Forum Moderators: buckworks

Message Too Old, No Replies

Russia and credit card fraud

         

partnermine

9:47 pm on Jul 23, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



We're a dating site, so we sell memberships and no physical goods are shipped, ever. We use paypal at present, and not eligible for their Seller protection Plan, since that appears only to cover the despatch of tangible goods.

Ok, that sets the scene.

Over the past few weeks we have gained a lot of "russian brides", and we assume that some of these mustbe genuine. Equally we know there is a Russian mob bride scam designed to extract cash from lovelorn men globally, but usually in the USA.

One of these brides bought membership of the site (a mere bagatelle, at $12.80) as a fraudulent creditcard transaction. Probably another one has today.

Paypal didn't seem to bother too much about our side of the first one and charged us the chargeback fee for it. We're riding with the second (well it is only $10) to see what happens.

But the question is, "Why would you put through a transaction on a stolen or cloned card that obntains you nothing except membership of a dating site? What is the point?"

We can simply not understand what is in it for the Russians. Any clues, please?

Sanenet

9:56 pm on Jul 23, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Could just be that it's a real member who didn't want to pay the entry fee and trawled the net looking for a false credit card?

partnermine

10:02 pm on Jul 23, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Well yes, it could. But the first fraudster bought 30 days membership when already granted a special offer of free top level membership for 12 months.

Add that to the fact the our fees are pocket money prices, and it seems unlikely

Lord Majestic

10:03 pm on Jul 23, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Perhaps they are doing real-life test of whether credit card will be accepted, and if so they go for major hit on some sexy physical goods e-tailer?

partnermine

10:17 pm on Jul 23, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Now me, I'd do the big hit straight away. Does that make me or them the stupid ones?

We thought the same, but it makes no logical sense.

hfwd

11:47 pm on Jul 23, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



They use the cc for both small & large orders because it's free for them!

You'd be surprised how much fraudulent cc charges from stolen cc are used in convenience stores & gas stations, not just for expensive items.

julesn

11:58 pm on Jul 23, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Perhaps they are doing real-life test of whether credit card will be accepted, and if so they go for major hit on some sexy physical goods e-tailer?

That's our theory too, that in a number of cases the fraudsters are just using our site to test out cards to see if they have been reported stolen and blocked yet etc. They may have used the card a few weeks before hand, and want to see that it will still work on something that wouldn't trigger any alerts.

jules.

partnermine

12:06 am on Jul 24, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



In general, though, the Russian Bride Scam has nothing much to do with credit card fraud. It's like "Separate Departments"

The theory is sound, but these guys are bright crooks and this seems crude.

By the way, what commonalities do yu see between the fraudsters. so far we see "pochta" email addresses. Are there other identifyung characteristics you have found?

partnermine

12:07 am on Jul 24, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



They use the cc for both small & large orders because it's free for them!

You'd be surprised how much fraudulent cc charges from stolen cc are used in convenience stores & gas stations, not just for expensive items.

But the thing is they are getting nothing from us. Just a membership.

hfwd

12:54 am on Jul 24, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



But the thing is they are getting nothing from us. Just a membership.

Which would've cost someone else $10. It's still free for them! Or maybe they're actually looking for love...

partnermine

10:41 am on Jul 24, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Which would've cost someone else $10. It's still free for them! Or maybe they're actually looking for love...

No. They are looking to entrap the lovelorn into sending large sums of money to them as a fraud. And before anyone says "Well, they need to invest in membership" please think it through. They don't need to pay us a cent because they can do what they want free of charge. Equally the one who bought a membership "she" already had was blowing cover in a fraudulent use of a card.

Now, since organised crime tends to be quite intelligent, this seems like the act of a moron.

Using logic, it can't be money laundering, because the sums are trivial and you need to get the cash out again. It can't be to defraud us out of membership because that is, frankly, stupid. It can't be to test the card because a large test that succeeds is better than a small test that succeeds - membership of a dating site is fantastic for those who want that membership, membership by fraud is just ridiculous.

We have theorised all the answers so far as well as any of you have. Does anyone have anything that is not just theory?

partnermine

5:09 pm on Jul 24, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Adding to this the fact that we get charged $10 for each chargeback by PayPal because services that are not tangible are not covered by Seller Protection, and I am seriously thinking of moving away from PayPal.

The challenge, of course, is that other services carry premium set up prices, and may well be as difficult over chargebacks.

How does one recognise a valid transaction? How does one recognise an invalid transaction?