Forum Moderators: buckworks & skibum

Message Too Old, No Replies

Cost me $39.80 to make $11.13

Here's what I learned.

         

MrSpeed

4:28 pm on Aug 11, 2003 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Not sure if this belonged here or the Affiliate forum.

I did a little experiment with adwords and Amazon.

I had three adgroups for different products in this campaign. In all cases the keywords were selected and the copy were written to make it very clear this was to purchase an item.

At first I bid high to increase my CTR. The conversions were like clockwork. I thought I was doing ok until I learned I was only making 5%. I thought amazom payed 15% for all items with a direct link. I was wrong. I then lowered my maximum CPC in hopes to bottom feed in position 3-4.

It seems like the conversion ratio dropped the lower my adwords position was.

On one adgroup I was getting a ton of Content-Targeted Ads.
202441 impressions, 288 for a .1% CTR. This adgroup led to at least 2 sales but still not enough to cover the cost.

Has anybody had luck using adowrds with Amazon?

ukstages

10:20 pm on Aug 11, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



using adwords for amazon products is generally not a good idea. at 5%, it's extraordinarily difficult to operate at an acceptable ROI.

even if you sell a $100 product, you're only making $5. at 15% for a direct link for a book (good luck), the odds are still against you.

we use adwords to generate traffic for other products with much higher commissions ... and if they happen to get interested in an amazon product along the way, well, it's just gravy.

wackybrit

12:22 am on Aug 13, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I have seen a book called "Google Cash" which is related to this topic. A friend and I were considering going halves on it. I didn't want to post a new topic on this, because it'd seem like I was a shill for the product. I have looked at the 'official' review and it seems really cheesy, and I have been unable to find a PROPER third party review from someone who isn't an affiliate for it! So.. anyone bought this e-book? Is it any good?

Bobby_Davro

1:23 am on Aug 13, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



If there was actually any money in it, then they wouldn't be telling you about it! They obviously feel that they can make more money by writing the book than they can by using their own advice; that should tell you something ;-)

Just my opinion of course.

hobbnet

1:43 am on Aug 13, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I mean, there must be some books out there that have a low enough CPC that would create a profitable ROI. But as stated above, once anyone finds any of these books they would be stupid to share with people what books these were as it would ruin their profitability.

Of course, I have never tried this before so I could be full of it. :)

aroach

6:08 am on Aug 15, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I too made the mistake of buying AdWords for Amazon products. It was a total bust on books but I did find one little niche product that is paying off nicely now that they raised the commission rate on Home and Garden. Frankly I don't expect this to last since I'm only paying a nickel a click.

werty

6:55 am on Aug 15, 2003 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



*raises eyebrows* home and garden you say?

I have not used adwords with amazon yet. I have used them for other affiliate programs and my media spend is around 250, my CJ balance is at 384. So that is not so bad.

Things I did learn: I have compiled a massive list of search phrases that are used to find my niche product. I have found out actual impressions as well as CTR on google for these phrases. I have learned that I need to make a site dedicated to these sweet widgets and get normal SE results instead of PPC.

If I was to end my campaign today I would have made around 130 dollars total. With all the work I put into it, it probably averages about $2.25 an hour. My list of new keywords and understanding for what people are searching for is worth so much more than that.

The last few days no one has purchased anything so I see my profit dwindle away. To me it feels like I am gambling and winning...I know if I let this campaign play out for another day someone will make a big purchase and will hit the jackpot...

Maybe I have a PPC problem?

Equiano

9:22 am on Aug 15, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



It can be done. It may require targeting items other than books and identifying items that generate a high conversion ratio

if you can acheive the below you're on your way

Cost Per Click $0.05
Average number of clicks to sell one item : 10
Cost of sale $.50
Cost of item $50
Amazon commission (5%) - 2.50
Gross Profit $2.00

It then becomes a volume game to make real money.

It can be done and some items have a much higher conversion rate, remember Amazon sells a huge range of items.

The good thing about Amazon in my opinion is it converts well, the bad thing is the length of the cookies validity.

Dave_Hawley

10:59 am on Aug 15, 2003 (gmt 0)



I sell Amazon books from our site but would never consider using Adwords to try and sell them. The only way would be to spell out in the ad that the there is nothing for free. Something like "BUY from us is ascociation with Amazon". Then your CTR would drop and Google would disable your ad.

Amazon are very good at ensuring you rarely get 15%. All the user has to do is click anyone of the other 100 or so links on the page and you drop to 5%.

They have a load of rubbish on their site saying things like "add a shopping cart feature and make more". What they don't tell you is, ANYTHING added to a shopping cart is 5%

They are good for some beer money but little else :o)

Dave

BriGuy

11:05 am on Aug 15, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I actually have been able to turn a profit on this sort of thing, though only after a month or so of grossly overpaying for keywords.

I pretty much make most of my money selling the items capped at $10 per referal. There's enough interest on many of the items that it's become profitable for me. I DO sell books, but mainly as a means to increase my unit totals to qualify for higher tier levels. I don't really think that books in and of themselves can be tremendously profitable.

You may want to consider niche DVDs (especially expensive box sets) too. They still pay the same 5%, but you may be able to squeeze a bit more profit out of them as I have been able to do.

As for the 15%: It's kind of a shell game with Amazon. People have to buy the book DIRECTLY from the page for you to get credit for the sale, and the book must be 15 to 30% off. I've seen Amazon adjust the rates back and forth for bestsellers, with most going for 40%. As a result, I've gotten only a handful of 15% sales from books. IMHO, its not worth the trouble.

talk4

11:23 am on Aug 15, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



You do also have to consider your cashflow in the equation. When you find a merchant and/or product that does turn you in a profit (yes they do exist) it helps if they are with a network like CJ paying monthly in arrears rather than paying quarterly in arrears like Amazon.

illudium

4:28 pm on Aug 15, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



i'll just say that I do adwords & amazon and do quite well. with some luck i can leave my "real" job and just concentrate on the adword buys.

thing with amazon is that there are the obvious choices and the ones you have to dig for. the obvious ones are already adword'd to death so you'll only lose money. its finding the not so obvious ones. :)