaking is presenting different data to different users based on what you know about them.
Most forum software uses large html templates and presents unrelated text to the topic of the thread to the requester. This screws up targeting of the advertisements sometimes since often times the extraneous information outweighs the thread. Cloaking allows you to make sure the content outweighs the html and other crud.

What I do is remove all unnecessary information ( signatures, profile links, etc ) and present only the bare minimum to the adsense ( and all bots for that matter ) bot. This increased the accuracy of my targeting. Do this at your own risk. My recommendation would be to make sure the page is useful if it was sent to a regular browser and do not stuff keywords... just present the same data you would normally, albeit with a lighter html presentation. As an added bonus you can use this for cell phones and other small screen devices.

6. Don't hold your breath.

While all the tips did help me I still don't make much from the forum sections of my sites. You would do better to add a content section if you don't already have one and work on articles.

Best of luck!

6:15 am on Jul 28, 2005 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member



Goog job , vabtz
8:14 am on Jul 28, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Good post.

AdSense's results are not uniform in the entire world. Like in India i had seen that AdSense do not print relevant advt.

9:55 am on Jul 28, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



that is some good advice and interesting, thanks for the piece.
im not sure all forum sites are like that....active members of a forum site are more likely to click on ads as they understand it is a system to maintain the site online and feel a sense of loyalty if they enjoy the place so in some cases, regular members are those who click most.
11:21 am on Jul 28, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Ugly URLs are definitely a no-no with Adsense. I found this out very recently when I made some changes to my URLs which took strings like "page=1&thread=2&order=subject&crap==morecrap" out.
12:19 pm on Jul 28, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Instead of cloaking you could try to modify templates so that they will fit better with your content.
12:23 pm on Jul 28, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Forgot to add: Very good post, very inspiring. Just started to make some adjustments with my forum.

One thing I did was to switch the view. Users now will see the entire thread at once instead of single posts. I'm sure, my pageimpressions will go down. However I hope to receive better targeted ads and more $$ in the end od the day.

Also this will be much more comfortable for users.

12:52 pm on Jul 28, 2005 (gmt 0)



>> active members of a forum site are more likely to click on
>> ads as they understand it is a system to maintain the
>> site online and feel a sense of loyalty if they enjoy the
>> place so in some cases, regular members are those who click most.

That is exactly the behavior you do not want. I do not want someone doing me a "favor" by clicking ads. I don't want users to "understand" they need to click the ads to "support the cause". That could lead to fraud allegations and does a disservice to the advertisor and google.

12:55 pm on Jul 28, 2005 (gmt 0)



taps: good point, I agree with you that would increase targeting. I think it depends on what the average page size will be. I would like to avoid pages larger than 25k to help my pages get indexed in SE's.

DXL

2:56 pm on Jul 28, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



If I'm running an Invision Board on an Apache 1.3 server, how do I change the URLs to display differently?

I realized that search engines aren't indexing any of the forum pages, would make a huge difference if they did.

3:31 pm on Jul 28, 2005 (gmt 0)



I can only help you if your using phpbb. I converted my phpbb board to friendly urls and removed session ids etc.
5:55 pm on Aug 31, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Having just got around to doing this, and being in possession of a very lame CTR :D I was wondering if anyone would guess at what % improvement this will make?
6:07 pm on Aug 31, 2005 (gmt 0)



Depends on what you have implemented now.

Some of this is to help get you referrels from the search engines. If your forum is not search engine friendly it may a serious difference.

If it is SE friendly then the change in CTR is likely to be negligable. The other benifit however is some of the changes improve the user experience.

6:14 pm on Aug 31, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Well I have gone from normal phpbb2, to the mod_rewrite to make the urls search engine friendly. click wise I'd say I'm starting from almost zero.

I am a top 100,000 site according to Alexa, but I don't think my adsense returns reflect that at all.

6:47 pm on Aug 31, 2005 (gmt 0)



Alexa can be misleading.

What are your uniques per day?

I personally make more money from my articles section than my forum. But my forum is on entertainment, perhaps yours is on something more lucrative.

One thing for phpbb that you need to fix is the duplicate urls. There are a bunch of different urls that will show the same thread, hunt those down and fix them as appropriate.

7:22 pm on Aug 31, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I am not set up to know the uniques at the moment, so Alexa and a typical 100,000 page impressions is all I have to go on.

We are talking purely forums and no content. I am just after some idea of a minimum figure I should be hoping/aiming for.

7:25 pm on Aug 31, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



So how would one go about modifying phpbb with mod_rewrite to get cleaner URLS? Thanks
7:28 pm on Aug 31, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



[phpbbhacks.com...]

do a search for mod_rewrite.

There are two versions on the site, one does mod_rewrite alone, the other applies more extensive SEO techniques.

8:38 pm on Aug 31, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I think it depends on forum. On some forums, they know all the players in an industry and only click when a new advertiser comes in. If the ad text / title is interesting, regulars will click.
9:38 pm on Aug 31, 2005 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member



I still don't understand the concept of NOT having ads showing for registered members.
Even if it only registers a dollar a day, it's still good for all involved, is it not?

Unless of course, your members are offended by the ads.
I've had mine integrated for around 3 months into every thread, and on the forums home page.
The response?
NONE!
Not one single member has asked what they are or where they came from.
Anyone that surfs the net has already run into them on almost every site they visit by now.

9:38 pm on Aug 31, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator webwork is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member



Since forums are subject to the same AdSense TCU and related agreements as individual publisher sites, even though a forum's content is created on the fly, make certain you have a Forum Compliance Toolkit and Forum Specific AdSense Compliance Procedures. [webmasterworld.com]
9:54 pm on Aug 31, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator rogerd is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member



Nice post, vbatz. Like several others, I wouldn't rule out ads for regular members - if you have a fishing forum, an ad for a new fishing lure might attract clicks from long-term members.

Having said that, regular forum visitors have an even more advanced case of banner blindness than most surfers, so expect low CTRs compared to article pages, etc.

12:04 am on Sep 1, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Instead of "cloaking" and running the risk of getting booted from serps, use AdSense Section Targetting [google.com] and forget about black hat techniques.
1:09 am on Sep 1, 2005 (gmt 0)



Thats very true, I reccomend using that now too. This post was made before that was available.

I take issue with the black hat comment though. I assume by that you mean unethical. If you read what I wrote you will see that I did not tell anyone to do anything dishonest. Cloaking has many uses and even WebmasterWorld uses cloaking.

8:43 am on Sep 1, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



2 things:

1) Cloaking on a forum is, IMHO, necessary. You don't want your unregistered users seeing all the same 'bumph' as the registered users so you show them slightly different content. This, by definition, is cloaking - but it's a necessary evil and also serves to increase keyword relevance on your page

2) Question - How can I implement mod_rewrite on an active phpBB forum (that is spidered fairly well) without duplicate content? Is there any way to serve the bots a 301 when they hit the old style index.php?t=x type pages?

5:55 pm on Sep 1, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



The new ad section directive (search for section on Adsense control panel) can come in very handy in getting targeted ads displayed on forums.
9:58 pm on Sep 1, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I've tried several positions for Adsense on my forum - the heat map doesn't work as well for forums as it does on standard web pages.

In my experience a skyscraper in the left gutter performs best.

10:11 pm on Sep 1, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Thanks Jema
11:36 pm on Sep 1, 2005 (gmt 0)



Badass that is not what people typically consider cloaking.

Most people consider cloaking when you deliver data based on user agent, IP, or both.

3:19 pm on Sep 2, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



regular forum visitors have an even more advanced case of banner blindness than most surfers, so expect low CTRs compared to article pages

I've seen this on my forum. I combat it by changing the ad colors on a semi regular basis, I'd recommend once or twice (2x would be my max) a month.

In my experience a skyscraper in the left gutter performs best

My experience validates this also. I run a left hand skyscraper, and a banner a the top and bottom of each topic. Here are the percentages from a recent month:
Left Hand Skyscraper: 73%
Top Banner: 11%
Bottom Banner: 15%

I just realized that the sky scraper % is a little skewed because it is the only one of the three that runs outside the topic pages. BUT my site is primarily a forum, content is only 20% of my traffic.

This 45 message thread spans 2 pages: 45
 

Featured Threads

Hot Threads This Week

Hot Threads This Month