Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from

Forum Moderators: martinibuster

Message Too Old, No Replies

Link farm or link directory?

this mentioned on another forum



5:31 am on Mar 10, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

this was mentioned in the google news forum. How do you distinguish between a link farm and a link directory? brett said it is when the sole purpose is gaining pr but everyone is doing this now. i am trying to link to sites with similar content to mine or who offer the same services but in a different country and almost every single one wants a reciprocal link. with all those reciprocal links, my page will soon look like a link farm. is there any way to make a distinction between a link farm and a link directory?


5:39 am on Mar 10, 2003 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator brett_tabke is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month

>trying to link to sites with similar content to mine

While not necc wrong, I think the real thing to do is link to sites that have complimentary content to yours. If you sell spoons, you want to link to the forks and knives sites and not to the soup spoon sites.


2:52 pm on Mar 10, 2003 (gmt 0)

How do you distinguish between a link farm and a link directory? - troi21

Darn troi21, I have so much work to do and I see this great question, impossible for me to pass by, thanks ;)

Distinguish or create?

Let me be the first to say there is a lot of ugly linking going on, by whatever name folks want to call it. I do like a good link directory, it makes my job easier for one.

A link directory develops out of planning. It’s obvious there’s been some research, analysis and then a strategy is formed.

Key components I use to differentiate between a link farm and a link directory

a. Is there a structure in place, with separate categories?
b. Do the categories make sense? – see Brett’s comment
c. Are the listings presented in a uniform manner? – title/description about the same length like you’d see in ODP or Yahoo.
d. Are there a reasonable amount of listings per page? – 10-25 as opposed to hundreds.
e. Does the directory stand alone or is it and extension to the site offered as a resource?
f. If it stands alone are the links balanced by content?

Other things I really like to see in a directory include:

A linking policy stated.
A method posted for communication.
A bit of text content telling me why the category is there.
Static links with no redirects, frames, or tricks of any kind.
Not polluted with banners or more affiliate links than link partners, ugh.
A link direct from the homepage.
Not every link going out has a return link coming in, not totally a reciprocal directory.

Now, I have seen some cleverly designed link farms, some better than other and they exist quite well and I believe fit a necessary purpose to move information around. Kind of like bottom feeders that clean up the waste in a pond, ugly but needed. I mean are you going to run home in glee because you caught a bottom feeder, probably not. I think the same holds true about link farms. You may get in one but it’s not something to ring the bells about.


5:25 pm on Mar 10, 2003 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member

but can google differentiate between the two?

Featured Threads

Hot Threads This Week

Hot Threads This Month