Forum Moderators: not2easy

Message Too Old, No Replies

Meanings of name or dictionary sites

Are the databases they use free domain?

         

jleane

5:44 pm on Dec 26, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Has anyone been to one of those sites where you put your name in and it returns its meaning and origin? Or to an online dictionary or famous quotation site? Would the databases they use be public domain? Before you jump the gun, I'm not planning on stealing databases, I'm just wondering if information of this nature is 'free for everyone'.

Does it vary on a case by case basis? For example meanings and origins of names would be free domain since they are a matter of history/fact whereas dictionary definitions would be the property of the company that published it (eg websters).

Or am I way off?

4crests

6:46 pm on Dec 26, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



The meaning / origin of names may be a matter of history/fact. However, the way the history is worded or typed up is copyright protected.

For example, the meaning of the surnmae
Smith = A Blacksmith,
obviously that wouldn't be copyrighted.

But, if a website typed up their own elaborate 2 page history of the name Smith, and put it all into their own wording, then yes, this would be copyright protected. And, the copyright doesn't necessarily have to be documented. It is considered copyrighted from the moment the first person created the body of text.

Matt Probert

5:55 pm on Jan 10, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



As a publisher of such a site, I have encountered just this issue...

As 4crests said, the way the data is written can be copyright.

Very short information, such as "Brighton is a town in Sussex" or "Wheelbarrow is dominoe slang for the 2-1 card" are not copyright. However, dictionary definitions may be, and to be safe one should paraphrase wherever possible.

So for example, where the OED defines paraphrase as:

"An expression in other words, usually fuller and clearer, of the sense of a written or spoken passage or text; a free rendering. Also, the use of these as a mode of literary treatment." this definition is clearly copyright, and you should not copy it but rewrite it perhaps (as an example) like:

"Paraphrase means to rewrite in your own words."

Matt