Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from 50.19.156.133

Forum Moderators: open

Message Too Old, No Replies

Summarizing our hopes, fears, and concerns succinctly

Let's try the One Line Gmail Brainstorming Game!

     

ThatAdamGuy

1:39 am on Apr 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



I hope this doesn't run afoul of WW rules, but I thought I'd try something different here. So many of us -- especially yours truly -- have written at length (and I do mean at length) about our Gmail feelings. I thought it might be interesting to force all of us to succinctly list our BIG PICTURE Gmail hopes and fears and rebuttals into one-line bullet points (not little wishlist things, a la "I hope they let us sort in reverse chronological order..."). This may restore some lost civility, and also help us put things in perspective.

THE RULES:
1) Don't address someone else's list (e.g., don't say "Hey, it's not true that..." or "Your fear is stupid because..."). Instead, simply include a broad rebuttal statement if accurate.
2) Don't let ANY one point exceed 80 characters :D
3) You don't have to include stuff in all sections.

Okay... here we go! I'll start with a list of what I understand to be collective hopes and fears, not just what my personal feelings are. You're welcome to do the same.

HOPES:
- Replaces my need for other mail software / services.
- Allows me to save time with all e-mail tasks.
- Lets me find any mail(s) easily and quickly.
- Gmail is released as soon as possible for the public.

FEARS OR CONCERNS:
- Content scanning for profit is unethical.
- Gmail creates slippery slope which other companies may exploit.
- Large data pool per customer encourages snooping (anti-terror, subpoenas, etc.)
- Uncertainty of what happens to data or policies in the future.
- Ads showing next to my newsletters will harm my business.

REBUTTALS:
- Content scanning for profit is no different than spam/virus scanning.
- Ad targeting data is discarded after ad is shown.
- E-mail is insecure by nature anyway; Want privacy? Use encryption.
- Google has been a responsible company in the past.
- ALL terms/policies with services are "subject to change."
- Your ads will show next to others' newsletters; it all balances out.

Your turn :)

born2drv

8:00 am on Apr 17, 2004 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



my additions...

hopes:
- google can effectively eliminate or greatly reduce spam
- google will properly market gmail for what it really is (grand monetization scheme based on your personal content) ;) ... and not just big storage/low spam/searchable email.

fear or concerns:
- ads shown for content I created are monetized without any royalties paid to me
- no way to opt-out for emails sent to gmail users from being archived or monetized
- no control of when email will actually be deleted from google's servers

 

Featured Threads

Hot Threads This Week

Hot Threads This Month