Forum Moderators: buckworks & skibum

Message Too Old, No Replies

What happened to near-automatic approval?

Ads seem to be taking longer and longer before going live...

         

mthomas

8:46 pm on Jun 25, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I'm on 24 hours now since setting up two ads and they're not showing yet. The ad diagnostic tool didn't display any reasons for my ads not showing.

This actually happened last time, only.. it was 4 hours before my ads went live.

24 is a bit too long of a wait. Do ads only get approved/go live on weekdays now?

sailorjwd

9:52 pm on Jun 25, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



It appears I'm having similar problem...

I made the mistake of changing my display urls friday afternoon (added www.). Nearly all traffic stopped immediately and hasn't return.

mthomas

10:45 pm on Jun 25, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I was wondering if this might be happening because I have a few adwords campaigns running that aren't getting many clickthroughs.

I did hear from someone before that your account "slows down" when your CTR is low, but I'm not sure if it's true or not.

patient2all

11:51 pm on Jun 25, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I just changed an ad text now (Saturday evening). It had to be done. New ad was showing within 3 minutes on Google.

Of course, there is no chance of a weekend change showing on either partner or content sites until at the very least Monday. Reviews only happen during business hours, oddly enough. You'd think with Google's size and profits they could run 24/7, look at all the jobs they could create.

Mr Thomas,

If your ad text or any of your keywords fell into the sensitive category, they will have to be reviewed by a human. Many, many words are sensitive. Words like children, combat, war and many more obvious ones will keep your ad from showing until it is approved manually. The ads diagnostic tool will show "You have no ads that match the search term ..." for each keyword if an ad is not approved.

Sailor,

Perhaps your traffic tends to come from the Search network (mine does) and again, changes made to an ad must be reviewed by a human before they'll again show on Search or Content. Until then they'll only show on Google.com itself (unless they're "sensitive" in which case they're out of the game completely).

patient2all

mthomas

6:51 pm on Jun 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Thanks for the info patient2all.. in my case though, I didn't choose to have my ads show up in the content network, just for the main google search.

It's now been close to 2 days and the ads aren't showing up. None of the keywords can be considered sensitive, as it's the name of a product.

Time for *another* email :(

sailorjwd

9:25 pm on Jun 26, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



patient2all,

Thanks for the info.

It isn't too much of a mystery. They simply stopped my ads showing on everything but Google search (and it appears ask.com). So, I'm left with about 8% of normal visitors. But it is almost unbelievable that my account goes down for likely 4 days because of this...That is a lot of K$ for me and G to lose.

A side note: I'm noticing visitors from G search ads have a 30% less CTR compared to visitors from everywhere, including content. Too bad I can't exclude G search only.

mark1111

9:25 am on Jun 27, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



How are you separating the stats? Using the figures in the ad group or a tracking system? (You know the former is for all search, including their partners.)

running scared

3:22 pm on Jun 28, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



If it is a product it might be a trade mark issue. You can get some keywords through and the ad group looks entirely normal but the ads do not show because the keyword has been registered with Google as a trade mark. The ad diagnostic tool does not pick it up in this case.

Thsi can happen to ad groups that had been running previously without problem.

You may or may not pass the review...

Merchantprince

2:42 pm on Jul 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I wanted to add to this thread after discovering yesterday that my new campaign wasn't yet active. I set up a 4th of July Sale for this weekend, but it's been 24 hours now with no traffic to the ad.

I did file for an exception for the all-caps acronym "HDTV", but I've filed (and been approved almost immediately) for those kinds of exceptions before.

I've been an advertiser for over 4 years on Adwords and never saw anything like this delay before. But it's also been weeks since I last put up any new ads, so is this new?

patient2all

9:47 pm on Jul 4, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I hope it's now new or some kind of change in policy!

In any case, I put up/changed ads the middle of last week, (Tuesday June 28th. & Wedsnesday June 29th.). They showed immediately on Google itself and were on the partner network within 24 hours.

One thing everyone should be aware of is the schedule of the ad approval people. Oddly, they work strictly business hours, Monday to Friday (a little Saturday according to AWA). I think, but am not sure, that they operate out of Ireland (can anyone confirm?)

Therefore, if you make a change on Friday, it's going to be Monday or even Tuesday before the ad can be reviewed. It appears they accumulate quite a backlog over the weekend.

The ideal time to make changes to ads appears to be Wednesday and Thursday. They're often approved the same day.

----

BTW, normally your ads will appear on Google.com within minutes of putting them up. Google will take a chance on the unreviewed ad. They all must be seen by someone though before joining the Partner (AOL,Earthlink,etc) network or the Content(adsense,etc) Networks.

If the computer flags your ad or keyword as sensitive, it will show no where until reviewed by a human. I've had a great # of ads flagged as sensitive and I don't know why and you can't tell why either. Even if it went through before, you don't know they aren't always adding words to their 'sensitive' lists. For that matter, perhaps the program that flags sensitive topics works as well as the Keyword Estimation Tool :)

I've also had ads just stop for about 2 weeks, then I'd notice and email them and a few days later they were running again -- no explanation.

----

I think it's a holiday weekend not just in the US, so bar-b-que and don't try to apply pure logic to where none may exist :)

patient2all

Merchantprince

6:54 pm on Jul 7, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



It would appear a great many people on all forums are reporting situations like this. Something is happening at Google and no explanations are being provided to advertisers. And none of it looks good...