Forum Moderators: martinibuster

Message Too Old, No Replies

After 2 Years, 50% Drop in AdSense Earnings

Need a Troubleshooting Checklist

         

blaketar

5:08 pm on Feb 22, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



While many people tend to quickly blame Smart Pricing or other unknown phenomena on drops in revenue I am trying to form a deeper understanding of the system.

For two years my site has been progressing slowly upwards with adsense revenue and traffic. With each check I receive I thank Big G knowing I would not be where I am at today without it!

Suddenly however, starting on the 2nd of this month overall daily revenue and the amount per click I was receiving was literally chopped in half. Ad Impressions, Clicks and CTR all have remained the same with some days showing a slight increase.

I was waiting to start my search for potential answers thinking that this may be the typical variation in revenue, however the trend continues downward with yesterday showing 1/4 of the revenue received this same day last month. As the title implies, I am at a loss for answers and am hoping that someone can possible describe what could be happening?

humblebeginnings

5:20 pm on Feb 22, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Blake, I experienced the same thing from mid january to mid february. Up to january my earnings have been rising for about 9 months in a row. Then all of a sudden, earnings dropped, and dropped, and dropped. Until mid february my earnings were down to about 1/4 of the december level. And after that, my ECPM started growing again. I really have no explanation.
Pages views and CTR stayed about the same all the time. The only thing falling was ECPM. I am just glad the worst seems to be over now. I surely hope you have reached the bottom now...

martinibuster

6:42 pm on Feb 22, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Are there seasonal fluctuations?

Is a dip in earnings at this time of year unprecedented?

Have you made any changes?

Have you gone through your site in a hunt for irrelevant ads?

Are you being site targeted?
Site targeting once brought one of my websites earnings to a crawl. Every page of my site contained an image ad for a site that was barely related to my theme, but unrelated to many of the pages on which it was showing.

hunderdown

6:54 pm on Feb 22, 2006 (gmt 0)



From the library:

[webmasterworld.com...]

danimal

8:21 pm on Feb 22, 2006 (gmt 0)



hunderdown... didn't you just tell us that there weren't many people out there complaining about google cutting their earnings? lol.

put me on that long list of people that have had their epc cut drastically by google, starting in the middle of january.

hunderdown

8:34 pm on Feb 22, 2006 (gmt 0)



there weren't many people out there complaining about google cutting their earnings?

That was my entirely subjective assessment based on comparison to other months.... There were months last year when the "earnings are down" threads were almost constant.

But it's difficult to get any sense of where AdSense is going as a whole. How many people post here, even semi-regularly? Maybe a few hundred? And there must be thousands, perhaps tens of thousands of AdSense publishers.

Is what we see here a representative sample? Probably not. Is someone whose earnings have gone up as likely to post as someone whose earnings have gone down? Probably not.

As I have said elsewhere, I don't see any value in speculating about what Google is up to. My focus is on building up my site, using AdSense more effectively, increasing my targeted traffic, and otherwise doing what I can to keep my earnings moving up.

Nitrous

8:44 pm on Feb 22, 2006 (gmt 0)



Those that see a big drop, how much traffic/earnings per day average?

Personally my 7000 daily views, and 125 dollars is slightly better now than it ever was. It has been almost completely consistent for over two years. BUT i have 15 small sites.

Looked at individually they vary drastically. Together they average out.

I suspect its an advertiser/competition/traffic/bidding/seasonal/search engine issue. And that if you dont have enough traffic or subjects then you will see huge variations at times.

europeforvisitors

9:34 pm on Feb 22, 2006 (gmt 0)



Is what we see here a representative sample? Probably not. Is someone whose earnings have gone up as likely to post as someone whose earnings have gone down? Probably not.

Plus, we have no idea what kinds of sites are involved. In some cases, there might be very obvious reasons why a site might have seen a drop in income, but we'll never know because most members don't include URLs in their profiles.

blaketar

10:41 pm on Feb 22, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



If it helps any members I average 50,000 to 60,000 adsense impressions per day. See about 10,000 unique visitors a day and get about 500 to 700 adsense clicks a day.

I do not have adsense on all pages and most impressions are from AdLinks or block units.

I Would give out my URL but others have stated it is not a very good idea to do so? Automotive Sector.

creativepart

10:51 pm on Feb 22, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Overall my earnings have risen every month for 6 months because I've been adding ads to new pages and improving placement on the page. But in mid-Jan even though the month was up overall there was a very noticable drop in the middle of the month.

Starting on Jan 15th they dropped 35%... but only for one week and then returned to previous levels. This happened again in mid-Feb too.

February looks like it will be the first month without an overall increase since last July for my website--not a decrease over previous months, just no increase for the first time in 6 months.

When my daily amounts drop they drop consistantly all based on eCPM not views or clicks. Then after a week the daily totals come back but they do so gradually.

Weeks one and two average $24 a day
Week three averages $16 a day
Week four/five averages $20 a day
Week one of next month $24 a day

It has done this two months in a row now.

GoldenHammer

11:45 pm on Feb 22, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I have been too with AS for years, the best response (if you have done the optimization provided in the AS web pages) is do nothing, be patient, don't spend your effort to study or don't make further optimization. Making additional changes that try to "resolve" the declines, in most case, gives worser result.

Wait no time to spend your effort for more productive and postive work - develop target traffic and introduce new tools to maximize and diverified your income.

Aircut

3:13 am on Feb 23, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



i see the same trend here.

i host 10K users a per day with 500-700 clicks. no major site changes, or traffic sources. it is all natural traffic....

CTR has dropped and so does the ecpc. i was thinking that

a. i get less targeted ads....thus less clicks...less earnings...

or

my site has been targeted. [authoritative in a niche craft]

from 200-250$/day average last year and January. i am running same traffic through and manage to squeeze 160$/day....

hope things will improve

ccam96

4:35 am on Feb 23, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



As an AdWords user I can only guess that it may be from the recent introduction of seperate content and search pricing. Advertisers can now specify, within the same AdGroup, a different price for content sites vs. search. I know personally that I've reduced my content price per click bid to about 50% of my search price per click bid and still get a reasonble amount of traffic from content sites.

I think that this change was rather recent although I may be wrong.

unreviewed

5:49 am on Feb 23, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



>>users a per day with 500-700 clicks

160 per day with that amount of clicks is nothing to complain about. You are in the top percent of Adsence revenue possibility. 700/160 = 0.4375 USD. Most of us will dream of that type of average.

Key_Master

6:00 am on Feb 23, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Actually, that would be 160/700 or roughly .23 per click.

moTi

7:03 am on Feb 23, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



ok, i can say that i'm in a very similar situation as the op. a little abstract of how things were going so far:
adsense member since two years, in the second year largely steady comparable traffic and stats, with one exception: highest earnings occured back in summer 05. epc taking a 50% dive since autumn 05.

well, too tired to list the whole spectrum, but over the last couple of months i tried nearly ALL of the tricks, gimmicks and strategies to recover earnings focusing on epc and ctr that came into my mind or that were recommended by forum users (often contradictory but thank you anyway).

completely to no avail.

I suspect its an advertiser/competition/traffic/bidding/seasonal/search engine issue.

couldn't have said it better :) i'm tired of experimenting for the worse. in addition, it is totally unclear, when expected changes come to effect. don't try to tell me that if you do changes today, epc effect rolls out tommorow or within a week. i don't believe this anymore. also, i have learnt to not blame smartpricing anymore. it's absurd. i now realize that - apart from usual site optimization - i'm overwhelmingly dependant on exogenous factors. my conclusion: it's very hard but i try not to bother.

approch of explanation:
- advertisers now understand the system and are lowbidding more aggresively
- explosive increase in ad space in consequence of the adsense boom
- seasonal fluctuations

although i thought my site topic was rather not season dependant, i'm starting to see evidence for the latter point. i'm experiencing the same epc dilemma as exactly one year ago. if things go in the right direction i have to bear up a dry period till the start of summer to see earnings rise again. in the meantime all i can do is to take care of my unique content and hope for the best. and wait for adsense competitors to enter european market so that i can switch and rotate. yeah, definitely something to look forward to..

unreviewed

8:46 am on Feb 23, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Key_Master, thank you. I put the cart before the horse.

Aircut

12:25 am on Feb 24, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



160 per day with that amount of clicks is nothing to complain about

first, i was not complaining, i was pointing a trend that lower my earning in 20%. my averages was 200-250/day with same traffic, traffic sources and ads layout. and now its only 160$day

and i repeat, i believe google is delivering less targeted ads which lower the interest for the user to explore them..... other possibility is that my site was hit by site targeting. any other thoughts?

elfred

10:44 am on Feb 24, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Aircut, my experience is that, starting from october, 17th, my AdSense daily earnings suddenly stumbled. I predicted I would have ended earning about 20% in a few months and now... I'm earning about 15% of the original amount. It was quite a nice earning. Before the drop. Everything is statistically relevant and Google is trying to help me. Now I have access to advanced features, but they don't seem to help. Basically, I think that previous ad targeting was based on multi-word keywords, but that now it is based on what AdSense calls "broad" targeting. An example: if your site talks about "car polish", you might end up with ads talking about "polish". I think this is a derivative of AdLinks implementation.

Aircut

2:33 pm on Feb 24, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



well...my site is craft authoritative site. THE site in its niche if i may say so. it talks all about making widgets.

ads are showing are about non profit radios and military schools. common. i have seen better google performances!

europeforvisitors

2:43 pm on Feb 24, 2006 (gmt 0)



my experience is that, starting from october, 17th, my AdSense daily earnings suddenly stumbled. I predicted I would have ended earning about 20% in a few months and now... I'm earning about 15% of the original amount.

It would be better to compare year-to-year statistics for the same time period. On my site, there have been double-digit percentage increases in CPC, eCPM, and total revenues for Jan 1-Feb 23, 2006 compared to the same period last year.

elfred

5:46 pm on Feb 25, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



It would be better to compare year-to-year statistics for the same time period. On my site, there have been double-digit percentage increases in CPC, eCPM, and total revenues for Jan 1-Feb 23, 2006 compared to the same period last year.

EFV, I can assure you that I can create good reports and properly extract statistically significant data. I'm quite a good engineer at data mining. I'm happy for your success and the same thing happened to me last year, but now there is little I can do. The AdSense consultant that is helping me told me that my website is "really interesting, well done and with original content". If AdSense actively helped me, I guess it is partly due to interesting and consistent statistical analysis I presented when the problem arose.

europeforvisitors

6:43 pm on Feb 25, 2006 (gmt 0)



Elfred, I wasn't questioning your competence.

BTW, you may have hit on something with the statement:

Basically, I think that previous ad targeting was based on multi-word keywords, but that now it is based on what AdSense calls "broad" targeting. An example: if your site talks about "car polish", you might end up with ads talking about "polish"

I pulled the AdSense code from my root directory after I got tired of seeing ads for San Diego tourism, New York hotels, etc. on the home page of my European travel-planning site. Maybe Google knows something I don't, and CPC ads for San Diego or New York perform better than more accurately-targeted ads do. But I'm skeptical--at least until AdSense switches its standard pricing and revenue-sharing scheme from CPC to CPM.

Aircut

12:19 am on Feb 26, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I could not stand it anymore, so i have contacted google. got a canned email at first with an apology, and than a second email that they have tuned {?} the targeting to my site. {kill me if i understand}

the next day the ecpm was the worst in 2 years, and today it is catching again.

lets see, and thanks google for bothering with my case

danimal

12:29 am on Feb 26, 2006 (gmt 0)



i had to have adsense support do the same thing on several pages... the html and text wasn't the problem, because it was very similar in structure to most of the other pages, but the ad targeting wasn't even close.

right after they tweaked it on their end, the adsense was right on target... it's as if the targeting sets a site-wide default, instead of being page-specific, like it should be.