Forum Moderators: martinibuster
Does this apply at the company level or at the directors level.
I have several companies, and would like to keep adsense revenue separate for each limited company.
I am however the director of each of these companies,
with the same mailing address.
Would this be a violation of the Adsense TOS.
I really wanted the second account for record keeping simplicity. Both corporations pay taxes on their own.
Come on Google, can you make this clear for us please?
The TOS mention stuff about individuals, entities and networks. Are they saying that if you are a director on multiple companies that you are therefore a network and cannot have an Adsense account on each?
Yes, I love Adsense. But...it seems that the TOS mean Google can do pretty much anything and close down your account for virtually any reason. This is such a shame because I love Googles search engine, I think they have done a great job in helping both surfers and SEO's. But when it comes to Adsense their TOS are a bit onerous.
Anyone else here got an answer on this one? For those who are directors on multiple companies, even if you are doing it you may be breaking their TOS unwittingly. I am sure you would like to stay in Googles good books. So maybe Google can help us here.
For tax reasons, income must be reported properly for each company, however Google does have a mechanism by using channels to do that.
So I guess the question is, can Google force mulitiple corporations to use the same google adwords account, if the directors are the same.
I think the TOS was thinking of individuals and and not the complexity of the corporation, when they threw that little restriction in.
It would be nice if Adsenseadvisor to weigh in on this one.
Having just read the TOS I cannot work it out! Perhaps they leave it deliberately vague so they can just shut your account if they feel like it.
I can't blame Google for leaving out a few details in the TOS. It's a lot easier to evolve a new program like this if you can change the rules on he fly. I think we are given a lot of freedom, which I appreciate. For example, we can put our AdSense code on any site we want. Google has been criticized for being too generous in that regard. You can please all of the people some of the time and you can please some of the people all of the time but...
Google states an individual cannot have more than one adsense account. It also states an entity cannot have more than one adsense account. However, the question is can a seperate legal entity (corporation) compete in the same niche as another legal entity if the common link is the same director with each company.
I have a strong feeling that Google will not give any clear answer on this one.
"Multiple accounts held by the same individual or entity are subject to immediate termination unless expressly authorized in writing by Google (including by electronic mail)."
I set both of my sites up as separate corporations for liability reasons. Separate corporations are spearate entities. Therefore if one of my corporations gets sued it has nothing to do with the other. That's my insurance policy.
I don't see how there is a question that two corporations are two separate entities. My state and the federal goverment recognize these corporations as separate entities. Each has to have its own tax ID. I didn't try any subterfuge when setting these accounts up with AdSense. They approved them no questions asked.
Now Google can change all this by rewriting the TOS, however. But my understanding is that they can't terminate you based on the existing TOS.
If Google wanted things to be different, then they would rewrite the TOS and give you so many days to consolidate your google accounts.
English is such a terible language for contract law. Maybe contract law should be written in total mathamatical logic notation.
I have emailed them about this in the past, they checked my sites and emailed back that they'd allow me to do it.
Strictly speaking though the previous arguments about a registered, limited liability company being a separate legal entity apply.
Legally, a corporation is a 'person', so two different companies are two separate 'persons', regardless of who the directors are.
My point was that in theory you shouldn't have to contact Google for approval. I contacted them just because I like to play it safe.