Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from 54.160.163.163

Message Too Old, No Replies

Google PR Update - some unexpectedly high/low PR is being reported

     

Aimee

3:39 am on Apr 5, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Just to see my site has a PR 7 now, yesterday is only 2.

PR update start?

Aimee

12:59 am on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



happy, still has PR 7 today ;-)

But this morning I find a old site's PR get down, from 8 to 7.

ronburk

3:29 am on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Well, that's kinda weird. My largest PR has been 4 for some time. Now that's still true -- except for a single interior page that's only a few weeks old, which is now PR5.

Theory 1: Update isn't complete, and home page will soon move to PR 5 (sounds like wishful thinking to me).

Theory 2: There's a bunch of external inbound links to my new PR5 that I can't locate anywhere (but Googlebot did). Seems a little suspicious that such a new page could have spontaneously gotten more IBL than the 2-year old home page. Not impossible, but I'm dubious.

Theory 3: Oddly enough, the new page was designed specifically to attract bookmarks. It has frequently updated price information, and is the only page on the site that says "bookmark me to stay uptodate" and provides a little JavaScript to make bookmarking as easy as clicking. Maybe a fair number of people did bookmark it and (put tinfoil hat on here) Google is somehow able to track browser bookmarks and count them in PR calculations. OK, I shouldn't even have mentioned that theory, since too many WebmasterWorld members are wearing their tinfoil hats full time already :-)

bobmark

3:38 am on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



ronburk, its possible to have an internal page with a higher PR than the index page IF links in are that good.

This tends to get swamped in large sites by the usually greater links to the site itself and not show up but I once linked into a page on a low PR site with very few inbounds from an internal page on one of my sites and that site's PR (the one I linked to) on that page suddenly was higher than anything else on the site.

On most dc's I look at, link results have reverted to old data, not the FEB-15 links. Wonder if, like the "real PR" / toolbar PR" there is an up-to-date "real links" index that doesn't show up on a link:www.widgets.com search.

ronburk

4:46 am on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



ronburk, its possible to have an internal page with a higher PR than the index page IF links in are that good.

Good point. So a better theory is: somebody gave me a single, pretty nice inbound link to that internal page, and I just can't find it yet (can't be more than a few weeks old, so that may make it harder to find).

Still... I just hand-scanned every hit for that page in the logs (not much traffic, only been around a month, so not hard to do) and can't find a single hit with a "real" referrer field from a website. Seems a little odd that I would pick up a link from a good PR page, but that page generates virtually no traffic.

Still..., could be somebody's personal links page that has real good PR, nobody but the owner clicks on it, and the owner uses a browser that masks the Referer field.

Sure does have me curious now :-).

MrRoy

7:07 am on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



All my internal pages PR gone. Only the home page is having a PR of 7. dunno watz exactly is going on.
I have introduced 301 in my website a month ago. But then the url's which was launched few months back was having a high PR. Those url's PR is also gone.
dunno how to react to the present situation.....

ariane

8:13 am on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member



I see changes in SERPS today as well ,some "authorities" have lost top 1 placement after 3 years in very expensive KW's. in travel and hotel categories.

lasko

9:53 am on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



All my internal pages PR gone. Only the home page is having a PR of 7. dunno watz exactly is going on.
I have introduced 301 in my website a month ago. But then the url's which was launched few months back was having a high PR. Those url's PR is also gone.
dunno how to react to the present situation.....

Do nothing at the moment.

Its happened to us as well many different web sites.

We've seen strange things happen like this before in the last couple of years.

Whilst an update is in progress best just to enjoy other things in life a wait for it to end.

For sure Google is doing something different this time round so I guess we'll see many strange reports.

annej

4:15 pm on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member annej is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member



Whilst an update is in progress best just to enjoy other things in life a wait for it to end.

Excellent advice! Now if I can just make my self follow it.

au_sammy

4:24 pm on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Nothing new here, just adding to the 'data' on the latest strangest PR update.

A domain that I own, has been online for two years, has NO inbound links, has NOT been updated whatsoever for those two years, now suddenly has PR4 (was and always has been PR1).

Very strange indeed....

Bigdream

5:51 pm on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Hi Frndz,

Since last few days my site's home page Pr was toggling between Pr 0 and Pr 2. At this time all the inner pages were with Pr 0. Now in last month home page has got a stable pr 2 and all the inner pages are with pr 3. So its definitely a change in Pr going on.

Also I wud like to ask one question. I have heard that inner pages pass the pr back to home page. So when inner pages are passing pr back to home page will it make a difference if i use www.mydomain.com/index.html and not www.mydomain.com to link back to home page.
Shud these be considered as two different pages due to which my home page's pr is 2 and not 4 which it should be ideally. As home page shud have mor epr then inner page.

I look forward to hearing from you. Any information, suggestion are most welcome.

Thanks,
bigdream

300m

7:52 pm on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member



I am confused with this PR update. I have a site that has had content pages added to it between december and february. All inner pages are getting a PR4, but the home page is a PR3. Even stranger, I also included a blog on this site and it has had the largest PR jump on a blog I have done to date. PR0 to a PR6. That does not sound right to me at all.

PlanetTokyo

9:22 pm on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Same here. I have a new domain that is barely three months old and it's now a PR 6.

While I'd like to be optimistic about this, I'm of the opinion that this is either an error, or there's been some fundamental change in the calculation of PR.

soapystar

9:36 pm on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



right..id say the new pr scores are now out of 20...not 10...

Blueshadow

10:19 pm on Apr 7, 2006 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member



ever since Big Daddy started the whole google search is a big mess and it's not getting any better. I hope google can fix everything soon.

annej

1:01 am on Apr 8, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member annej is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member



BigDream, If you are using www.mydomain.com don't throw in the index version You want to be consistant throughout your site or Google will decide each is a different page and you will lose PR and may have dup problems.

Liane

4:26 am on Apr 8, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Same here. I have a new domain that is barely three months old and it's now a PR 6.

For quite some time, Google has given new sites (which have made it past all the filters) a nice boost in rankings for a few days. I think its their way of announcing a new site has hit the block.

Its a nice feature and one which I think is deserving of many thanks for some of us webmasters who may want to link to these new sites.

Perhaps ... just perhaps Google gives all new sites which get past all the filters an automatic PR6 for a few days. It makes sense now that I think about it. New sites (which meet all Google guidelines) get a brief boost in rankings which allows them to be found by those webmasters paying attention. If they are good enough, perhaps ... just perhaps we will deem them worthy of a link?

I think this is just Google's way of identifying new sites and shoving them to the forefront for a few days to get the attention all newbies rightly deserve. If they are worth linking to, we will (or should) link. If not, we won't. If this is Google's point, I think it is brilliant! I just wish Google would confirm or deny their intentions one way or the other so that webmasters could know for sure that this really IS the point!

C'mon Matt ... jump in here and confirm or deny. I would put money on my theory, but I know hundreds will shoot me down. Its about time Google spells things out a little more clearly for some of us who may be a little slow on the uptake ... don't cha think?

I am tired. I am a yacht charter broker who builds her own pages. I have to admit that I do enjoy the diversion of building my own web pages ....... but it is not what I do for a living!

There are many of us out here who are just trying to produce the best websites we are capable of. A well written, clear and concise set of rules from each of the search engines would be greatly appreciated.

steveb

5:48 am on Apr 8, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member steveb is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member



PR has nothing to do with age. Saying a three month old site has a PR6 is like saying a Mercedes is painted grey.

rkhare

2:53 pm on Apr 8, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



from the matt cutts blog
Looks like by the end of the weekend, the density will be going back down though. Very strange.

does it mean anything, the bloated PR going to settle by weekend?

or its just a casual remark in happy mood after a mc happy meal

walkman

2:57 pm on Apr 8, 2006 (gmt 0)



>> does it mean anything, the bloated PR going to settle by weekend?

change of the algo probably to target certain types of spam.

Eazygoin

3:02 pm on Apr 8, 2006 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member



Sorry RK, but you have to take it in context. It was a bit of fun about the density of spam in the San Diego area :-)

daneosporin

4:20 pm on Apr 8, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Google is somehow able to track browser bookmarks and count them in PR calculations

I consider this a fact. My brother has a site which has a random page with funny videos. This page wasn't optimized in any way and a few months ago all of the sudden became PR 7. The page hasn't gotten any incoming links naturally either so this must have been caused by people bookmarking the page.

Check Google's search engine patent from a few years ago too. There's a few items about the toolbar tracking what people do.

ZoltanTheBold

11:38 pm on Apr 8, 2006 (gmt 0)

5+ Year Member



Could Google Analytics be a factor? It has been around just long enough for it to perhaps be considered? Seems more realistic to see Google using actual data they have on traffic than data we think they might have about bookmarks.

Alternatively what about a combination of the two? A site that gets traffic from "nowhere" could be considered more valuable than one that always gets traffic from predictable sources like search engines (in the sense that it is potentially worth more because someone bothered to bookmark it). After all what better vote can you have than many individuals deciding a site is valuable enough to bookmark? Given the ability to track IP addresses this might be harder to fake as well.

Then again, given how dire Google are at solving relatively simple problems I'm not sure I'd credit them with the sophistication to do any of this.

rkhare

1:09 pm on Apr 9, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Could Google Analytics be a factor? It has been around just long enough for it to perhaps be considered? Seems more realistic to see Google using actual data they have on traffic than data we think they might have about bookmarks.

no way, my recently created link page, without any traffic is now PR4, same as main page, whereas the most frequented page is still PR2

Ams24

3:10 pm on Apr 10, 2006 (gmt 0)



Hi!

It would be interesting to know if those weird PR updates are already impacting in the relevancy (SERPs) of your pages or in the deep indexing; or are they just a couple of green pixels on the toolbar? What was the impact?

Dayo_UK

3:35 pm on Apr 10, 2006 (gmt 0)



It would be interesting to know if those weird PR updates are already impacting in the relevancy (SERPs) of your pages or in the deep indexing; or are they just a couple of green pixels on the toolbar? What was the impact?

Well in the past the TBPR was a historical score which would have already impacted the serps.

I dont think that it would be sensible at this stage, with all the changes going on, to say that past behaviour means that this happened this time around.

For a start an export was done whereby the new calculation did not takeover from the old calculation - it was more of new pages recieved the new calculation of PR while the old PR still remaining for existing pages.

Lorel

4:21 pm on Apr 10, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I set up five new pages around mid March and earlier and they all got PR 5 or 6 with this update--they are all infomation pages of interest to about anyone who has a website. One page is ranking #1, another #5 in Google, with the others much lower.

My home page only has PR 5 and I doubt the new pages have any links other than a few internal links--according to Google they have none.

Several new sites I manage raised in PR on their home page.

One thing I noticed re Supplementals, I had checked all my clients for hijackers over the weekend not realizing there was an update going on and noticed that all the sites where I have been trying to get rid of supplementals are mostly gone. These were usually pages that had been redirected with 301s or set up so they would return a 404 months ago via htaccess.

mattrix

2:59 pm on Apr 10, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Our main site went from a PR6 to a PR1 a few days ago. What is strange is subpages are still PR5 and we still #1 in our rankings (SERP). Traffic has not decreased either.

Anyone know #*$! is going on?

bobmark

5:28 pm on Apr 10, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



mattrix, I can't swear to right now but a few weeks ago toolbar PR went weird - huge drops or PR0 on a lot of sites - and, like you said now, didn't affect SERPs.

I think this relates to an oddity in the toolbar PR as opposed to "real PR" (the PR index Google uses in calculating SERP's which appears to be a lot fresher than the PR shown in the toolbar).

The other time it just went on for many sites for a week-10 days without ever affecting SERP's and then toolbar PR went back to normal.

mattrix

5:51 pm on Apr 10, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Thanks Bob, little bit scary being on a "fake" PR1 - so thats at least somewhat reassuring to know.

stevelibby

10:47 am on Apr 11, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Hi
given the latest pr update, my sites deep pages has lost its pr? home page Pr remains at 4 though, whats happening?
This 167 message thread spans 6 pages: 167