Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from 220.127.116.11
I was initailly thinking usability at first, but I don't want to dilute my page rank by having 50 links to the same domain on my home page.
Any advice would be much appreciated.
[edited by: Bishop at 6:09 am (utc) on Dec. 1, 2005]
Firstly, having 50 links off your home page to another site is not the normal and google will perhaps think you are a doorway page. Think of it this way, if you are saying to visitors "OH, you don't want this page, go here..." fifty times on your home page, then the usefullness of the site is questionable and Google may think why should I bother ever showing it?
However, if you have a few external links to related sites with topics your site doesn't cover, then that could be good.
Apart from that, in simple terms you have a pr allocated to a page, lets say pr5. If you have 10 links off the page, in theory the pr is divided by 10 and given to each link to carry across to the respective page. So if you have 50, you give 1/50th to each page on the other site you mentioned. If you only have one link then you get all the pr going across to that one page. If that one page then distributes the pr to the other 49 pages, in theory the effect is almost the same as 50 links from your other site..... but it isn't....because in my opinion external links are treated differently to links to the same domain and the 49 pages are now two clicks away rather than one.
Plus a whole bunch of other stuff may apply! Google says 100 links is the most they want to see, though they will follow more but the pr flow probably gets too diluted.
Would it make more sense to just have one link to the external domain with each state accessible on the external site verses having the 50 states linked to the external site right on my home page?
Absolutely! If you think this will descrease useability, then make another page on your site that has the 50 links and link to that from the home page. Thus you will not leak so much page rank and risk problems with google.