Forum Moderators: open

Message Too Old, No Replies

DMOZ - category no longer accurate

Should I leave well enough alone?

         

aroach

5:07 pm on Apr 18, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Since widgets won't work in my case, I'll use tribbles.

When I first opened my site about three years ago I planned for it to be primarily about Tribble Health issues and submiited to that category in DMOZ and was listed there.

As my site has grown and changed the last couple of years I find that I do not have much info on Tribble Health at all but instead have more general information on tribbles. The largest section of my site is now Homeless Tribble Shelters but I also have Tribble Memorials, Tribble Fiction, Tribble Humor, etc., etc.

About a year ago I submitted a change request to DMOZ which was never acted upon. I am thinking of submitting another one but I fear losing my listing altogether because I recently added a shopping section to my site with affiliate links to tribble related products. There are no banners, no pop-ups, no in-your-face hard sell tactics. Just products that should be of interest to people who have tribbles mostly confined to the shopping section of the site.

Am I better served to just stay in the wrong category than to risk being dumped for affiliate links?

Mohamed_E

5:22 pm on Apr 18, 2003 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I view my DMOZ entry entirely as a source of PR, never, ever, having had a referral from it. If that is your case then there is absolutely no point in trying to change the category.

If you view the DMOZ listing as a source of referrals then you have a difficult balancing act, risk assessment or whatever you choose to call it!

aroach

5:53 pm on Apr 18, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



The category I am now listed in is PR5. The more general category I feel I belong in is PR6. Don't know if that in itself is worth the risk.

I also find that I am miscategorized on every little podunk directory on the web that uses DMOZ data. I don't honestly know if that is hurting me or not since no one ever comes from any of these directories.

ettore

11:59 pm on Apr 19, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Having your site listed in the most appropriate category will help users to better find it when searching for that topic. Sure, don't expect referrals from ODP directly, but if your site is miscategorized there will be hundreds of ODP data users who have it in the wrong category.

Also, having your site listed in the most appropriate category, and with an appropriate description of the site's content, will boost the theme relevancy of your site. If your site isn't focused anymore only on Tribble Health issues, you might get a description telling users that they will find there Homeless Tribble Shelters as well as Memorials, Fiction, and Humor.

It's not only a PR thingie.