Forum Moderators: open

Message Too Old, No Replies

Replying and # posts shown

revisiting this debate

         

jollymcfats

8:55 pm on Jan 24, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I'd like to re-open the request to expand the number of posts shown when replying. I definitely agree with the aim of keeping replies on topic (as discussed here [webmasterworld.com] and
here [webmasterworld.com], and probably elsewhere).

But in the the forums I participate in (mostly the hands-on coding forums), I often feel that the last post is the topic.

Most technical posts seem to follow a back and forth pattern: An initial question, a follow-up, then back-and-forth between those two posters until a solution is reached; or a similar scenario except several people chime in and a collaborative solution to the problem eventually emerges. In both cases the value of the post is the linear journey the thread takes towards the solution.

That's a fairly long way of getting around to my specific request: show first and last posts when replying, at least in the coding/technical forum categories.

I think the added context would be very useful when crafting follow-ups. I would probably personally answer more posts than I currently do if I didn't have to take the time out to open & switch between multiple tabs to collect the context I feel I need for a quality answer.

And if the posts re-displayed during post preview, that would be even better. I use preview often when formatting code, and it's painful to lose that context. Re-displaying the topic and the _current_ last post would be immensely useful.

tedster

8:22 pm on Jan 25, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I use shift-click when I click on the Reply link - then I have two windows/tabs open and can click back and forth easily to any post in the thread.

In discussion threads, the current "first post only" approach has been a boon for limiting topic drift in the thread. So I use my approach in the technical/coding forums.

Brett_Tabke

9:16 pm on Jan 25, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



> I often feel that the last post is the topic.

There in lies the rub and why those other forums langust. Threads that stay on topic to the original topic, are more enjoyable to a broader audience than threads that wander. Threads that wander became microtopic and interest only a few people.

jollymcfats

10:39 pm on Jan 25, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I certainly agree, and I'm not proposing any changes to those forums. Rather, a per-forum reply style specifically enabled for the coding forums.