Forum Moderators: IanTurner & engine

Message Too Old, No Replies

Site based in UK, but not in yahoo.co.uk!

My site shows in yahoo.com but not .co.uk help!

         

Googly

2:02 pm on Dec 16, 2002 (gmt 0)



My website is hosted in the UK. Our domain is a .com. We are a UK site. We also have a number of .co.uk domains at our disposal, but none of these can be found pointing to our website from the web.

I have noticed that all results in the search yahoo UK only SERPs are all .co.uk

Is it a prerequisite that your domain has a .co.uk to show up in these uk only SERPs?

If it is, does anyone think that a .co.uk name, which we already have, can be used by letting Google follow it to our site? Will this work? Or does anyone have any other ideas?

ps google.co.uk UK pages only- likes us

Cheers
Googly

4eyes

2:48 pm on Dec 16, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Is it a prerequisite that your domain has a .co.uk to show up in these uk only SERPs?

I have .coms showing OK.

Does your .com have a Yahoo listing or are you are referring to the 'web pages' results which come from Google.

Is your .com just 'not in' or is it appearing but just ranked in the depths of the SERP?

Googly

3:09 pm on Dec 16, 2002 (gmt 0)



Sorry I should have been more clear really. But this is quite difficult to analyse without the actual example.

We do not have a yahoo listing, it seems .coms are allowed if they have a listing, which is not surprising. Also none of the competing results have yahoo listings.

I get to the results page by first typing *ww.yahoo.co.uk - selecting UK ONLY and then doing the search.

These are the web pages results. The .com is just not in, it would definitely be ranked well if it was. For instance in is in ww.yahoo.co.uk when you do a All Sites search.

We can't afford a yahoo listing. Just thought I'd make that clear.

makemetop

4:12 pm on Dec 16, 2002 (gmt 0)



Yahoo UK and AOL UK do a domain filter if sites from the UK are selected and the results come from Google. As far as they are concerned - a .com in Google is not a UK site - it is an international site.

Sort of makes sense if you think about it.

4eyes

4:30 pm on Dec 16, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



MMT is right (apart from the 'makes sense' bit:))

Whilst happy to accept .coms in UK directory categories, strangely Yahoo do not accept Google's idea of what constitutes 'UK' when it comes to the Yahoogle bit.

They take the Google UK results then dump all the .coms and 'foreign' domains.

Seems you just got to be a little bit more UK to get into the Yahoogle results.

Tony_Perry

6:14 pm on Dec 16, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



MakeMeTop is right. Invest in a .co.uk domain and that will fix the problem.
Tony Perry

Googly

9:29 am on Dec 17, 2002 (gmt 0)



Okay cheers.

We have a few .co.uk domain names. However our only fixed domain name is a .com, which is with our web host. Our .co.uks use frame pointing to our website homepage from 123-reg (domain name company), we use these to put on our printed stationary.

(For example *ww.btconnect.co.uk (pointing) and *ww.btopenworld.com (fixed))

The only domain name on the web (e.g. links in directories) is our .com . So what kind of effect would putting a link using our pointing domain name (.co.uk) on the web have, so that the googlebot can spider it?

My view is that this probably won't make a difference and that the .co.uk would have to be a fixed domain name. Or if the .co.uk was recognised then only our homepage would enter the serach results on yahoo.co.uk. Anyone have any thoughts on this?

Googly

markd

12:39 pm on Dec 17, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Even with a .co.uk, don't you then run into the good old 'mirror site' problem?

4eyes

2:32 pm on Dec 17, 2002 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



If the .co.uk is using framed redirecting then spidering won't help. It will just associate your .co.uk domain with the frameset, not the visible content.

To guarantee a result you would need to have the .co.uk hosted in its own right. Of course, then you would run into the duplicate content problem.

I'd host the .co.uk in its own right and create a robots.txt exclusion for Googlebot on the .com.

You would then need to get any incoming links for the .com changed to .the .co.uk.

running scared

3:06 pm on Dec 20, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Does anybody have a feel for what proportion of Yahoo users would actually select the "UK only" results? My gut feeling is that unless you are heavily reliant on a UK audience, it will not make a huge difference to the number of referrals. Fine to add this consideraton to choosing a domain for a new site but is it worth losing sleep over for established sites? Running parallel sites seems to be highly problematic.

Interesting to see that .net sites also get filtered so I imagine that any domains without a .uk in it gets dropped. I have to agree with 4eyes about domain filtering not making sense.

running scared

3:24 pm on Dec 20, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



st read this recent thread about no of people using Google's UK only filter. [webmasterworld.com...] Seams to be quite a lot so therefore is worth worrying about.

Also just re-read 4eyes suggestion of hosting the .co.uk ste in its own right and adding the exclusion in the .com So now realise that yuo weren't talking about parallel sites. Also had the Christmas party last night.

Why would you not just permanently redirect from the .com to the .co.uk?

cabman

4:35 pm on Dec 20, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



We have the same problem, .com hosted in UK, invisible on Yahoogle UK only search.
Ours is a paid Yahoo listing too.
However our PPC listing via espotting is still there.
Seems easier to increase keywords on espotting rather than change everything to .co.uk domain.
Could I have stumbled on the real reason for the exlusion? Or is that just too cynical?

makemetop

12:42 pm on Dec 23, 2002 (gmt 0)



>Or is that just too cynical?

Way too cynical. There is nothing new about filtering out .com domains. Most UK versions of SEs have given a UK sites option which has done that for years. We've always used the 4eyes method for client sites to overcome the problem. Google UK was the first SE I've seen trying to identify location by hosting IP or domain as opposed to just domain.

Googly

3:02 pm on Jan 8, 2003 (gmt 0)



Okay, sorry that I haven't added to this post recently, but I am now back after having extensive log-in problems, which surprise surprise seemed to be my fault. I'm about to give you an update on my yahoo vs .co.uk saga.

So I realised that it wasn't going to make sense to get a yahoo.co.uk paid listing if I could get my website in the yahoo.co.uk index via a cheaper option, namely Google. So I had a website with a fixed .com domain name, which wasn't getting into the uk website search in yahoo.co.uk.

The only .co.uk domains for the website were not fixed (they were just pointers) and so once I had typed in the ww. mywebsite.co.uk it would find my website and revert to ww. mywebsite.com. During some experimentation I found that it was possible to get a page into the uk search yahoo.co.uk index if the page was pointed to by a .co.uk. I only have one link on the internet to this website (as I am still experimenting) and this link is on another site I own. The link was ww. mywebsite.com before this saga, but before Christmas I changed it to ww. mywebsite.co.uk.

Obviously this would only put the one page into the index and all links from that page were .coms, so no other pages would be 'turned' into .co.uks. Hope you understand this.

The reason that I'm using these pointing .co.uks rather than a fixed .co.uk is to do with money and a lack of foresight. I didn't see this coming and so we did not buy a fixed .co.uk domain name. This may be a better solution for the future.

So now onto the issue of duplicate pages. If the .com was already in the index and along comes a .co.uk, how is this handled. Well I have just looked in Google.com and both the .com page and the .co.uk page are in. In Google, I suppose expectededly, the older page is given a higher ranking. But what will happen in search uk sites in yahoo.co.uk?

Well, as we already know, the ww. mywebsite.com url
is completely ignored, but the ww. mywebsite.co.uk url is recognised and gets in! Result! What's more, it comes in at number one for my main keywords.

The changes on the aforementioned website which made this happen only took place before Christmas, so the lovely Freshbot was kind to me and has made this happen.

Obviously anything can happen in the next couple of updates, and this approach may not hold ground in the future. The ideal solution I think would be to get a fixed .co.uk domain name, but for now....here's hoping.

Googly

JudgeJeffries

7:28 pm on Jan 9, 2003 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Just to add a little more to this discussion, I posted similar questions on the Yahoo and Google forums regarding my dot.info site which disappeared from Yahoo regional listings and the clear concensus was to dump the dot.info register a dot.co.uk and permanently redirect the dot.info to the dot.co.uk.
I was more than a little irritated to find that I needed to pay another £200 to Yahoo to get a timely inclusion of the new site having paid £200 for the old site only a couple of months ago.
To make matters worse I was also advised to change to UK hosting!

tigermanz

7:09 am on Jan 17, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Here are the big questions:

1. Did you state in your first £200 application that you wanted a listing in an additional category?

Did you give your 1 category as a Main Yahoo.com listing? and then your second as a regional UK category?

Here is the answer.

Contact Yahoo! London and ask for URL support and tell the guy that answers your web site address and what the problem is.
He will probably get you listed in the Yahoo.co.uk directory.

It takes a few days, as they updaet the Yahoo UK directory on a Tuesday and a Thursday.

If you are selling hardcore adult entertainment or anything illegal in the UK,you dont have a chance.

It looks as if Yahoo.co.uk are Beta Testing the same system that was being used in the Yahoo.Com site before Christmas, the whole directory is now not worth submitting to at the moment as the main results being displayed are from the web (Google).

I hope this helps.