Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from 18.104.22.168
Forum Moderators: rogerd
So I'm considering two solutions and I'd like to see what you guys think and hopefully you can add a few more suggestions.
1. Creating a reply button on each post that says something like Reply with Reference. This creates a link at the top of their new post that goes to the post they are referencing. I need to think harder about the name of the button though.
2. Allowing a Reply with Quote button, but setting a limit on the characters you can quote. Of course when setting a limit, you have to be careful, because there may be a legitimate reason for needing to go above that limit.
I'm thinking about doing a combination of both and setting the limit pretty high. I will still have bbcode quotes as well. Any further suggestions or thoughts?
From a community standpoint, quoting seems to be a way for an irritating member to compound the irritation by dissecting other members posts.
Personally, I often use Control C to grab a few words, and stick 'em right in the post. No BB code, and less temptation to quote the entire post. E.g.,
>>not to mention that it's an extra bandwidth hog<<
Readability of the thread suffers, too. I have no problem with putting the onus of identifying the post on the member creating the reply. If someone is going to reply "That's a great idea" to a comment from six posts ago, he needs to either say, "GoofyOne, that's a great idea!" or include a couple words to specify the reference.
I posit this theory: It becomes a 'forum habit' or standard. Kill it early. Kill it often.
Maybe have a list of 10 suggested ways a person can do the same thing without bulk quoting?
I could put at the buttom of every post a "Reply to this Post" button. Then in the response, I would put a "This post is in response to post #x by ThatGuy" link at the top or bottom of the post.
Sometimes I have a little trouble figuring out who's talking to whom, but this forum is much better than most linear forums. Members are much more attuned to how this thing works. I'm fine with leaving it alone.
>> Then in the response, I would put a "This post is in response to post #x by ThatGuy" link at the top or bottom of the post. <<
This idea would drive me crazy, linking back and forth, and opening browser windows. I hope you don't implement this one.